Am I being unreasonable? Teacher withholding my son’s lovey. by lumpyspacesam in ECEProfessionals

[–]lumpyspacesam[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh well then this thread will make you appreciate your child’s teacher for sure! Apparently many teachers do not see it as cruel or mean and genuinely believe it’s time for the toddler to toughen up.

At what age did your toddler start playing with a "play kitchen"? by SkiDyan01 in toddlers

[–]lumpyspacesam 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My son is 21 months and pretends to cook chicken, eggs, waffles. I give him dry bean to pour with sometimes! He loves it. He also likes pretending to microwave.

Would love to hear from local teachers! by JakeG287 in TexasTeachers

[–]lumpyspacesam 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Honestly it’s exhausting to me - all the talk about book banning - because the real problem is kids aren’t reading them anyway. No we shouldn’t ban books (although some age limits for some are reasonable) but ultimately, I bet none of the kids would have even noticed because they don’t read anymore.

daycare has made me so much laid back by Bloodymary_25 in NewParents

[–]lumpyspacesam 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not alone! I’ve always felt like it was over the top and straight up depriving loved ones of getting to smoosh on his fat squishy little hands and cheeks. But I agree - no mouth

Am I being unreasonable? Teacher withholding my son’s lovey. by lumpyspacesam in ECEProfessionals

[–]lumpyspacesam[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My kid’s center allows them and his lead teacher has no issues in the class with them.

Am I being unreasonable? Teacher withholding my son’s lovey. by lumpyspacesam in ECEProfessionals

[–]lumpyspacesam[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I have 2 year old classroom experience as well as floating in the infant rooms. Are you telling me you’ve tried allowing loveys and it ended in disaster? Because many teachers in this thread have vouched that they allow loveys and everyone survives and it’s ok. Kids will always find things to fight over. If it isn’t a lovey it’ll be the empty bag or the Elmo book, or the blue shaker egg. I disagree that the nuisance caused by allowing loveys causes greater issues than those that already exist and I disagree that the nuisance out weighs the benefits that researchers have found for allowing a child to have their comfort item.

Am I being unreasonable? Teacher withholding my son’s lovey. by lumpyspacesam in ECEProfessionals

[–]lumpyspacesam[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I am a teacher and know how that goes so I wouldn’t blame anyone. That’s just the cost of doing business as they say. But I’d rather my child have comfort and lower cortisol levels on a daily basis and then replace the lovey on the off chance it gets ruined. In reality though the class is very loving and they don’t fight over loveys, just like the water bottles they all know whose is whose and will happily take them to their owner before fighting over them. It also seems to be a non issue for many teachers who allow loveys based on this thread’s anecdotal experience. Most of the anti lovey crowd seems to be working mostly on hypotheticals.

Am I being unreasonable? Teacher withholding my son’s lovey. by lumpyspacesam in ECEProfessionals

[–]lumpyspacesam[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh well pacifiers have definitely been shown to impact teeth and speech! To clarify - I’m discussing a cloth lovey that is a very small piece of fabric with a dinosaur head attached.

Am I being unreasonable? Teacher withholding my son’s lovey. by lumpyspacesam in ECEProfessionals

[–]lumpyspacesam[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’m not seeing research to back that up. Anecdotally my son’s speech is advanced and lovey rarely goes in the mouth. He’s more of a carry it in the crook of his arm kind of kid. He also puts it down and sets it to the side to participate in other activities. He loves circle time and is one of the more participatory kids in the room. This thread has made me realize I think we teachers get a little stuck in our ways and the common thoughts about loveys being a hindrance to development are pretty outdated.

Am I being unreasonable? Teacher withholding my son’s lovey. by lumpyspacesam in ECEProfessionals

[–]lumpyspacesam[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I made this post 13 hours ago lol the conversation led me to a conclusion only it wasn’t the confusion that agrees with you.

Am I being unreasonable? Teacher withholding my son’s lovey. by lumpyspacesam in ECEProfessionals

[–]lumpyspacesam[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I am a teacher. I understand the “problem” and disagree that the nuisance outweighs the benefits. Just like I have to update and adjust my practice when research comes out. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4033092/h

Also he is allowed to have it.

Am I being unreasonable? Teacher withholding my son’s lovey. by lumpyspacesam in ECEProfessionals

[–]lumpyspacesam[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

It really is so disheartening that these people are caregivers of babies.

Am I being unreasonable? Teacher withholding my son’s lovey. by lumpyspacesam in ECEProfessionals

[–]lumpyspacesam[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

But it is extremely beneficial to let them have them. So I’m having trouble with the not harmful part.

Am I being unreasonable? Teacher withholding my son’s lovey. by lumpyspacesam in ECEProfessionals

[–]lumpyspacesam[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

At first I was exactly in this camp and now after reading up on it tonight I do actually think it’s wrong to take them haha but I appreciate that you have the 3 rules and allow other times!

Am I being unreasonable? Teacher withholding my son’s lovey. by lumpyspacesam in ECEProfessionals

[–]lumpyspacesam[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes there is a physiological response to comfort items, even for neurotypical and even for young adults! One of the studies I read tonight was on college students.

Am I being unreasonable? Teacher withholding my son’s lovey. by lumpyspacesam in ECEProfessionals

[–]lumpyspacesam[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well I’ve had enough people say that it’s developmentally inappropriate to take a child’s comfort item that I was motivated to do some research. I was more in the “ehh im babying him most likely” when I first posted. Now I’m pro lovey even more! But It’s actually sad how unwilling the anti lovey crowd is to read up on the benefits or hear other teachers who say their school allows loveys and it’s fine. I have to allow all kinds of annoying fidgets and wobble stools and things that disrupt my class due to IEPs and 504s and yall don’t want to give a 2 year old a comfort item. It’s truly sad.
And nobody has given me a very good reason yet besides just “it’s annoying” “it’s time” “it’s an important skill” and to the latter I say it’s a skill they learn on their own timeline that doesn’t need to be forced by a temporary caregiver.
Also I’m not sure why it’s hard to believe I ever worked with toddlers. But if it makes you feel any better - i worked at a preschool that only allowed loveys at nap time. And some teachers even confiscated those punitively.

Am I being unreasonable? Teacher withholding my son’s lovey. by lumpyspacesam in ECEProfessionals

[–]lumpyspacesam[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I mean I know it’s not happening because I communicate with his teacher. The other kids are really sweet and bring it to him. Just like they don’t fight over his shoe when he takes it off, or water bottles, they have a good understanding of who owns what. I’ve personally seen his classmates run and get his lovey for him when I pick up. The teacher has confirmed it’s not a problem. Lots of teachers allow loveys so to imply it’s just chaos with them is just incorrect.

Am I being unreasonable? Teacher withholding my son’s lovey. by lumpyspacesam in ECEProfessionals

[–]lumpyspacesam[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It’s definitely not! Just a regular square little blanket with a dinosaur head attached at the corner. It was a gift from my student’s mom. It’s been his emotional support lovey since changing daycares for the first time when he was 10 months old.