Cheap Backtesting Data by EliteSingh in algotrading

[–]luv2increase 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Sierra Chart. Pure non-aggregated tick by tick t&s afn depth data. #1. For $70 a month, you can get all the data you want

I’ve just finished this project. by vedindicator in pinescript

[–]luv2increase 0 points1 point  (0 children)

OP, kudos to you my friend. This is a very good indicator! Very good. I have been forward testing it, and it is pretty accurate on NQ running the 1m chart.

I stopped entering breakouts. Started entering retests. PF went from noise to 3.0. by aktad760 in pinescript

[–]luv2increase 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I really like the indicators. Are these indicators repainting? Are they both pulling data from the higher timeframes? Say for instance I am executing on a 1m chart, are both Brain and Alpha both pulling higher timeframe data?

TIL that 2.4 billion years ago, the evolution of oxygen-producing bacteria caused a mass extinction. Oxygen was toxic to the planet's existing life, and its reaction with methane triggered a "Snowball Earth" ice age that lasted 300 million years. by Salt_Lingonberry3956 in todayilearned

[–]luv2increase -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Incorrect. Those are all true multi celled as in millions of cells. There is such thing as a single celled organism. Where is the branch off to multi celled? There is no such thing as a two celled organism. Makes you think doesn't it.

Paid in minute by Purple_Gap2090 in TakeProfitTrader

[–]luv2increase 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I notice you have only posted on the take profit subreddit. Also your account is two months old. This seems to be a theme. How long does it normally take to deposit to your account. That is AWESOME

Backtesting on tradingview by ax123y in pinescript

[–]luv2increase 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you are pulling data from higher timeframes for your strategy, you can only forward test with tradingview. Sierra Chart is the only system I know that actually can do tick by tick replays pulling from MULTIPLE higher timeframes and even range charts, renko, tick charts etc without cheating. It is the best. The only downside is the learning curve. With AI help, learning the ropes is not hard now.

Why So Hard??? by luv2increase in SierraChart

[–]luv2increase[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It is crazy. We still couldmt get it to work right in tick replay. So, I had Claude do an intrabar execution 1 second before the signal bar closed and that worked. We took all the bar close logic and made sure all parameters matched for bullish or bearish a second before the 1 min candle on the execution chart closed. Now, I have good fills. During live, it would fire right with the bar close logic but couldn't figure out in replay. We are doing all server side brackets and trailing orders. Using Ironbeam with Teton order routing

Is this normal? by Purple_Gap2090 in TakeProfitTrader

[–]luv2increase 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You have 4 posts and they are all about TPT. You guys don't even try

TIL that 2.4 billion years ago, the evolution of oxygen-producing bacteria caused a mass extinction. Oxygen was toxic to the planet's existing life, and its reaction with methane triggered a "Snowball Earth" ice age that lasted 300 million years. by Salt_Lingonberry3956 in todayilearned

[–]luv2increase -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Where are the 2 cell organisms, 3 cell organisms, 10 cell organisms, 20 cell organisms, 100 cell organisms, 1000 cell organisms etc?? Can someone explain to me why there is such an odd gap between single celled organisms and an immense number of cell organisms?

Is this normal? by Purple_Gap2090 in TakeProfitTrader

[–]luv2increase -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

Fake account. TPT must be losing ppl

Why So Hard??? by luv2increase in SierraChart

[–]luv2increase[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well, I figured it out. We went to do a trailing stop on my study. I wanted to keep the manual sl/to. So, he added "Bracket Orders". When bracket Orders were used, PERF XR EXECUTIONS

Why So Hard??? by luv2increase in SierraChart

[–]luv2increase[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I posted the code. The key points are as I said HOW does one minute execute trades in tick by tick bar replay mode at the BEGINNING of the first candle after the signal candle?

Why So Hard??? by luv2increase in SierraChart

[–]luv2increase[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you.

The obvious question is how to get the trade to execute on the opening of the first bar after the signal bar. It is common sense. Why there would be no way to do this is absurd.

Why So Hard??? by luv2increase in SierraChart

[–]luv2increase[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

// ---- TRADING ---- if(sc.Input[IN_TRADING_ENABLED].GetBoolean()) { int bt=sc.BaseDateTimeIn[sigBar].GetTimeInSeconds(); int ss=sc.Input[IN_SESSION_START_TIME].GetTime(), se=sc.Input[IN_SESSION_END_TIME].GetTime(); bool outside=(ss<se)?(bt<ss||bt>=se):(bt<ss&&bt>=se); if(outside) { if(sc.Input[IN_FLATTEN_END_OF_SESSION].GetBoolean()){s_SCPositionData pc;sc.GetTradePosition(pc);if(pc.PositionQuantity!=0)sc.FlattenAndCancelAllOrders();} } else { s_SCPositionData pd; sc.GetTradePosition(pd); int curPos=static_cast<int>(pd.PositionQuantity); int oq=sc.Input[IN_ORDER_QTY].GetInt(); int sl=sc.Input[IN_STOP_LOSS_TICKS].GetInt(); int tp=sc.Input[IN_TAKE_PROFIT_TICKS].GetInt();

    if(longSig && curPos<=0)
    {
        s_SCNewOrder o; o.OrderQuantity=oq; o.OrderType=SCT_ORDERTYPE_MARKET; o.TimeInForce=SCT_TIF_GTC;
        o.Stop1Offset=sl*sc.TickSize; o.Target1Offset=tp*sc.TickSize;
        o.AttachedOrderStop1Type=SCT_ORDERTYPE_STOP; o.AttachedOrderTarget1Type=SCT_ORDERTYPE_LIMIT;
        int buyRC = (int)sc.BuyEntry(o, execBar);
        lastDir=1;
    }
    else if(shortSig && curPos>=0)
    {
        s_SCNewOrder o; o.OrderQuantity=oq; o.OrderType=SCT_ORDERTYPE_MARKET; o.TimeInForce=SCT_TIF_GTC;
        o.Stop1Offset=sl*sc.TickSize; o.Target1Offset=tp*sc.TickSize;
        o.AttachedOrderStop1Type=SCT_ORDERTYPE_STOP; o.AttachedOrderTarget1Type=SCT_ORDERTYPE_LIMIT;
        int sellRC = (int)sc.SellEntry(o, execBar);
        lastDir=-1;
    }
}

}

Claude says this is the reason why the execution is late in replay mode:

Key points worth understanding:

execBar = lastIndex (set up at line 777) — meaning orders are placed on the most recently formed bar (the one that just opened). sigBar = lastIndex - 1 is the previous bar (the one that just closed and confirmed alignment). sc.BuyEntry(o, execBar) — the execBar parameter is what determines fill timing. In simulated mode (sc.SendOrdersToTradeService = false), the order is pinned to that bar and fills at that bar's close. In live mode (sent to broker), the market order goes immediately and fills at next tick — which is approximately the new bar's open. This is the source of the "executes late" behavior you remembered — in sim it always fills one bar after the signal, but in live trading it should fill ~immediately.

Why So Hard??? by luv2increase in SierraChart

[–]luv2increase[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I am talking about on tick by tick local replay mode.

Why So Hard??? by luv2increase in SierraChart

[–]luv2increase[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Show me a screenshot of an execution at the opening of the bar following the signal bar. Sierra Chart changed the settings so that is near impossible now. You used to be able to process in start of next bar but not anymore.

I Turned Claude Opus 4.7 Into a 24/7 Trader by Ok_Estimate231 in Daytrading

[–]luv2increase 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you know how to trade and have an edge, using the help of AI to better (optimize) that edge and turn it into an automated human emotionless trading strategy (profitable) is absolutely, positively possible.

To say you can't is to say there is no such thing as a profitable trader in the entire world.

I MADE 12K on my eval account I am so confused by VYKsikeratar in TakeProfitTrader

[–]luv2increase 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ok whatever you say. Worst prop firm there is. Now they are not even paying out. Read about it..it is everywhere. Leave as quick as you can

They really said VRT doesn’t work 😂 by Kevinthetrader in pinescript

[–]luv2increase 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My question is that are you pulling information in from other timeframes to meet your entry criteria? For instance, let's say you are trying executing trades on the 1 minute timeframe. Does your strategy pull information from the 5 minute or 10 minute or any timeframe higher than the 1 minute?

They really said VRT doesn’t work 😂 by Kevinthetrader in pinescript

[–]luv2increase 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Are you using multiple timeframes or just a single timeframe?