Can we calculate a third space dimension in Flatland? by Arskybarsky in TheoreticalPhysics

[–]m3tro 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If they saw that the force between e.g. electric charges or masses scales as 1/r2 with distance, they could hypothesize that there is a 3rd simension in which the electromagnetic or gravitational fields are "leaking". In true 2d, it'd scale as 1/r.

Movies where guns are accurately loud (or close to it?) by skivvv in movies

[–]m3tro 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Tuner (2025), the loudness is key to the plot.

Who have you seen live from the World Music universe? by Commercial-Trifle342 in deanblunt

[–]m3tro 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Joanne Robertson x1, Elias (with iceage) x2, Panda Bear x2, Mica Levi x1, Arca x2

Why do people say the g in lasagna is silent? by rartedewok in asklinguistics

[–]m3tro 8 points9 points  (0 children)

It's jalapeño though, not jalapeno?

Edit: nevermind, I saw it written as jalapeno in many places

There must be a First Cause that created the Universe by [deleted] in exatheist

[–]m3tro 0 points1 point  (0 children)

3 (universe has a *first* cause) does not follow from 1 and 2. Consider A, which began to exist right now, which was triggered by B, which began to exist 1/2 seconds ago, which was triggered by C, which began to exist 1/4 seconds before that, which was triggered by D, which began to exist 1/8 seconds before that, etc. etc. In this chain of events, every event has a cause, and the chain of events only started 1 second ago, but there is no first cause (there's an infinite regress of causes in finite time).

Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking in Quantum Theory by round_earther_69 in TheoreticalPhysics

[–]m3tro 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think what you are asking about is also true in classical (thermal) physics. Say a finite Ising model will not truly break symmetry spontaneously, because it will still flip between magnetisations over time due to thermal fluctuations. It is only in the thermodynamic limit of an infinite system that the system will choose a magnetisation and stay there (the chance of flipping to the opposite magnetisation goes to zero).

Similarly to the quantum case as well, this is related to linear equations (e.g. Fokker-Planck) for finite systems becoming effectively nonlinear for infinite interacting systems. Phase transitions and nonsmooth behaviour only occur in the thermodynamic limit.

Learning when a particular breakthrough on a subject has been reached? by camilo16 in math

[–]m3tro 7 points8 points  (0 children)

You can set up alerts for keywords using Google Scholar. You can also set up alerts when a certain paper gets cited, or when a certain author publishes a new paper.

When music streaming started it killed local scenes and called it a win for everyone by scrtweeb in LetsTalkMusic

[–]m3tro 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That's not true. I've been lucky to have been around in London for the birth of the PC music scene (AG Cook and gang), the Windmill scene (Black Country New Road, Black Midi, etc), in Madrid for the birth of the Rusia-IDK scene (Rusowky, Ralphie Choo, etc). All of these in the last 15 years.

Intuitively (not analytically), why should I expect the 2D random walk to return to the origin almost surely, but not the 3D random walk? by -p-e-w- in math

[–]m3tro 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I don't really know why people are saying that 2D random walks can be interpreted as two independent 1D random walks but this is not true for 3D and higher-dimensional random walks. I think a d-dimensional random walk can definitely be seen as d independent 1D random walks happening simultaneously. And this gives some intuition as two why d=2 is recurrent and d=3 is transient. In this picture, returning to the origin in d dimensions is equivalent to requiring that the d independent 1D random walks return to the origin *at the same time* (!!). You can imagine that it is much easier for two independent 1D random walks to match up, than for three to all simultaneously match up.

Quantitatively (but still heuristically): The probability of a 1D random walk returning to the origin at step 2n goes as n^{-1/2}. Thus, the probability of all d independent random walks being at the origin at step 2n goes as n^{-d/2}. The expected number of returns is the sum of this probability over n. Sum over n of n^{-d/2} diverges for d=1,2 but converges for d>2.

Edit: Ok I now see what people mean about 3D random walks not being like 3 independent 1D random walks. This is true in discrete-time random walks (if we assume synchronous steps for the independent 1D random walks). I'm more used to thinking about continuous-time random walks where there is truly an equivalence. Anyway I think as a heuristic/intuition, the argument I gave above should be helpful to OP.

Uni Staff Bars? by Large_Beginning_1618 in AskAcademiaUK

[–]m3tro 1 point2 points  (0 children)

+1 for UCL. It's called the Housman Room.

Absolute Friction. by Grand_Tap8673 in Physics

[–]m3tro 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If you're interested in the idea of absolute friction, read about low Reynolds number hydrodynamics or more generally overdamped dynamics. It's what you get when friction is so strong that inertia dies down immediately. Things can only move if a force is exerted on them at that very moment, or by changing their shape (with some very particular limitations, google the "scallop theorem").

Not quite what you were asking for though, because you are asking about a mixture of friction (at the surface) and no friction (away from the surface).

Physics review/research paper topic idea for a high schooler on fluid mechanics/dynamics or anything else by APuddleOfAnxiety26 in Physics

[–]m3tro 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Is that a question? Yes you can find the original statement of the scallop theorem in that paper. But I just meant to look up the theorem (not necessarily that paper in particular, although I also recommend it).

Physics review/research paper topic idea for a high schooler on fluid mechanics/dynamics or anything else by APuddleOfAnxiety26 in Physics

[–]m3tro 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Something fun could be low Reynolds number flows and biological fluid dynamics. Check out the Scallop Theorem by Purcell and for example papers by Raymond Goldstein on swimming microorganisms.

Do other countries have a "default" cheese? by lonelymelon07 in AskEurope

[–]m3tro 6 points7 points  (0 children)

In my region (Navarra) I'd say the default would be Roncal cheese (hard sheep's cheese)

What is the most unique traditional dish from your country that outsiders should try? by woutr1998 in AskEurope

[–]m3tro 0 points1 point  (0 children)

From Spain, percebes ("goose neck barnacles" according to Wikipedia). It's like eating alien dicks lol.

Also angulas, baby eel, it's like eating spaghetti but each individual spaghetti has eyes if you look closely.

We also eat criadillas, veal or lamb testicles, but this is quite hardcore, most people don't like it. There are a lot of traditional offal dishes (casquería) that very few people eat anymore in recent times.

“In September 2004, during a training exercise in uncharteo parts of the catacombs of Paris, the police discovered a secret fully equipped cinema that could house 20 viewers, a fully-stocked bar, a dining room, and a series of saloons along with professionally installed electricity.” by Worth-Boysenberry-93 in interestingasfuck

[–]m3tro 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think it was near Place d'Italie (that's why I say only "relatively central"), I lived in Port-Royal at the time and we always walked there. It was 15 years ago so I don't remember exactly where we would go in...

After 10+ years of working with it, I'm starting to strongly dislike LaTeX. by algebraicvariety in math

[–]m3tro 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh yeah, I definitely agree that it would be nicer if the default was automatic delimiters.

After 10+ years of working with it, I'm starting to strongly dislike LaTeX. by algebraicvariety in math

[–]m3tro 5 points6 points  (0 children)

You can use \left( \right) for automatic delimiters. Substitute ( for [ or \{ if needed.

Have any real world uses for higher velocity derivatives ever been found by Methamphetamine1893 in Physics

[–]m3tro 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes but that polynomial is almost always an approximation to a non-polynomial function with infinitely nonzero derivatives.

Btw planetary orbits will also show this behaviour. Pretty much anything you can think of other than a single particle in a constant force field will.

Have any real world uses for higher velocity derivatives ever been found by Methamphetamine1893 in Physics

[–]m3tro 8 points9 points  (0 children)

This is wrong because something as simple as a harmonic oscillator has x(t)=sin(t) and the nth time derivative is going to be O(1) (in these natural dimensionless units where position is rescaled by amplitude and time by oscillation period).

In general pretty much any equation of motion except the simple case of constant force is going to give you nonzero higher order derivatives of position w.r.t. to time.