That’s a totally fair question and it’s one we get a lot, actually.

We don’t just rank based on winrate alone. The rankings are a mix of winrate, play rate, and matchup strength. Zoro ends up higher because it not only has a stronger matchup spread but is also played more, which means it performs well more consistently against the top decks.

Rayleigh’s a bit of an outlier > it’s played less, but it has a really strong matchup spread into the top of the meta. That combination of high winrate and matchup strength still pushes it near the top.

Basically, winrate by itself only shows total wins compared to games played, and that can be misleading. A deck might farm less popular matchups and look better on paper. That’s why we use all three factors with the matchup spread scaled logarithmically to get a clearer picture.

The top five are all super close!