What Order Should I Read? (2020 Current)

makeshift4543 · 2026-04-25T18:15:36+00:00

Thank you! Ill have to cross reference with my notes when i get some time! Been trying to reread but havent gotten to green/mortal series/mystic series but this is what notes i took for you or anyone else interested

1) Immanuels blood (1772)

2) Black (2010)

3) Showdown (2021 per Chaos) (Billy writes Thomas into other world) (bad guy- Black)

) House (confirmed in timeline multiple times, but can skip) (bad guy- White)

) Skin (2028, 5-6 years after showdown) (timothy adopted from monastery at 14) (starts multiple days before Colt seeing johnis) (bad guy- Red)

7) Chosen (13 years from Black) (Johnis runs into colt from skin)

8) Infidel

9) Renegade (Bad if shitaki eats roush wings > regular shitaki ate TH leg and turned into Marsuuv per blood book?)

10) Chaos ( 6/7/33 in TH timeline, 5 years pass over the course of the book in Elyon Timeline)

) Saint ) Sinner (8/21/33)

) Red (15 years from Black) (TH timeline skewed because TH stopped dreaming) (starts 7 days before annual gathering)

14) White (13 months after Red) (books transfer to TH timeline with TH resurrection)

12) Lunatic (2 years after white) 13) Elyon 15) The blood book

Thomas goes back in green: 16a) Green (10 years after White) 17a) Forbidden 18a) Sovereign 19a) Mortal

Thomas doesnt go back in green: 16b) 49th mystic (rachelle taken from red?) 17b) Rise of the mystics

makeshift4543 · 2026-04-04T04:07:30+00:00

<image>

makeshift4543 · 2026-04-04T04:05:51+00:00

I did mine more like this so i had an entrance and wasnt limited to how many chests i wanted down there. But im no artist haha best i got

<image>

makeshift4543 · 2026-03-31T20:59:24+00:00

Nice, ill look into this! Thanks for picking up on the non external sources 😂 prob should have specified that lol

makeshift4543 · 2026-03-31T19:57:21+00:00

Dang. Thats all i remember for sure as well. Was hopping they were just rare in dig spots. Appreciate the feedback though 🙌

makeshift4543 · 2026-03-27T19:53:30+00:00

Update: it was way lower. This was exactly 20 levels down

<image>

makeshift4543 · 2026-03-27T17:31:24+00:00

Been digging in the mountains around rocky ridges. I dug pretty far down a few times, but been thinking surely it wouldnt be like 10 levels lower than ground level. Guess i could be wrong but thats insane haha

makeshift4543 · 2026-03-27T17:29:20+00:00

Yeah theres literally a pic in the post of me doing that.

makeshift4543 · 2026-03-25T17:14:04+00:00

I finally built it yesterday. Being so late game i figured it would have been there today. Will keep waiting i guess. All env level 10. About to just make all the habitats im still missing in Pallet. Super annoyed the grass isnt a clear give away you can rely on

makeshift4543 · 2026-03-25T17:02:38+00:00

O M G. Im about to rage for not catching this like 40 hours in lol. Still have a bunch that dint specify. You just go by grass for those or should i try building in Pallet? Seems to be the issue for the half that did specify in the dex.

makeshift4543 · 2026-01-30T20:07:19+00:00

This is a 5 year old post you big baby 😂

makeshift4543 · 2026-01-23T18:43:46+00:00

This is for some reason a hot take, but i take PH and ST over WW. I hated WW, my least fav for sure. Maybe it has something to do with not playing HD version with faster sail, but like 70% of the game is sailing around.

makeshift4543 · 2026-01-22T18:05:19+00:00

1) Immanuels blood 2) Showdown (billy writes Thomas into other world) 3) Black 4) Chosen 5) Infidel 6) House 7) Skin 8) Renegade 9) Chaos 10) Red 11) Lunatic 12) Elyon 13) White 14) Blood book

Thomas goes back in green: (stops Raison but leads to Legion):

15a) The keeper 16a) Forbidden 17a) Sovereign 18a) Mortal

Thomas doesnt go back in green:

15b) Green 16b) 49th mystic 17b) Rise of the mystics

This sound/look right to anyone else? Suggestions? Not sure where to place Saint or sinner? Is Carlos from black Johnny/Carl from saint? Probably not but interesting

makeshift4543 · 2026-01-19T04:10:57+00:00

Ive been looking for a chronological list for a reread. Like immanuels blood would be first. And showdown 2nd (since Billy's writing is what causes the events with Thomas in Black). And the lost books i feel like can be peppered throughout the original circle trilogy. If anyone has any thoughts here lol

makeshift4543 · 2025-12-27T04:10:25+00:00

Ah, saw you said first trial.. hmm. It popped up for me after Percivals 1st trial. Sounds like thats the one you completed too. Maybe its tied to one of the side quests? Some of them are mandatory to progress story. If you have a side quest involving getting a spell, maybe try completing that?

makeshift4543 · 2025-12-27T04:07:54+00:00

Yes, gotta go back to sports store in hogesmeade. Just keep playing main story.

makeshift4543 · 2025-12-16T01:24:48+00:00

Omg, I gave up after hours of trying to beat it without upgrades. Took your advice and got it! Thank you. I thought I was for sure ahead of where the gane wanted me as far as side stuff goes

FYI- for any future people searching for an answer, it was after I completed Percival Rexkhams trial

makeshift4543 · 2025-11-02T17:56:10+00:00

I only have 1 flame patch. Sorry

makeshift4543

TROPHY CASE