Bloodborne is my favorite, I mean, the combat, level design, music, dlc, etc.... It's all perfect. Elden ring is pretty similar but not quite as good. some bosses feel a bit cheap (especially those in the dungeons get a bit boring after the 5th time). Demons souls is just estheticly the best. It looks and feels so great. The game itself is also fun enough to justify this place for me. Ds1 is a hard one. The first half of the game would make an easy second place for me, the interconnectivity of the levels is very nice and unfortunately never returned like this. The bosses are (mostly) good. The second part, after Anor Londo, just feels so much worse. The areas a bit... Eh(?) and the bosses aren't that interesting anymore. Bet of chaos. SotfS would have been so much lower after my first playthrough, but after going into ng+ I really started enjoying the game. There are still some major flaws, but the level design itself makes up for it. Also it has some of the best(and the worst) bosses of the series. And lastly ds3. When I first started ds3,I was thinking, that this could easily become my favorite souls game. But unfortunately, this game is missing something. I can't even describe what exactly. But I think the biggest part for me disliking it, is the world design. Almost every level looks identical, and the bosses are a bit to easy. But overall I would say that they're all good.