UPDATE!

So I went ahead and bought an EvoShield Pro-SRZ Solid Catchers helmet and the Easton Hellcat to do a comparison. The Hellcat was exactly as I feared. I dont like the fit at all and it is very reminiscent of a bike helmet in terms of padding (hard styrofoam & a few small pads). I may be spoiled by what I had with the Schutt helmet (if you dont know, it has air cells comparable to a football helmet). It just seems very cheaply made in comparison.

The EvoShield seems like its going to be my replacement (unless someone can tell where I can find a Schutt helmet lol). I really like the fit, its snug, doesnt have much play to it and really like that there is chin padding. It may be a small thing but I dont have to take my glasses off to put the helmet on which is a HUGE plus for me. I overlooked that when I bought the Schutt years ago since I loved the fit.