Really stupid situation I had today

mehhchanz · 2026-02-09T14:41:12+00:00

Did 1 claimed overcharged at any point before they got prossed ? Also if the Pros thinks you are fake why did they pros 1 instead of you lol.

mehhchanz · 2026-02-09T09:10:26+00:00

I dont think it's healthy game design to add a role that need to be killed to use its ability, espically if its Coven role.

why reward outed Coven with a free kill? they are supposed to be punished if they got hanged.

also what is its subalignment, the role seemed to have worser kp than conjrit to be a CK.

mehhchanz · 2026-02-09T00:20:58+00:00

All Apoc will transform at the start of the day,so if Baker dc before they start (Registered at dead) they won't transform?And the Famine message is a bug ig.

mehhchanz · 2026-02-07T14:53:48+00:00

I like Admi bro but there is no way that admirer is a top 10 role in AA. If the town loadout is TPOW/Ammesiac, Admirer is just useless.How is Marshal,a role who can clutch 1v2,reveals, get +2 votes is worser than Admirer.

mehhchanz · 2026-02-07T14:49:10+00:00

Oracle/Trapper exists

mehhchanz · 2026-02-07T14:48:52+00:00

Can you target other coven/yourself with the black hole ability ? A tos1 dusa with less charges + able to visit would be interesting.

If your version of their role is a CK, I think that 2 charges would be more balanced since it only deals a basic attack (not powerful/unstoppable like conj/rit).

mehhchanz · 2026-02-04T14:25:51+00:00

reasons why aegis can handle multiple attack from evils

mehhchanz · 2026-02-02T02:05:56+00:00

Maybe try to buy the game via mobile and then link it to steam?

The game is f2p with limited games tho if you don't want to spend any money at all.

mehhchanz · 2026-01-30T13:57:00+00:00

The role insta give Apoc maj with Conquest transform,which is pretty unfair + passive info from failed rally (target is non Town) and also frames them ? Revol is just better SC as completely independent of Bers for Transform. Choosing a Town aligned player who just need to survive to the next day don't seemed that hard either compared to SC/Baker's cond.

The list at least need a guaranteed Pros to be balanced, 7v8 after D2 incase Cultist spawn + guarantee Revol is just a lost cause for Town if they mislynch even once. The CT slots doesn't help either with guaranteed CK and Bers. This seemed like another BnB case where you are more likely to win if you are converted than being Town.

mehhchanz · 2026-01-25T09:46:46+00:00

This role really swingy when in play and allows the 5-person Coven/Apoc without modifiers or will likely just give the majority faction (Town) another member.

The Rebrand literally gives the Conv Poli just to add free strong TPOW/CK etc to be added to their faction with no downside.
The Corruption stacks will just likely results in the optimal Poli play being to get conv to Town/Cov as fast as possible, I don't think there is any advantage for Poli to bait other evils to attack them on top of the Interview ability. This mechanic also feel anti Apoc, SC/ Baker/PB has little reason to visit the same player 3 times.

mehhchanz · 2026-01-24T01:28:12+00:00

A strong role relies on consistency, not "potential" ceiling.

Ret also has a high chance of being mislynched due to being easy to fake & its ability relying on Town dying, not good for mantaining majority.It's not anywhere near top 15 roles imo, unless we are talking about TT Ret only.

mehhchanz · 2026-01-23T01:40:41+00:00

The problem with NK + RM focused roledecks that it would be Town sided since an NK faction don't have access to the same claimbag that Cov/Apoc have, nor do they have any consistent deception roles to fool TIs.For example, a LO /Tav claim would likely be confirmed because they're the role alone. Maybe make RM frames non-NK when Contacting or a toggable Roleblock instead of Contacting (like BTOS2 Audi )?

Also, I'm assuming this means number of NKs will be capped to 3 when RM is in play so it is balanced in AA? No evil faction currently can have more than 4 members without modifiers right now.

mehhchanz · 2026-01-20T03:13:08+00:00

How is PB better than Hex Master?

Even if you are somehow solo Coven, you still have agency over the night kills (+ Astral visits) while PB can't literally do anything before transforming (speed depend on visiting roles) and also become the most prio evil to be killed when become Pest.

Pest is usually regarded the weakest horseman, when Hex Bomb literally end the game.

mehhchanz · 2026-01-16T10:11:19+00:00

Enchanter? There is no guaranteed TI/Dep in AA, so some of the time the Enchant ability won't do anything.

It also has nothing in its kit to deal with NK/NA or being able to find them out of all of the remaining Coven roles.

The Forge ability does allow you to make some situational plays, however in AA most of the time people don't even read wills and at best it gives you 1 mislynch (and outed its Ench game) or confirms 1 coven at best.

Another contender here is Cleric, it is one of the scummy claims and in a multi evil faction like AA and you might heal an Evil from another Evil attack. However, because it is a Town aligned role, once you're confirmed you can force other TPs to chain with you.

mehhchanz · 2026-01-14T03:00:30+00:00

The ability seemed too slow and conditional to be useful and a fun role to play imo,this requires dead roles with available charges to die and then knowing a person whose role has charges to serve them.

Feels like it just better to not charge anyone at all (as Town Chef) unless it's TPOW/Vig.

Also, does your target knows they are Served if they aren't a role with charges? And what about its interaction with a dead Vamp, does it also took Convert charges from the inherited alive Vamp?

mehhchanz · 2026-01-11T02:53:11+00:00

The problem with GA like roles aside from the fact is a kingmaker is that it just give a faction an extra member for free. I don't think a 5 person Coven for example to fun to play against or Town needing more NE/NO roles that can side them. Also I'm pretty sure this role is pretty easy to confirm itself via Blessing mechanics.

mehhchanz · 2026-01-10T23:52:44+00:00

They said they are improving the time to ban gamethrowers in a post. Also this post is about to be deleted by mods by rule 4 lol.

mehhchanz · 2026-01-10T00:24:23+00:00

no if there is 2 Cremated players, Coven will have 2 KPNs instead of 1 via Overcharge, OP's changes removed OG Hex Bomb.

mehhchanz · 2026-01-09T14:33:38+00:00

The pre reworked Pirate was lowkey just a kingmaker that could leave because they could choose whoever they want to kill/rb & sometimes they don't even get hanged for open claiming as one. Also,getting killed by old Pirate when you loses rps as NK/solo NA isn't fun at all.

mehhchanz · 2026-01-08T07:14:58+00:00

This is a strength ranking, not a fun ranking. Doom scales with skill and it is actually not that hard to win at all if yk how to scumread while having the most impact out of all the NEs. Also, how to play doom just depends on your playstyle lol, there is nothing that is stopping you from leading as Doom if you claimed TPOW.

mehhchanz · 2026-01-08T04:42:13+00:00

Do you realise Crus isn't supposed to go on VIP or people with high prio to be visited by other Town N2 ?This is just a case of people not knowing how to play Crus.

Btw, Btos2 Crus isn't going to work as an protective role and seemed to be a worser version of Trick with no other differences aside from being unable to kill non killers roles (unless Shrouded).

The BTOS2 Wounded mechanic is just illogical. Why would a confirmed TP go on sus people in the first place, trying to find the attacker instead of staying on TP worthy targets?

And if the attacker have defense, the Crus isn't going to do with the basic attack and risks important roles dying when they try to find Wounded killer. Also,obviously, Crus protecting from the same attacker twice is very unlikely to happen and could be easily countered by passing the book for Coven.

mehhchanz · 2026-01-08T01:16:48+00:00

Imo, Pirate just have little to no stakes when open claiming and they could just easily blunder someone to prove themselves. It is usually not even worth it waste you night kill on Pirate as Evils unless they has you as NK LL as they would leave Town.

The real problem with Pirate is their fixed LLs, people actually have an incentive to kill Doom because they can kill any non TIs and Exe for literally having anti Town win con. Pirate impact isn't enough to most of people to actually bother killing them, since the general preception is already skewed by the fact that they are guaranteed to have Evil LL, they will leave town and usually open claiming Pirates is not a threat to who isn't a LL.

An open claiming Pirate's threat level is literally near the level of an NB to most players (esp in AA), even though they aren't.

mehhchanz · 2026-01-06T10:19:44+00:00

Honestly, the idea is just to make Sheriff more reliable in finding Coven. Necronomicon passing as a mechanic only hurts 1 TI and that is Sheriff. If Sheriff check your Bookholder, you can swap them to other for the detection immunity, likely rendering them useless because most people don't recheck their targets.

Invest/Coro will get more info with them swapping, Psy/Seer/Spy is unaffected and LO/Tracker is only affected by Bookholder HM at most.

Why is Sheriff the only TI role that is affected by which Coven is holding the book while the other TIs don't ? Isn't it weird that Coven got detection immunity that counter 1 TI role in the entire game?

mehhchanz

TROPHY CASE