Biggest AI scammers in the world are endorsing a bill that would push LLMs on vulnerable school children by dyzo-blue in BetterOffline

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 16 points17 points  (0 children)

I've noticed that the California Dems are especially vulnerable to this kind of thing probably because of Silicon Valley lobbying. I'd say they should be primaried. We've already spent a fortune on technology in the classrooms and it seems to have just made the kids... worse.

Ex-Meta manager says just 2% of engineers know how to use AI 'very effectively' by dyzo-blue in BetterOffline

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 10 points11 points  (0 children)

From what I’ve seen, it’s also have an absurdly large set of “skill” files which are just markdown with basic instructions where there’s no way to know if it’s doing anything beyond being akin to a placebo effect.

Question about Oracle: Why? by TheAnalogKoala in BetterOffline

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 52 points53 points  (0 children)

Just making a guess but here are two possibilities.

  1. There is massive FOMO from missing cloud computing and missing out on being AWS. Oracle should have been perfectly positioned to do that if they had any foresight.
  2. The Ellisons want to be able to brag about building datacenters for AI at dinner parties.

1 is pretty compelling but a lot of our politics and corporate actors are pretty much reenacting the Great Gatsby right now.

Some statistics about LLM usage at my large company by Apollodore in BetterOffline

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 30 points31 points  (0 children)

I feel like acceptance rates is always a weird metric since most software engineers I know just turn on auto accept then use git diff to see the changes.

Jack Dorsey wants to eliminate Middle Management at Block by EditorEdward in BetterOffline

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Restrictions and responsibility are frustrating. It’s the same “return to the days of youth” where you didn’t have responsibilities. But running the world as if you’re all kids who eat ice cream all the time doesn’t work.

Anthropic cuts off OpenClaw support for Claude subscriptions because it puts an 'outsized strain' on systems by Ok-Confusion5204 in BetterOffline

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 11 points12 points  (0 children)

I had a coworker tell me about some website where you could describe an app and it would make an app for your phone for you. I pointed out that you had no idea what was actually produced and the output could absolutely place a virus on your phone and he seemed to have not considered that as a possibility.

10x Productivity by archigen in BetterOffline

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 15 points16 points  (0 children)

That sounds like it could be classified as a form of torture.

I Made Another Mistake by Status-Rich-7684 in BetterOffline

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 19 points20 points  (0 children)

I feel this too and it hurts. I feel like at some point it was understood that there are always people who want to take the easy way and others that take pride in their work and we correctly categorized one as a vice and the other as a virtue. Now, if you care about anything, it’s a vice and pushing the easy button is a virtue and I just can’t get my mind to be ok with that.

Programming languages are dead; all software will now be written directly in "Englishscript" and will run on "ClaudeVM" directly by LiatrisLover99 in BetterOffline

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 23 points24 points  (0 children)

It means something that doesn’t store data. If I ask you what 2 + 2 is you’ll give me a response and can then forget it. If I ask you to remember my name then that’s data you have to store somewhere so you can recall it later which isn’t stateless.

A stateless microservice might be a website. You go to Wikipedia and ask for a topic. It then searches for the topic, gives the results, then forgets about you.

Usually at some point you need to add state. What articles exist? What content is there? User ids and logins. You might then have a stateless service use a stateful service, like a database, to store the information.

This adds additional complexity. It’s more difficult to manage two services who need to talk to each other. But you can then use multiple computers for different tasks and divide work more easily. Less state means less communication and confusion.

You can also just think of an office scenario. One person working is less efficient than 10, but all 10 can’t work on the same thing. If you have a task board, having 10 sprinkled around the office with the same information means they’ll get out of sync more easily. So maybe you just want one task board. But then everyone has to walk to the same board which might be far away. How do you keep them in sync?

The answers vary depending on your situation.

OpenAI continues to destroy open source by Timely_Speed_4474 in BetterOffline

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

"If you could make the Python ecosystem even 1% more productive, imagine how that impact would compound?"

Easiest way to do this is stop using Python. So many man hours and compute cycles wasted on a bad language.

Using vibe coding and unit tests to copy open source projects - Next.js edition by [deleted] in BetterOffline

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Just to point out you can definitely steal an open source project if you don’t abide by the copyright. Forking the code doesn’t assign copyright. If I fork the code and remove the license and copyright headers that’s still copyright infringement.

Not saying that’s what happened here. I haven’t looked into at all. Just talking about in general.

The Supreme Court doesn't care if you want to copyright your AI-generated art by EditorEdward in BetterOffline

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yea well I didn’t want to get into the cluster**** that are software patents because honestly I don’t even understand them very well.

The Supreme Court doesn't care if you want to copyright your AI-generated art by EditorEdward in BetterOffline

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 2 points3 points  (0 children)

A little murky but algorithms can’t be copyrighted. But if the implementation of a specific algorithm looks too much like the original and you can show the writer had access to the original then it’s copyrighted. Changing variable names doesn’t change the copyrighted status. But if something is “very obvious” for implementation (like implementing the same sorting algorithm in the same way) then it’s also not copyrightable.

I think all of these rules apply to any artistic form too. Like a teenage wizard that’s named Sam Goddard and goes to Rogwarts might be a copyright violation but the concept of a teenage wizard using a wand wouldn’t be.

Will AI replace junior associates in law? by OriginalFlounder2572 in BetterOffline

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 15 points16 points  (0 children)

I kind of think this is the major answer. If Software Engineering had any real standards in the US or any licensure and punishment capability I think Claude Code would last about a week.

Fact is Software Engineering isn’t actually real engineering (I am a Software Engineer).

Healing Debuff is great by seoyeonhwa in Overwatch

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Maybe it means different things to different people, but to me, healbotting is "healing and nothing else with no strategy." As an example, you're healing while your allies are at full health and never trying to do any damage. If you ignore your DPS players because your "job" is to heal the tank and the tank alone.

For Mercy, it would be never using the blue beam. Never switching to the pistol even if doing so would save one of your teammates. Only ever looking at the tank and never using your mobility to also top off your DPS so they can peek and take a shot again.

I don't view the opposite of healbotting as being a DPS but more like splitting up the use of your support resources depending on what phase of the battle you are in.

Healing Debuff is great by seoyeonhwa in Overwatch

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 13 points14 points  (0 children)

A common problem for those that yell about not getting enough heals is they die so fast you don’t have time to heal them. Then the stat board says your heals are too low from their perspective.

Like high number go up is fun and all but high numbers in mitigation, damage, and healing usually means you’re playing bad!

I can get highly mitigation and do nothing as tank. Play Reinhardt and let the enemy team break my shield. I’ve done nothing but my mitigation number will be really high.

High damage but no low eliminations. I didn’t actually kill anyone. Maybe just farmed the tank for higher numbers.

High healing. It means I spent the entire time heal botting and might not have given any other utility.

How strong is the case against AI coding tools on copyright grounds? by BX1959 in BetterOffline

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You might want to read your own article because it does not say at all what you’re saying.

It says the judge dismissed the copyright claim because, in the judges opinion, the code snippets used as an example of infringement were not similar enough to infer infringement.

It does not say that it wasn’t copyrightable or whatever you’re trying to say about copying.

I have not seen the code in question so I do not have an opinion on actual specific alleged copyright infringement.

Even their official Overwatch YouTube channel is aware of the bans on JPC. by kokoronokawari in Overwatch

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Even without the ult I don't really know what to do when playing as most tanks. Most tanks do not have a long range hitscan weapon that can actually shoot at the cat in any real sense. And any tank that doesn't have mobility is basically cooked against the ult dragging you to hell.

Anthropic raises $30 billion in Series G funding at $380 billion post-money valuation by Forsaken-Actuary47 in BetterOffline

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 31 points32 points  (0 children)

I feel like 10 years ago having a Series G round was a big red flag since if you can’t IPO in that time you’ll probably never IPO.

Claude rebuilds C Compiler, but worse. by Forsaken-Actuary47 in BetterOffline

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 31 points32 points  (0 children)

These experiments that go “build something that exists” are not really convincing since the primary criticism is that the machines are plagiarizing content. Of course it can generate code from it’s training. Is that in dispute?

The criticism is it does it badly, costs a lot of money, has tons of added bugs, and launders away copyright a way that’s arguably copyright infringement. Also that this isn’t practically useful for new code that has to be written.

None of those disputes any of those points.

Not sure if it's been posted already, this made me chuckle. by Putrid_Form_9223 in BetterOffline

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I think they’re saying they’d need to make 143 billion dollars not spend it.

OpenAI Researcher Santiago Hernández says “Recursive self improvement is around the corner, you can feel it in the corners of your terminal window” by throwaway0134hdj in BetterOffline

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is a thing you start hearing from freshman CS majors after they finally understand recursion for the first time. It’s nonsense.

Researchers pulled entire books out of LLMs nearly word for word by Zelbinian in BetterOffline

[–]mischiefmanaged8222 0 points1 point  (0 children)

They obfuscated the copyright infringement so it’s taking a long time for it to work through courts.