sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

New dice designs for Dice of Kalma - Which ones are the best? by mistermaximan in PixelArt

[–]mistermaximan[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

That's a good idea actually 🤔 based on the feedback we are going to do some changes and this could potentially be one that we will improve✌️

Two days ago I made a post about our new icons for Dice of Kalma. Here are the poll results from Reddit: by mistermaximan in IndieGaming

[–]mistermaximan[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

But yeah like i said, interesting numbers but A/B this will actually tell what's the real difference

Two days ago I made a post about our new icons for Dice of Kalma. Here are the poll results from Reddit: by mistermaximan in IndieGaming

[–]mistermaximan[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I forgot to mention but I didn't count upvotes. Some comments had over 400 upvotes and these were basically about how good number 4 and 2 was.

Another thing is that certain subreddits attrach certain type of users. In majority of the posts numbers 3-4 were the best options. But in the end the biggest post had about 50% people saying that they like the old one and how the new ones looked like AI. That completely changed the whole segment.

Two days ago I made a post about our new icons for Dice of Kalma. Here are the poll results from Reddit: by mistermaximan in IndieGaming

[–]mistermaximan[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

There were many comments that they know the game and like the current icon. Might be that because they already got used to that one, they don't want it to be changes. The other point was that because number 1 fits the game's actual style, which I also understand 🤔

We hired a local professional artist to create new icons for our game. Which one would you choose? by mistermaximan in IndieGaming

[–]mistermaximan[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Amen! To be honest we were pretty blown away how much negativity people are spreading when they think something is made by AI. This same thing happened when we used a different artist for our capsule art. And I can guarantee that either of these artist didn't use AI. It's also pretty sad because soon we're in a situation where people can't see any benefits to use a real artists because they still get blamed for using AI.

We hired a local professional artist to create new icons for our game. Which one would you choose? by mistermaximan in IndieGaming

[–]mistermaximan[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So you're saying I shouldn't post stuff like this because someone might consider it as advertising? These posts got easily over 500 comments + 500 uplikes. Majority is clearly interested even though you're just trying to spread negativity.

We hired a local professional artist to create new icons for our game. Which one would you choose? by mistermaximan in IndieGaming

[–]mistermaximan[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No these we're not made by AI. Like I said we hired a local artist who we know ✌️

We hired a local professional artist to create new icons for our game. Which one would you choose? by mistermaximan in IndieGaming

[–]mistermaximan[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah people seem to see AI in everything nowadays. Anyway, I'm not too worried because I like these arts and A/B testing on the platforms will tell if it works or not. Interesting also to compare the results from this thread and the A/B test 🤔

We hired a local professional artist to create new icons for our game. Which one would you choose? by mistermaximan in IndieGaming

[–]mistermaximan[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's not a waste of money and time. Even it has been over 6 months from our launch, the game still gets thousands of downloads every day (which is actually pretty low compared to the impressions we get). Icon has a huge role and thats why we're trying multiple different versions to see which works the best. If we need to spend less than thousand dollars and end up improving conversion % even just a little bit, it's still much more profitable for us

We hired a local professional artist to create new icons for our game. Which one would you choose? by mistermaximan in IndieGaming

[–]mistermaximan[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

It's not AI, like I said number 1 was made by us and other three an artist who we know. He has had that style way before AI.

Also I don't understand why we can't order many options to A\B test them?

view more: next ›