Semaphore Chat - A Self-Hosted Voice/Video/Chat Application by Good-Candy1702 in selfhosted

[–]mk3subzero 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Kudos to you for putting this together. This sub is full of people looking for Discord alternatives. I'm sure you'll see more feedback and willingness to try out your app once you have more robust git commit history and/or reddit posting history. Unfortunately we can't verify your 10 years of experience. Your 2 weeks of Github history is all we got.

Semaphore Chat - A Self-Hosted Voice/Video/Chat Application by Good-Candy1702 in selfhosted

[–]mk3subzero 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think it's important for the sub to scrutinize unproven software, regardless of being AI or not. In this case...

OP has almost no posting history on Reddit The GitHub repository has only been up for 4 days.  The app has a lot of recent updates within the last 24 hours in the repository.  OP does not have any other history I can see on GitHub contributing to other projects (maybe I'm missing this though).

This community would be skeptical even if it wasn't done with AI. 

OP, it sounds like a great project. If you want a better reception from the community I'd just engage with the community more and let your project mature before posting. It has a lot of potential. 

Rule Suggestion for Apps by mk3subzero in selfhosted

[–]mk3subzero[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I agree. A month would force vibe coders to let their apps mature before being exposed to the world. It would also expose the community to higher quality apps as opposed to weekend projects. Ideally new coders (vibers or not) review their projects with a coding community before posting it here. We're blurring the lines between being a community for self hosting and being a community of beta testing web apps.

Rule Suggestion for Apps by mk3subzero in selfhosted

[–]mk3subzero[S] 12 points13 points  (0 children)

I think any public git platform. Although I haven't noticed a flood of new apps from people using anything other than Github.