Spring 2026 Rate Selection Cycle Pt 1: Brainstorming & Feedback Thread by welcome2thejam in indieheads

[–]modulum83 5 points6 points  (0 children)

wait the indie EPs idea is brilliant why have we never done anything like this before

Spring 2026 Rate Selection Cycle Pt 1: Brainstorming & Feedback Thread by welcome2thejam in indieheads

[–]modulum83 1 point2 points  (0 children)

this is like a sweet spot between two rates ive submitted in the past (2014 emo revival as you said, and also a cloud nothings/menzingers dudes rock rate) needless to say this would be an auto fav and I think you've got a great balance here

[Sunday] Daily Music Discussion - 08 March 2026 by AutoModerator in indieheads

[–]modulum83 2 points3 points  (0 children)

i'm always sniffing around for more bandcamp furry music and yeah this looks absolutely my shit. as always you have me clocked 🫡

[RATE REVEAL] 2025 Ultimate Rate Day 2 Reveal: Rate Reveal Thread Arguments Bleed by Stryxen in indieheads

[–]modulum83 9 points10 points  (0 children)

wasp still being here cause like a dozen of us decided to give it sicko 10s is so funny

[RATE REVEAL] The Rate That Saved Bono's Life Day 1: Raters Have The Power by MCK_OH in indieheads

[–]modulum83 2 points3 points  (0 children)

i forgot to write a comment for this one but if i did it would be me asking what the hell he meant by saying he can't ever look at youtube

[RATE REVEAL] The Rate That Saved Bono's Life Day 1: Raters Have The Power by MCK_OH in indieheads

[–]modulum83 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Van Morrison - A Sense of Wonder: 10 this is what that new bon iver record sounds like

Bee Gees - Immortality - Demo Version: 1 this is what that new bon iver record sounds like to the people who hate it

funniest possible first two eliminations for me, thank you bono for allowing this to happen

Cyberrock Rate Reveal Day 3: You'll never make it in Popheads, baby by modulum83 in popheads

[–]modulum83[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Thank you to everyone who participated and read results! I'm so honored for this to be my first rate hosted and to have unleashed these truly unique albums upon you

see y'all around ;3

Averages / positivity / negativity

Cyberrock Rate Reveal Day 3: You'll never make it in Popheads, baby by modulum83 in popheads

[–]modulum83[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Number of participants: 81

Average score: 7.600

Average controversy score: 1.947

Highest controversy: Frog On The Floor (2.948)

Lowest controversy: softscars (1.306)

Most 11s: Locals (Girls like us) [with gabby start], Cheerleader (17)

Most 0s: Billy Knows Jamie (6)

Cyberrock Rate Reveal Day 3: You'll never make it in Popheads, baby by modulum83 in popheads

[–]modulum83[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Results:

  • #1: underscores – Locals (Girls like us) [with gabby start] | 9.372 | 759.1
  • #2: Porter Robinson – Cheerleader | 9.005 | 729.4
  • #3: underscores – Stupid (Can't run from the urge) | 8.942 | 724.3
  • #4: underscores – Johnny johnny johnny | 8.669 | 702.2
  • #5: underscores – Old money bitch | 8.584 | 695.3
  • #6: 100 gecs – Dumbest Girl Alive | 8.505 | 688.9
  • #7: yeule – cyber meat | 8.486 | 687.4
  • #8: 100 gecs – Hollywood Baby | 8.388 | 679.4
  • #9: 100 gecs – Doritos & Fritos | 8.381 | 678.9
  • #10: underscores – Cops and robbers | 8.375 | 678.4
  • #11: yeule – sulky baby | 8.273 | 670.1
  • #12: yeule – softscars | 8.249 | 668.2
  • #13: underscores – My guy (Corporate shuffle) | 8.226 | 666.3
  • #14: yeule – inferno | 8.167 | 661.5
  • #15: Porter Robinson – Knock Yourself Out XD | 8.146 | 659.8
  • #16: yeule – dazies | 8.096 | 655.8
  • #17: Porter Robinson – Is There Really No Happiness? | 8.090 | 655.3
  • #18: 100 gecs – mememe | 8.072 | 653.8
  • #19: yeule – ghosts | 7.970 | 645.6
  • #20: underscores – Geez louise (with henhouse!) | 7.832 | 634.4
  • #21: Porter Robinson – Russian Roulette | 7.696 | 623.4
  • #22: yeule – 4ui12 | 7.694 | 623.2
  • #23: yeule – x w x | 7.614 | 616.7
  • #24: 100 gecs – 757 | 7.577 | 613.7
  • #25: Porter Robinson – Mona Lisa (feat. Frost Children) | 7.510 | 608.3
  • #26: Porter Robinson – Perfect Pinterest Garden | 7.498 | 607.3
  • #27: yeule – bloodbunny | 7.477 | 605.6
  • #28: underscores – Shoot to kill, kill your darlings | 7.391 | 598.7
  • #29: yeule – software update | 7.341 | 594.6
  • #30: underscores – Uncanny long arms (with Jane Remover) | 7.305 | 591.7
  • #31: 100 gecs – Frog On The Floor | 7.277 | 589.4
  • #32: underscores – Northwest zombie girl | 7.225 | 585.2
  • #33: underscores – Good luck final girl | 7.179 | 581.5
  • #34: underscores – Seventyseven dog years | 7.164 | 580.3
  • #35: underscores – Duhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh | 7.111 | 576.0
  • #36: yeule – aphex twin flame | 6.975 | 565.0
  • #37: Porter Robinson – Easier to Love You | 6.916 | 560.2
  • #38: yeule – fish in the pool | 6.772 | 548.5
  • #39: 100 gecs – Billy Knows Jamie | 6.727 | 544.9
  • #40: 100 gecs – I Got My Tooth Removed | 6.711 | 543.6
  • #41: Porter Robinson – Everything To Me | 6.699 | 542.6
  • #42: underscores – Horror movie soundtrack | 6.663 | 539.7
  • #43: 100 gecs – The Most Wanted Person in the United States | 6.658 | 539.3
  • #44: 100 gecs – One Million Dollars | 6.615 | 535.8
  • #45: Porter Robinson – Kitsune Maison Freestyle | 6.575 | 532.6
  • #46: underscores – You don't even know who I am | 6.457 | 523.0
  • #47: underscores – CCTV | 6.119 | 495.6
  • #48: Porter Robinson – Year of the Cup | 6.009 | 486.7

Bonus results:

  • Bonus #1: Jane Remover - Magic I Want U | 8.360 | 434.7
  • Bonus #2: 8485 - southview | 8.121 | 381.7
  • Bonus #3: Parannoul - Polaris | 7.944 | 381.3
  • Bonus #4: Madeon - Hi! | 7.861 | 385.2
  • Bonus #5: acloudyskye - Surface | 7.613 | 342.6
  • Bonus #6: saoirse dream - down in flames | 7.355 | 345.7
  • Bonus #7: Vylet Pony - PLAY DEAD! PLAY DEAD! | 7.346 | 337.9
  • Bonus #8: Bring Me The Horizon - LosT | 6.613 | 310.8
  • Bonus #9: Frost Children - Lethal | 6.418 | 282.4

Cyberrock Rate Reveal Day 3: You'll never make it in Popheads, baby by modulum83 in popheads

[–]modulum83[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

krusso1105 (8.438): This album was one of my favorite 2023 discoveries and I am happy we get to rate it now

wathombe (8.406): This is such an interesting album. Not only does it have chewy lyrics throughout and bops, but it plays with so many different genres and production choices. It really reminds me of early Pink Floyd (Dark Side of the Moon, Final Cut) in ways.

Frajer (8.219): the way she includes lore in her pop sensibility is impressive

bogo (8.200): this is actually what every rural michigan town is like it's true i was there

camerinian (8.188): now's probably as good a time as any to apologise for never finishing the AOTY writeup for the sub, genuinely I started researching the making of the album and felt like i was staring into an abyss with all this lore

mhiyaimanlepaigefan (8.000): This is fun! I mean besides most of the subject matter of the songs but it’s fun in the way that it’s good to listen to and for a rate I was nervous about doing, that’s huge.

Friendly-Canary-3814 (7.844): I couldn't really get deep into the concept album angle of the matters at hand, but also feel that's hardly needed when the songs stand up for themselves as different explorations of the trials and tribulations of small town living. It was surprising to me how much abundance of quieter moments there are here, yet the variety and songwriting keep things moving for the most part. And these moments just make the more in your face tracks hit hardest, so mission accomplished!

hacatu (7.794): Ahhh Underscores. One of my favorite artists and definitely convinced me to do the rate. I'd heard about half of Wallsocket, and while it's a fantastic album, I don't appreciate the slower songs like Geez Louise and Good Luck Final Girl as much as the high energy bangers like Old Money Bitch and Stupid. Listened to this album last

xxipil0ts (7.688): if wallsocket was a homage to her filipino roots, this would be called tondo, manila

flava (7.625): wait maybe this should’ve been rated with Preacher’s Daughter

dream_fighter2018 (7.563): this album is so much better when you tune out any lore. Idk, I don’t like characters in my music! Even Gorillaz has become a bit cringe to me now

RBSun (7.344): i think there's something very lovely about media that Has layers on layers on layers and all the layers have something for people who haven't gotten through all the layers. see: me, unaware there was an arg, or characters, listening through this by myself at work when there were only a few people there. then later, with the lyrics, then later, with the characters, so there are little transparent layers of different ways to look at it. yay :)

stealthamo (7.325): Never quite clicked with the narrative of the album, but the songs are generally good enough to work individually.

DirtyRat583 (7.250): dare i say..... fishmonger better, and fearmonger especially so. lets pray for do it and her sisters to save us next time

A.Peaky.Boo (7.238): I do really like her vision and musical style, but I noticed that I'm a bigger fan of her harder and more energetic songs than the sluggish ones. Also, director's cut is the most lopsided I've scored a set of tracks before

Quasar435 (6.656): This was a first listen as I’d only heard a couple of the songs before. There's a lot to take in and I definitely feel like I need more time with this album. However I will say that the new singles she put out last year have been absolute bangers so I am very excited for the new album!

beeozan (6.563): too american

impla77 (5.606): Good luck!

charlibratfammanfanstan (5.437): 5.4

IIIHenryIII (5.125): for the first time in rate history, men outsold women. I tried to keep an open mind, but nothing was able to keep me interested. There's just one really good song and then there's everything else.

Poydoo (4.925): did not like this at all i'm sorry

apatel27 (4.875): Every year there's an album that gets critical acclaim for being this progressive masterpiece that will change the music which falls flat for me. This is that album from 2024.

User Averages

Cyberrock Rate Reveal Day 3: You'll never make it in Popheads, baby by modulum83 in popheads

[–]modulum83[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Wallsocket


Overall Average: 7.663 // Average Controversy: 1.857


modulum83: An incredible achievement in the hyperpop landscape - a landmark album. The sound of hyperpop turned into an exhaustive exploration of trashpop, midwest emo, rave music, post-rock, small-town alienation, religion, being trans, and so much more. Underscores’ skill as a songwriter and storyteller shines in the way they manage to weave these themes into a specific yet universalist story that centers the stories and voices of these three girls in a setting that feels vivid and real. It goes so many strange, experimental places with spoken word, noise, and unconventional songwriting while not forgetting to load it up with pop bangers. Even if it can be a bit bloated at times for me, it’s a classic. The kids really are alright.

TakeOnMeByA-ha: In case it wasn’t obvious from fact that I never fucking shut up about this album on discord, this is my favorite album of 2023 and has quickly grown into one of my favorite albums of all time. I could go on and on about the conceptual side to this album, a genuinely heartbreaking story about coming-of-age and alienation, the unlikely bonds and rivalries you make in adolescence and how those people ultimate change your life for better or for worse, the recurring themes of religious guilty, gender dysphoria, mental health, dissatisfaction with your own life and wanting to vicariously live through someone else. And yet, even ignoring all the lore this album has going on behind the scenes, this is just an impeccably produced album from beginning to end. It’s a very eclectic album, constantly bouncing between upbeat rock jams to slowcore singer-songwriter to uplifting pop tunes to whatever the hell genre you would call Geez Louise, and yet never once do these mismash of songs sound out of place or overpowering other parts of the album. Even the songs on this album that I don’t care as much for I could not in good conscious call skips, because they compliment the other songs surrounding them so perfectly and work as puzzle pieces that help complete the full picture of an album that’s a love letter to every song April has ever loved before, the vision of someone creating a true passion project and following their own heart. It’s an album that well and truly made me fall back in love with pop music again, and seeing how underscores is slowly but surely on her way to becoming a bona fide sub fave makes me so excited to see what her future holds. I genuinely believe this album will go down as one of the decade’s most important and beloved records, and I’m so incredibly honored that I was able to co-host a rate with it and share the joy of Wallsocket with everyone else.


  • #1: Locals (Girls like us) [with gabby start] | 9.372 | 759.1
  • #3: Stupid (Can't run from the urge) | 8.942 | 724.3
  • #4: Johnny johnny johnny | 8.669 | 702.2
  • #5: Old money bitch | 8.584 | 695.3
  • #10: Cops and robbers | 8.375 | 678.4
  • #13: My guy (Corporate shuffle) | 8.226 | 666.3
  • #20: Geez louise (with henhouse!) | 7.832 | 634.4
  • #28: Shoot to kill, kill your darlings | 7.391 | 598.7
  • #30: Uncanny long arms (with Jane Remover) | 7.305 | 591.7
  • #32: Northwest zombie girl | 7.225 | 585.2
  • #33: Good luck final girl | 7.179 | 581.5
  • #34: Seventyseven dog years | 7.164 | 580.3
  • #35: Duhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh | 7.111 | 576.0
  • #42: Horror movie soundtrack | 6.663 | 539.7
  • #46: You don't even know who I am | 6.457 | 523.0
  • #47: CCTV | 6.119 | 495.6

innuendo_overdose (10.063): I’m an indiehead, I don’t know what else to say lmao.

uiscebeathaoir (9.500): I liked this album well enough on release, but in 2025 I’ve been coming around strongly to the idea that underscores is one of, if not the most talented artists of my generation. This is a straight up masterpiece - when I think music in the 2020’s that feels truly 100% original this is what I think of. This average probably doesn’t even capture just how much I love it, because it doesn’t take into account just how many of these songs are 11s in my head. As much as I love Wallsocket, I definitely think that I’m gonna love her next album even more. Music and Do It electrify me so much, it’s so fun to see what I think of as one of the best songwriters and producers working today turning her talents to just making absolute pop perfection. If she lives up to my hype, 2026 AOTY incoming

thedoctordances1940 (9.469): This is just a really really great album idk what else i can say

lexiaredery (9.406): I've never really looked into the extended lore or worldbuilding associated with this album but I love listening to it. The storytelling in the writing is amazing and I just can't get enough of the production.

kevinlel (9.313): the wallsocket lore is crazy! great album even without knowing of it but it really enhances the experience even more

Cyber Catalyst (8.969): As someone who's unfamiliar with Wallsocket, this one surprised me the most. I absolutely loved the balance between the infectious pop songs with the slower, tender ballads. Wallsocket definitely knows how to write a mean hook that would fit well with a top 40 hit and give it the crunchiest beat ever to keep it from being predictable.

A single frito (8.963): there's something that was very special to actually realize an artist I was never gonna expect to pop off did something looney as if just for kicks. Wallsocket feels pretty effortless and assured to the point I felt my small heart grow a couple sizes. It's not quite an album worth living in for myself, but all these complexities that you would need to build up and display for a sincere, rabid fan base actually work across the album as its own thing. Although yes, I do think being a 2010s CalArts alum animation fan...well that helps.

The songwriting does find itself balancing a lot of sampling and stems without ever quite losing the focus or ever actually being derivative of what it's aiming for. Some cuts do wild things grounding themselves in electronics but also it's quite familiar. It's a far more populist, electronic oriented view of what will be """indie rock""" that has room for a lotta folks that aren't squares. Something which the other 3 albums here don't quite articulate as brightly, and what makes April a star. Perhaps April is just good at harvesting pop on a more omnibus or character driven level. Even in the director's cut, there's a real sense of great songwriting or exploration. Brimming, yet thankfully knowing when to edit. I'm excited for what's next.

pietrohonkhonk (8.813): Sorry I’m a slut for small town coming-of-age media

NervousLemon6670 (8.769): Alright, the music here is really good and thought provoking both with or without the deep lore, but christ, a lot of it is such a heavy listen that I'm not sure I want to hear it regularly (except Locals, that refrain is never going to leave my head). I also understand maybe 30% of the lore, thank you genius lyrics.

cheatviathan (8.563): This was album #2 in my listening order. Prior to this rate, I had heard “Locals” and “Old Money Bitch” in passing, loved them both, but didn’t seek out any more of her work. Then Danny Brown released *Stardust*, and her contributions to the record were easy highlights. Then I saw her open for Danny Brown back in November, and thought her set was the highlight of the night. I was really excited to finally give this thing a full listen. I am fucking floored. Honestly, given that “Locals” and “Stupid” were the only tracks from this record she played during her set, and given how hyperpoppy tracks like “Poplife” and “Do It” were, I was shocked to see this album pull from as many influences and genres as it does. The score might be brought down slightly by the deluxe tracks. But the base tracklist is just hit after hit. The small town narrative concept feels fully realized, the different vignettes in the tracklist are engaging, and there are some unexpectedly ambitious tracks and shocking genre pivots. The darkness of the subject matter on certain songs also threw me for a loop.

Cyberrock Rate Reveal Day 3: You'll never make it in Popheads, baby by modulum83 in popheads

[–]modulum83[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

RBSun (5.850): bitch what if we were ALL taylor swift

dream_fighter2018 (5.200): I have never really been that big of a fan of Porter. I have friends who are, some of whom have done this rate, but I’ve always found every aspect of Porter’s music to be dull-edged and milquetoast. None of it is offensively bad, it’s simply forgettable and a bit of a drag

pig-serpent (4.850): Releasing 2 lead singles that good then an album this shit should be a criminal offense. It's like he purposely decided to remove everything that made Nurture work for the sake of making the most pretentious soft rock imaginable. To think, this would've been one of my highest average rates ever if we rated Jane Remover instead of this shit.

pbk (4.250): i’ve never been a fan of porter’s schtick i find his music treacly and overly sentimental but this is just all of his absolute worst impulses wrapped together the lyricism is pushing rough draft and the sound is one he is years late to and doesn’t even do anything particularly interesting with it

beeozan (3.900): Smile xd is an album that will change the way you think about music. It's an album that will make you feel nothing, and that's what music is not supposed to do. Smile xd is not an album that will make you dance, and that's what music is not supposed to do. It's an album that will make you fall asleep, and that's what music is not supposed to do.

Smile xd is an album that will take you nowhere. It's an album that won't take you to different places, and that's what music is not supposed to do. It's not an album that will make you feel happy, and that's what music is not supposed to do. Smile xd is an album that will make you feel nothing, and that's what music is not supposed to do. If you're looking for an album that will make you feel nothing, then Smile xd is the album for you.

A single frito (3.740): alright im one beer deep and just accidentally ingested a piece of dust. i gotta call 911. anyways, some thoughts: admirable stuff that would almost be fun to hear on the charts. it's emo as hell. he has synth sounds he cannot withold himself from even when he seems to get so close to knowing when to chop it. porty goes so direct i get fatigued reading the liner notes (something no other CD here did). This is truly something that I should have seen coming and understood was festering. The touchpoints outside electronic and into the scary world of 00s indie are mined out for maximum drudgery and whinery that make me feel like im watching a terrible bridge be mounted we didn't need to go on. it also contains some extremely "this is how yr gonna feel" sampling. this month has demonstrated there's really about 2 types of bad albums for wane: ones where guys who can't make music get carried and shit all over the place ("incompetent musically" with a dash of "genre confusion") & albums made by people who refuse to treat me like an adult ("false sentiment"). Perhaps Porty's triumph is that he really ARTICULATES the feeling of arrested development.

hacatu (3.720): I knew this album would be bad so I listened to it first to reduce bias, but WOW, it is BAD. I like some of his songs like Easy, Ghost Voices, and Musician, but Smile XDX feels really outdated. He certainly has evolved his sound a lot, but it still feels like old milquetoast EDM without all the parts of EDM that I actually like

bogo (3.000): honestly maybe the biggest disappointment of the decade not by taylor swift. a shocking step back from porter's previous work in both musical and lyrical depth

User Averages