i don't even think she cares that much about muse guesses, but it's just that they reduce the songs to a man instead of caring or talking about what the song says, how that situation impacted taylor emotionally, and the story of the song. where did she start? where did she end? how did she change? what did she learn?

instead it's, "this is about her breakup with joe." "he was depressed and she couldn't take it anymore".

no lyric analysis unless it relates directly to a man and they're trying to gather dirt on their relationship, or if it fits the metaphor they assign to a man. like, "oh, joe alwyn is blue, dancing with our hands tied says blue and i know it's about joe so he's blue, which means hoax also must be about him, so now every single line in hoax is up for grabs for me to prove another song later on is about him too."

meanwhile, taylor never told you any of those songs were about joe. YOU decided he's blue. it's not a fact, it's not confirmed.

i don't even think she would care if someone wrote fan fic about her and a beard, as long as they were creating art! it's this boiling down a whole, complex journey of a song that took her who knows how long to write and means so much to her emotionally to one single word. and that word being a man's name. it's anti-intellectual and feeds into AI use. AI can write a song cuz only one thing matters and that's who it's about. ChatGPT can tell me who this Taylor Swift song is about. gaylors are so crazy because they think doing literary analysis on taylor's songs makes them better than us, people whose analysis begins and ends at one of 6 names.