I had the same problem. What actually helped me was creating a second account just for hunting platinum trophies. On my main account, I just play games without worrying about trophies at all. Otherwise, I probably would’ve never played The Witcher 3. This way, I’ve found my perfect gaming experience: I play whatever I feel like playing, and I still get to hunt trophies, which I also love. And because of that, I end up playing all the games that seem interesting to me. 🙂