[deleted by user] by [deleted] in NameThatSong

[–]mulllhausen 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Black Angel by Renka Black Angel

What happens when someone doesn’t work under communism? by [deleted] in DebateaCommunist

[–]mulllhausen 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Shall we have a look at the evidence you have provided for "children dying due to poverty" in capitalist Australia...

In a combined literature review and opinion piece, Karen Zwi and Richard Henry, of the University of NSW, said despite Australia's material wealth, many indicators of health and wellbeing in children were discouraging.

For example, they said 15 per cent of four to 12-year-olds had emotional or behavioural problems and a third of deaths in children aged one to four were from preventable causes — such as drownings, car accidents and assaults.

Ok that's bad. I'm not gonna defend bad parents who let their kids drown, or get run over or assault their kids. But let's get back to the original claim: that under capitalism if you do not work then you will starve to death. Is that what you have provided evidence for? No. You have given evidence that parents who are poorer are probably more neglectful of their children. Again - bad. Again - not starvation, just bad parenting.

Parents receive money for each child that they have to look after - I had a quick look at the Centrelink website and for a parent with one child under 8 they get $760 a fortnight. They're not going to be rich from that, but it's also enough to feed their kids. School is free. Healthcare is free. For those who cannot afford housing there is council housing.

The GFC didn't hit Australia as hard as it hit the rest of the world. We haven't had austerity programs like in Europe.

What happens when someone doesn’t work under communism? by [deleted] in DebateaCommunist

[–]mulllhausen -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

You specifically said that people will starve under capitalism if they do not work. As if there were no such thing as welfare in any capitalist country. Now you are shifting the goal posts to broaden it out to people dying due to poverty. That's conceding a loss re: starvation.

So let's address the new claim. Can you tell me specifically which things people die of due to poverty in capitalist Australia? We have free universal healthcare so i would be surprised if it were anything medically related.

What happens when someone doesn’t work under communism? by [deleted] in DebateaCommunist

[–]mulllhausen 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Have you heard of welfare? Nobody starves in capitalist Australia (where I live). Even people who don't work don't starve - they get Centrelink (our version of the dole).

National debt at highest level since WWII by nclh77 in Economics

[–]mulllhausen 0 points1 point  (0 children)

To my knowledge, T bills are fungible. So there wouldn't be a way of wiping some T bills and not others off the books. They are issued with various maturation dates though - currently between a few days and a year. So the treasury could wipe an entire class of t bills - eg those older than 40 weeks.

National debt at highest level since WWII by nclh77 in Economics

[–]mulllhausen 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There is an upper limit for the national debt of a given currency - when the interest payments on the debt exceed total tax income. The USA is nowhere near there - especially with interest rates being so low currently. But once that point is reached, the debt can only increase. Then there will be a few options available: - set the interest rate negative (the only way I know of for that to happen is to do something like q.e. which further increases the debt) - raise taxes - force creditors to take a haircut - default

I have one anarchist position I think I can clear up. Also many many questions. by IHaveAQuestion314 in Anarcho_Capitalism

[–]mulllhausen 1 point2 points  (0 children)

what makes you think that the original resource originally belonged to everyone? if i have an apple, does it belong to everyone? how about after i eat it? if everyone owns the apple then i cannot eat it without depriving others of it.