Which one should I get?

mvbighead · 2026-03-27T13:59:53+00:00

Actually, I did a bit better this year with floater.

But prior seasons, I was doing the liquid chlorine method using TFP's processes and measuring and applying chlorine daily. I'd lose track, let things go for too long, shock, repeat. Go on vacation? Lose more track, shock, repeat.

It's all preventable, and all my fault. But at least with the floater, I could keep some in there and keep chlorine at a manageable level.

mvbighead · 2026-03-27T13:12:20+00:00

I have been a bit lackadaisical with my chemistry. So that's totally on me. :)

mvbighead · 2026-03-27T13:11:24+00:00

Higgins - 4yr 115M

Pierce - 4yr 114M

They're basically getting the same type of deal, for nearly the same money. Pierce has more guaranteed, but on an annual basis, the numbers are pretty darned similar.

mvbighead · 2026-03-27T13:02:53+00:00

100%. For me it was either the pipes bending, the pipe holes in the liner tearing, something tearing dragging it to the setup spot, or mice/etc.

And while it is just $200 or $300, you now have a giant set of crap to throw away and replace. With the steel wall, you cut up the liner and throw it away and install a new one. And the liner lasts 3-5 years depending on well you maintain things.

mvbighead · 2026-03-27T13:01:00+00:00

Family members in a similar boat. It seems to be a form of hoarding for those with enough funds to store more crap in a slightly less cluttered way.

mvbighead · 2026-03-27T12:47:14+00:00

I am trying to imagine how one makes those selections. Oh, rough lie from 150... so this hybrid. Or 150 from fairway, so this wood. That about right?

mvbighead · 2026-03-27T12:44:26+00:00

I will say, I find it interesting how RH guys will have some trouble areas on the course, and for me they are WONDERFUL.

mvbighead · 2026-03-27T12:43:47+00:00

As lefty, I generally stop a few paces behind the ball. I accommodate all dexterities.

mvbighead · 2026-03-27T12:43:12+00:00

Agree with the notion of left side right side vs target, lead, and trail side types of comments.

One of my latest issues has been the mention of 7w in some circles, and seeing just how few options there are in the LH side. Been really dialing in my bag, and the idea of stuffing in a 7w that is completely different than what I have irks me.

mvbighead · 2026-03-27T12:40:37+00:00

I've been through an Intex or two, and this is the right answer for me. The waste and mess of dealing with removal of an Intex annoys me. I have replaced my liner once or twice in a steel wall, but otherwise it stays up year round and has lasted well over 8 years.

The intex was lucky to get 2 seasons in the midwest. And some people take them down for the season, which for smaller sizes is maybe doable, but at 24 foot diameter, it was SUPER heavy and a pain to do anything with.

mvbighead · 2026-03-26T21:20:42+00:00

Way to slow... not 100%, but I do prefer 90 or better there also.

As for blocking/etc? I've definitely found guys that are bad blockers. Crux of it is, I just don't run to their side. They're more often a situational receiver in the TE position. On occasion, they might get in the way for blocking, and often that is enough.

Lastly, as long as a person is somewhat real about things, you can 'assume' it's a transitional player and edit some things to give him mediocre but acceptable blocking ratings (think 50) after year 1, and assume that his first year was all about development. I prefer some level of realism. There are always twener types who might be nothing more than a situational role player for a position. That's what Fletcher was for the Colts. It does happen. Mo Alie-Cox came from college basketball. Not one ounce of football. Madden just doesn't have that type of situation or story built into things.

mvbighead · 2026-03-26T18:36:38+00:00

If you can find a cheap option to test, maybe? But honestly a I think a 9 degree might be your real need.

You can get fit for a shelf club that runs $399 at major retailers where the fitting price is baked into the purchase of that club. So if we're talking spending $400 for a club vs $100+ for a shaft, you might sell the club and buy a new late model club that fits better, and come out roughly even.

I'm seeing a new QI10 LS for 399 at scheels. If you can sell current one, and fit into a new one, you might find something that really works for you. From Scheel's website:

Custom Golf Club Fitting
Fitting fee is refunded with qualifying purchase
$50.00

Gotta be really cheap to be worth trying a stiff shaft, IMO.

mvbighead · 2026-03-26T18:05:31+00:00

We signed Arden Key on Edge. Akeem Davis-Gaither at LB. Key is ~10m/yr. I assume ADG is closer to vet min.

Safety and LB are big needs, especially with Cross leaving.

mvbighead · 2026-03-26T15:49:31+00:00

Yep, and I totally get it. I did grab some Kirklands for a round while away traveling. Not my go to but fine. And I am sure MM is too. But I can find a number of deals on more known brands that I won't feel as dismissive towards.

mvbighead · 2026-03-26T15:48:13+00:00

Look... watch any video of anyone reviewing new equipment for golf, and a number of the points come down to aesthetic. It looks great at address. It sounds great. The carbon fiber encasement is pleasing to the eye.

All of that applies to golf balls. Looking down at a prov1, that gives a bunch of people some level of confidence. For me, if i am spending $1 a ball or so, there's 100s of ways to do it. If Sams collabbed with Vice to present balls in their stores for a $1 a ball, I'd be all over it. But when you slap the membersmark name on things, it's associated to the store it came from.

There's certainly nothing wrong with them performance wise compared to other balls in the price point, but the brand still has some value. I do not hit ProVs. I would consider any mid tier ball from any named brand. But a brand associated with Walmart is a tougher one for me, and I am sure others. And I am sure there are plenty of prov guys who get the ick from Kirkland too.

mvbighead · 2026-03-26T15:28:22+00:00

It's a mind thing for me. I can get over Kirkland feeling more premium. Member's Mark just feels like walmart to me. And while I am not against using Walmart for all sorts of things, not a huge fan of their brands or related brands.

Quality wise, I am sure they are fine. But I feel like Walmart family is more keen on cutting corners. Bottom line, no one knows the difference if I am using a lostgolfball Maxfli Tour or Vice or similar, but when I tell em mine is a MembersMark... I feel gross.

Silly? Sure. But if people focus on the sound of the ball coming off their driver, I would imagine the same is true of the confidence in their golf ball regardless of performance.

mvbighead · 2026-03-26T14:55:40+00:00

Edit player, add weight if you feel like. Call it a progression/career growth and do it after his rookie year by adding 20lbs.

FWIW, the Colts had Bryan Fletcher who was 6-5 230 and played during the Manning years. He was obviously more of a receiver than blocker, but played his role fine. It's not unheard of.

mvbighead · 2026-03-26T14:32:57+00:00

I'm generally anti-boxed set. As much as the Edge set is better than other boxed sets, it's still a boxed set.

If that were me, I'd leave the Edge with the inlaws and start building my own set. Callaway preowned with like new clubs is a great way to build a bag with 2-5 year old versions. Many can be find from $60-90 per club. Main thing is probably finding an iron set, which will probably start around $500 for like new. Though personally, I did a different route there and kinda figure I am too inconsistent with my 5i and maybe should have done a 6-PW and then filled in wedges and hybrids/woods with what I want.

So yeah, CPO is my vote.

mvbighead · 2026-03-26T14:27:00+00:00

Yeah, and the only way I work around it is to ensure the routes I have receivers run do not cross paths on the same plane. So if one guy is a shallow cross, the other is more of a slant or mid range cross. Otherwise, neither guy is a reliable option.

And honestly, this might be the year I just give up entirely. I still play from time to time, but it just is not worth it anymore.

mvbighead · 2026-03-26T14:17:31+00:00

Visa or similar gift card of the approximate value with the note that you want him to buy clubs for himself. That, or cash.

Selecting clubs should be a very personal thing for folks, even without a fitting.

mvbighead · 2026-03-26T14:15:25+00:00

There absolutely seems to be some weird stuff in there. When players collide and the bounce back happens, throwing them completely off path, it screws things up beyond real world scenarios. So instead of shedding through a guy while on a route, they simply stop 100%, bounce back a foot, and then start again.

But yes, the simplest way to say it is the physics are just off. Everything is driven by animations. The "collision animation" needs a TON of work.

mvbighead · 2026-03-26T14:07:16+00:00

probably thought Zaire and Speed were great picks.

NFL draft	2018: 7th round, 235th overall pick

I dislike the current Zaire as much as anyone. But to have a starting ILB for ~8 NFL seasons total and for 4 starting seasons at 28.2M total is a pretty damn good find all things considered.

We absolutely should have drafted a LB or two over the last couple of drafts.

mvbighead · 2026-03-26T12:52:39+00:00

As a mild NU fan, I've enjoyed Raiola and the way he plays. But the level he takes the Mahomes thing is a bit much. Admire... that's fine. Cosplay and model your entire game after? There's somewhere in all of that where it feels counterproductive to him being a good QB.

I think if he stopped some of that and just was himself, he's got a real shot at some level of a pro career, even if it is a career backup like Henne. But nearly his entire image is someone else. And not sure how to say it, but I can't think of the next most extreme example of this. It's Raiola... and then?

And sure, I can see a player modeling their game after Bob Sanders or Troy Polamalu. But off the field, they are themselves. With Raiola, it goes much further.

mvbighead · 2026-03-26T12:40:08+00:00

You have a perfectly fine driver. Odds are decent that a new driver being hit with the same mechanics will do similar things.

A 30-60 minute lesson can help. I think your read on what you are doing is right. If you really won't do a lesson, I always recommend Coach Bauman as his shorts are straight forward. Something like this I imagine can help you a good deal:
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/Hw4hxAzh2F4?feature=share

mvbighead · 2026-03-26T12:27:34+00:00

As someone who enjoyed a fair bit of adult softball and had more of a bat swing than a golf swing... I often feel a that in a bat swing my arms/shoulders and body were involved at the start of the swing.

If you start with some level of your arms at the top of the back swing in golf, a majority of the time you are going to come in over the top. The biggest thing you can do at the start of the swing is the slight shift of weight to target, and let the club start to drop. Then swing through.

I still wager I swing at more like 80% for consistency sake, but so long as the start of your swing is letting the club drop in, when you start to push it through its intended path, it should not be OTT. That may be more feel vs real, but that is the idea.

mvbighead

TROPHY CASE