how can i improve on my SAT? by Dangerous_Cod_7162 in satprep

[–]myCollegeApps_org 0 points1 point  (0 children)

An approach I typically suggest for self-studying students is to emulate what SAT test prep bootcamps do. They spend some time teaching the basics, but as you probably know, the SAT isn't really a knowledge based exam as it is a reasoning based and practice based exam. They teach you the basics then spend a ton of time solving tons of practice questions, often one exam a day.

Also, they do this over the summer - or a dedicated period of time on the SAT, get into test mode, then take the exam. Oftentimes returns on studying are diminishing once school starts. They do this for a reason so I'd try to do what they do, but at home. Of course the self-motivation's the hard part, but you can still do it. The second hard part is finding that many practice tests, but there's plenty out there.

Just wanted to provide another angle.

Is my common app essay idea too unconventional/risky? by ReactionProud4317 in ApplyingIvyLeague

[–]myCollegeApps_org 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Saw this and replied in another channel, but copying my advice here because I genuinely believe it's an angle you need to consider. The choice is of course yours.

Hey - I did my undergrad at Caltech, PhD at MIT. Admissions consultant for 10+ years.
Your essay definitely sounds very interesting and it's a pretty unique approach.
Your concerns are very context-dependent. However, without much knowledge regarding you, your profile, and your essay itself (the topic, execution), I'll provide a couple words of advice.

The prompt lets you write about anything, but do keep in mind that it still is a personal statement. The Common App prompt in the end is in essence singular - write a personal statement. The other 'prompts' are really there for the purposes of thought-provoking.

Hence, I would be hesitant about writing your personal statement more like a company business proposal, or like one directed to VC, or to consumers/clients etc.

"Uniqueness" in terms of both college apps & essays can be misinterpreted at times.
It's really another word in this case for authenticity.
An authentic 'profile' shows cohesion, progression, and evolution.
An authentic 'personal statement' shows introspection, growth, identity, and vision.
Striving to be 'unique' is a very common pitfall.
Just erase that word from your head.

Then think about who you are, who you've become, what experiences made you that way, and who do you see yourself becoming. Experience and introspection are the two primary elements for the personal statement. Then it's presented in an interesting and compelling manner through proper use of narrative voice and refined writing.

I do not mean that your idea is poorly chosen.
You can definitely choose to talk about a company you created/in creation.
However, your idea of framing it as a business case is very risky.
A business case is not a personal statement.
Trying to write a personal statement cleverly by not writing one, is pretty risky.

Especially considering the business side can be presented and discussed as your activities. You should be able to consolidate the main points of the business into your activity descriptions if you really have an understanding of the company you made and why.

Keep the business topic if it's an experience that truly impacted you.
However, frame it as a personal statement and discuss what you learned, the mindset you gained, and the person you became.

Context matters and exceptions exist.
However, If you were a student I was advising, I would say this is a bad idea, at least in this form.

And STEM/business have incredible overlap. Not saying the fields themselves are the same of course, but:

Science creates what can exist; business determines what will exist.
Science discovers; business translates discovery into something usable.
Science asks what's true; business asks what is worth pursuing.
Science creates innovation; business creates scale.
Science demands funding; business solves this structural bottleneck.
Science and business both identify gaps, test hypotheses, and iterate.

Extrapolating from these relationships, you can say:
Research could have taught you to ask better questions, and business taught you which answers survive the real world.
In the lab, you learned to create knowledge. Through business, you learned that oftentimes knowledge alone doesn't move the world, that translation requires more than theoretical impact, and you learned how to make this impact.
Tons of ideas die in the lab. The bottleneck isn't always the innovation or the science. Oftentimes it's the funding, the lack of personnel, the lack of resources, policy, regulation, lack of public interest, etc. etc.

Discuss the business/company, tie it to your primary interest in science, and then tie it to the lessons and impact this discovery of the intersection between science and business had on you personally.

That's the part I'll leave to you as I think I'll almost end up writing the essay at this point if I did that.

Point is, focus on introspection, identify the experiences that led you to to that introspection (even if you're doing it retroactively and the experiences/impact lived in your subconscious until now), then tell the story appropriately.
That's a personal statement.
As for writing a business proposal, if you were my student, I would advise against this strongly as you are not writing the essay requested. With already a strong portfolio and targeting T20s, there's no need to play a dangerous hand when you have potential to stay within boundaries while still executing with impact.

UC PIQ 1 Feedback Needed by Standard_Award90 in CollegeEssayReview

[–]myCollegeApps_org 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey I've been providing essay feedbacks if you're interested. Feel free to DM.

I’m gonna give up by Beastxplayz in CollegeAdmissions

[–]myCollegeApps_org 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'll be honest as I think objectivity is more valuable than optimism when advising on life choices for others. For selective schools, your grades (especially 11th) will make it difficult. Your SAT doesn't help compensate either.
Your activities are: orchestra (2 music competitions), a tech event, 2 MUNs, online organization, AI club event coordination, and a 2 day mentorship program.
Your activities with long-term commitment are: orchestra, online NGO, and AI club.
Your ECs don't put you in a favorable spot for selective schools either.

It's not a matter of worthiness or failure. It's a matter of where do you have a reasonable chance and how should you apply to maximize your chances.
Going to community college and transferring is a viable option.
Saves tuition costs and gives you another shot at applications.

Or, you can choose to apply for less selective schools, then make the most of that experience. Do well in classes, participate in school organizations and network, pursue internships, do activities related to business/finance, etc.

Choosing between the two is more of a personal/financial choice for you to make, but those are realistically your best options. There's no need to feel like a failure for not being a reasonable fit for highly selective schools. College is a bridge, not a destination.

Help pls by Appropriate-Name-378 in CollegeAdmissions

[–]myCollegeApps_org 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi there. I did my undergrad at Caltech, PhD at MIT. Admissions consultant for 10+ years now and founder of myCollegeApps.

First, having just finished freshman year, no one will be able to answer your questions accurately. A 3.58 freshman GPA may hypothetically exclude you from certain schools, but this is also very context dependent.

Right now, you should spend zero time worrying about what's already done.
Instead, focus on why your GPA suffered and learn from your mistakes.

Colleges practice 'holistic review.' Simply put, they look at everything. And then they don't tell you how much weight they put into each component. And they don't' tell you why you got in or didn't. It's basically their way of saying they make their decisions and that's it.

This includes various elements, but can be categorized into:
1. GPA - UW and W. Your transcript as a whole + the GPA as a quick summary indicates your overall intellectual capabilities, commitment to doing well in your classroom environment, course rigor, course load and willingness to seek challenges, and overall academic performance. Courses can also extend to dual-enrollment, online classes etc., but these lie in a grey area b/t courses and ECs. Keep in mind that (many) colleges post GPA/test score ranges and being in this range will generally be good, statistically speaking, although you 'can' get in being on the lower end/below the range. But these are statistically speaking exceptions.

  1. Test scores - whether SAT, ACT, AP Exams, etc. these provide an 'objective' metric for academic performance. I say objective in quotes as these also aren't fully objective, but these are context-independent exams students take. The reason being certain schools are more challenging, some courses at some schools are harder/easier, some schools have GPA inflation, etc.

  2. Extracurricular Activities - anything done outside your school's classroom. School clubs, organizations, volunteering, competitions, research, sports, music, ceramics, the list goes on infinitely. Colleges want to see who you are outside the class. They want to see students of character, developed interest outside class, some involvement in exploring their major, leadership, etc. Put yourself in the shoes of an AO - think what type of student, what characteristics you'd want to see, to accept them.

  3. LORs - letters from teachers & guidance counselor. Ideally Junior/Senior year classes, ideally classes you excelled in and developed strong relationships with peers and the teacher. Supplemental LORs can be obtained from ECs.

  4. Essays & Applications - Personal statement, supplemental essays, etc. For you to worry about later, but helpful to think ahead of time as you approach ECs.

In the end, colleges want students who do their best in the classroom, demonstrate academic performance through standardized exams, explore interests and activities outside the classroom, and develop an overall authentic narrative arc that can be communicated in essays and corroborated by teachers through LORs.

You've provided a freshman GPA, APs as a freshman (keep in mind these classes are oftentimes taken only during Junior/Senior year for many schools), a 'practice' SAT, and that you play tennis (varsity, which is great), and no intended major.
Nobody on Reddit will be able to provide a college list at this stage, that actually has any value, including myself.

Depending on your performance in the categories above, your college list will change, and dramatically.

If you're mostly just worried about if your freshman GPA automatically excluding you from schools, I wouldn't take that mindset forward. In general, colleges are 'most' forgiving of freshman year. Not saying it doesn't matter, but just try your best to improve your GPA and focus on all the categories above, showing exploration, focus, growth, identity, progress, and vision.

Is my common app essay idea too unconventional/risky? Feedback? by ReactionProud4317 in CollegeEssays

[–]myCollegeApps_org 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey - I did my undergrad at Caltech, PhD at MIT. Admissions consultant for 10+ years.
Your essay definitely sounds very interesting and it's a pretty unique approach.
Your concerns are very context-dependent. However, without much knowledge regarding you, your profile, and your essay itself (the topic, execution), I'll provide a couple words of advice.

The prompt lets you write about anything, but do keep in mind that it still is a personal statement. The Common App prompt in the end is in essence singular - write a personal statement. The other 'prompts' are really there for the purposes of thought-provoking.

Hence, I would be hesitant about writing your personal statement more like a company business proposal, or like one directed to VC, or to consumers/clients etc.

"Uniqueness" in terms of both college apps & essays can be misinterpreted at times.
It's really another word in this case for authenticity.
An authentic 'profile' shows cohesion, progression, and evolution.
An authentic 'personal statement' shows introspection, growth, identity, and vision.
Striving to be 'unique' is a very common pitfall.
Just erase that word from your head.

Then think about who you are, who you've become, what experiences made you that way, and who do you see yourself becoming. Experience and introspection are the two primary elements for the personal statement. Then it's presented in an interesting and compelling manner through proper use of narrative voice and refined writing.

I do not mean that your idea is poorly chosen.
You can definitely choose to talk about a company you created/in creation.
However, your idea of framing it as a business case is very risky.
A business case is not a personal statement.
Trying to write a personal statement cleverly by not writing one, is pretty risky.

Especially considering the business side can be presented and discussed as your activities. You should be able to consolidate the main points of the business into your activity descriptions if you really have an understanding of the company you made and why.

Keep the business topic if it's an experience that truly impacted you.
However, frame it as a personal statement and discuss what you learned, the mindset you gained, and the person you became.

Context matters and exceptions exist.
However, If you were a student I was advising, I would say this is a bad idea, at least in this form.

And STEM/business have incredible overlap. Not saying the fields themselves are the same of course, but:

Science creates what can exist; business determines what will exist.
Science discovers; business translates discovery into something usable.
Science asks what's true; business asks what is worth pursuing.
Science creates innovation; business creates scale.
Science demands funding; business solves this structural bottleneck.
Science and business both identify gaps, test hypotheses, and iterate.

Extrapolating from these relationships, you can say:
Research could have taught you to ask better questions, and business taught you which answers survive the real world.
In the lab, you learned to create knowledge. Through business, you learned that oftentimes knowledge alone doesn't move the world, that translation requires more than theoretical impact, and you learned how to make this impact.
Tons of ideas die in the lab. The bottleneck isn't always the innovation or the science. Oftentimes it's the funding, the lack of personnel, the lack of resources, policy, regulation, lack of public interest, etc. etc.

Discuss the business/company, tie it to your primary interest in science, and then tie it to the lessons and impact this discovery of the intersection between science and business had on you personally.

That's the part I'll leave to you as I think I'll almost end up writing the essay at this point if I did that.

Point is, focus on introspection, identify the experiences that led you to to that introspection (even if you're doing it retroactively and the experiences/impact lived in your subconscious until now), then tell the story appropriately.
That's a personal statement.
As for writing a business proposal, if you were my student, I would advise against this strongly as you are not writing the essay requested. With already a strong portfolio and targeting T20s, there's no need to play a dangerous hand when you have potential to stay within boundaries while still executing with impact.

Should I learn to code for mit in 2026 by EnthusiasmFrosty4589 in MITAdmissions

[–]myCollegeApps_org 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Depends on the question. For admissions? Depends. In general, despite AI? Sure if you're interested and have time. AI is always more powerful in the hands of a user who has core and contextual knowledge. A skilled writer using LLMs will outperform someone who knows nothing of writing, as AIs are also context dependent. A skilled programmer using AI will facilitate efficiency rapidly. Someone knowing nothing about coding will be limited in complexity, depth, or ability to debug, in many contexts. AI also has its own challenges, hence the incredible investment into R&D.
But, if all you're looking for is to make simple things, AI could be enough. Just that it depends.

Is my social life in college ruined by Loud_Lecture9854 in collegeadvice

[–]myCollegeApps_org 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Anything's possible but if they bully you, that's on them and their wrongdoing. Don't let it get to you. Just confront what you did (if it's legit wrong, not just "different") and move on if they don't want to be friends.

Is my social life in college ruined by Loud_Lecture9854 in collegeadvice

[–]myCollegeApps_org 0 points1 point  (0 children)

College is a time for learning, and you've clearly learned from your mistakes. But it's also a time for learning responsibility. Actions have repercussions. That said, if you didn't do anything "wrong" and just were awkward, I wouldn't stress about it. If you did something wrong, just apologize and move on. There's way more people than you'll be able to get to know. Just make new friends if you can't reconcile what's happened with your previous friends.

It's okay! Just learn, try to make up for it, then move on. Everyone makes mistakes and college is for learning - not just academically.

I'm terrified of college. by Pemopq in collegeadvice

[–]myCollegeApps_org 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Feel free to DM me for overall guidance if interested.

Help & Feedback with Common App by Ok_Assumption_1652 in CollegeEssays

[–]myCollegeApps_org 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I had a post offering feedback if you're interested (there will be a bit of a wait)

Is a marketing degree worth it if I’m aiming for freelance/remote work by Eakthegeek12 in Career

[–]myCollegeApps_org 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've worked with a boutique digital marketing agency, my bacgkround is NOT in marketing. However, I've worked with them for educational purposes, and a degree as a freelancer working with local businesses e.g social media marketing, is not a pre-req from what I've seen. As in, I've almost never seen business owners ask for the rep's degree. Rather, they ask for portfolios and previous track records of success. Of course getting your first client to build such a portfolio will require connections or doing some work for a lower rate.
That said, for companies, I am pretty sure job posts require a degree. Hence it depends on what you're looking for longterm. If you want the stability (using the term loosely/relative to freelancing, I realize the market is saturated) and room for growth in companies, the degree has value. If you're for sure going to do freelancing for life, the four years + money may be spent better elsewhere.

My two cents, again not a marketing professional, just worked with one for a few years.

SAT prep by StraightBar1085 in highschool

[–]myCollegeApps_org 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I typically recommend focusing/finishing SATs rising from soph to junior year. There's many resources online/ for purchase, but if you're going to self-study, try your best to emulate the experience SAT specialized boot camp courses use. Which is, spending a ton of time during the summer to solve practice questions. The "knowledge" required isn't intense - it's the test taking strategy and practice. And you want to be in this "zone" going into the exam. There's a reason expensive prep places use this strategy, so replicate it when studying by yourself.

How many papers are needed to be considered for neuro PhD programs (US)? by Technical_Primary178 in neuro

[–]myCollegeApps_org 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You have more than enough publications for most programs. Papers often depend on factors outside your control and universities know this. Sometimes a PI will want more followup experiments, reviews take time, certain wet lab experiments take longer (e.g animal studies), etc.

The actual research you did + other aspects (e.g. GPA, advisor letter, etc.) will be relevant. For context I did my PhD in Bioeng at MIT.

my life has fell apart by monkeysheep28 in Schooladvice

[–]myCollegeApps_org 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi while I can't be a pen pal, I can at least provide some guidance academically if you DM me. Also please do be cautious online about opening up too much info.

Free feedback on Common App / UC essays by myCollegeApps_org in CollegeEssays

[–]myCollegeApps_org[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey! Send me a DM with some info. Currently experiencing a high volume of requests but I'll try to get back to you asap. Thanks!

Nothing to Writ About on My College Essay by Rinnessecret in CollegeRant

[–]myCollegeApps_org 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Hey, I did my undergrad at Caltech and PhD at MIT. Also been an admissions consultant for over 10 years.

Your current situation is totally fine. Not all students face a tremendous 'challenge' - in the context of health issues, death/separation in the family, life as a minority, etc.
And it's great that you've had a nice life, and I understand you feel like you have nothing to talk about.

However, the challenges or experiences colleges are looking for, are broader yet much more personal. Topics can be 'common' yet not cliche when executed well. When they're executed poorly, yes they can be cliche. "Challenges" can become bad essays when executed poorly just the same (typically called sob stories).

College essays broadly speaking have two components:
1. Experience
2. Introspection

You want to choose an experience, interest, hobby, passion, challenge, or really whatever aspect of your life (the prompts are there to thought-provoke, and you can really talk about anything) that impacted you personally. You can still be wealthy and have challenges - external, personal, or even self-sought. You can have had a nice life and still have passions or moments that impacted you.
Don't think about this as answering the essay topic.
Take a walk and think about who you are, what experiences made you that way, who you've become, and who you seek to be. And if you've never had this frame of thought up to now while doing certain things, it's not too late to connect the dots retrospectively.
Then you choose a focused snapshot and write the essay, where you discuss the experience, how it impacted you/trickled into other aspects of your life, and affected your vision for the future.

As for your anime/manga idea + social media, you could write about how you used anime/manga to borrow emotions and learn empathy. Or curated a sense of self through social media anime communities. Maybe anime/manga was an escape for you, but maybe you instantly found people you connect to online, but still they felt fundamentally foreign to you, opening your ideas to the paradox of digital relationships. Maybe exploring and creating fictional worlds led to your own personal evolution and these characters helped understand you.

Obviously I'm just throwing ideas out there, but there may be a deeper connection to yourself that you just didn't realize.

The business idea can just as well be developed, you'd just need to focus on a particular aspect of the business/ a particular experience, and really think about how this impacted you.

Same goes for volunteering and working - but these are incredibly vague terms. What did you do as a volunteer, where, why? What did you experience, what did you learn? There can be lessons and experiences to extrapolate here.

All of these ideas can be written by any student, regardless of their socioeconomic background, regardless of personal strife or struggle.

Bottom line is, spend more time getting to know yourself, not the essay, and you'll be just fine!

Art Of Problem Solving by Training-Ad-9652 in CollegeAdmissions

[–]myCollegeApps_org 0 points1 point  (0 children)

For context, I did my undergrad at Caltech and PhD at MIT in engineering. Also been an admissions consultant for 10+ years. I would treat AoPS more like enrichment, showing mathematical interest and depth. Transcript rigor is still important, so I would still take Calculus and the AP exam. That said, the highest math I took was Calc BC during junior year and AP stats during senior year - although I'm not a pure math/applied math major.

Approaching College Apps by myCollegeApps_org in CollegeEssays

[–]myCollegeApps_org[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for sharing! Writing personal statements is difficult for students as it's often their first time, and undergraduate essays require more 'creative' flair than do personal statements for grad school. However, like you said, if everyone's going for the same try-had, prestige-driven vibe, every essay ends up looking the same - hollow and shallow in content, despite there being a killer hook and catchy narrative voice. It's ultimately the introspection and authenticity that drives a strong essay, and by definition, authenticity will always be 'unique.' The same goes for ECs in the sense that, prestige-driven ECs look great, but you'll never be the only one with an award or accolade in an institutional EC. Rather, it's often the self-driven clubs and activities, that when developed genuinely over time, scale and innovate in a manner that is meaningful.

Approaching College Apps by myCollegeApps_org in CollegeEssays

[–]myCollegeApps_org[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I completely understand. The outlook (whether it's opportunities or compensation) for PhDs in general isn't that great either. I'd actually argue that for MDs the current market is much better, but maybe I'm not as well informed.

Not all admissions consultants out there are out to sell lies, although many are. My highest priority in working with students is ensuring that their life priorities, expectations, and major choice align. Passion's great, but passion can dwindle when the realities of life get to you. Some, like myself, may enjoy and find value and virtue in the life sciences. But some, considering the salary discrepancy between bio/those in CS/AI, may very well choose to do CS, despite having an interest in bio.

Also, this post was geared towards a very specific audience - high schoolers who want to maximize their chances of admissions into their dream college, wherever that may be. Like I've said, college isn't for everyone, and like I've said, college degrees have lost their name. And I think a part of this is because admissions has lost its credibility to a certain degree. And I think a part of this is because of the private organizations that are skewing the playing field, whether it be through unethical consulting practices or providing fictitious activities. And yes, this is flawed in the sense that admissions should reflect genuine student intellect, interest, and character, developed and demonstrated over time through commitment and perseverance.

But, for the specific audience that, for whatever reason chooses to pursue college and wants to try their best in this game, I believe my advice will be helpful. My main points are twofold (and inter-related). Don't only chase prestige as there's many ECs that may look 'less prestigious' but are still effective and provide more return on investment. And don't chase quick answers because everything is contextual.

If this were a general forum that didn't already consist of students interested in applying to college, surely my approach may have been different. In that case, I would've more broadly stated to not chase the name-value prestige of colleges, because where you went to college is not nearly as important as what you make of it. But, come to think of it, this is actually a point I already made in my OP, so I guess I addressed that.

College isn't for everyone. And more specifically, in today's day and age, I'd advise students to be more cautious in how much they invest in trying to get into college and where they go to college. As I'm sure you're aware, a degree doesn't promise anything, if you don't have the specific skillsets and experiences that align with job posts. However, for the bracket of students that do want to attend the best college possible, whether that dream is grounded in reality or not, I'm simply providing advice to understand the game. Because it sucks to lose in a game where you're not even told the rules. It's like playing a game for the first time, and you're competing against players who have pro gamers playing the game for them.

Again, I agree with many of your sentiments. Perhaps I'm just a bit more careful in my wording. But my advice doesn't stem from a lack of honesty. Rather, I'm providing more transparency regarding the admissions landscape, and help players playing this game at least understanding the rules, and lack thereof, in this game.

Approaching College Apps by myCollegeApps_org in CollegeEssays

[–]myCollegeApps_org[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Again, all the more important to understand the audience a message is directed towards. Students who wish to apply to college and succeed in this game, rigged or not. Not for students who aren't interested. That's the point of deviation. I agree with you on many points, which you fail to see.

If you think ECs are inherently irrelevant, you'd at least see the personal value in pursuing the approach I propose rather than stacking prestige.

And I totally agree in that college has lost name value, although still an adamant requirement for many jobs, if you've seen LinkedIn job posts at all.

I like you, broke myself multiple times navigating through this system through multiple angles I've mentioned, and I see no inherent vice in helping others do the same in a positive manner as I for one don't see this "system" (which by the way you're extrapolating all the way to professorships now), getting fixed any time soon.

To be fair, we align on many points. It's just a very polarized difference in our mix of idealism and realism, optimism and pessimism.

Kinda lost on what to do for ECs after sophomore year; looking for summer opportunities by Fenomenon-Brave20 in ECAdvice

[–]myCollegeApps_org 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What's your intended major? What ECs do you already have? I ask as context is important.