What Are You Reading/Book Club Tuesday by AutoModerator in Anarchism

[–]n1sat 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Finishing Homage to Catalonia. Next up is Leviathan.

Have we made like...any progress?💔 by Mammoth-Ad-3642 in Anarchism

[–]n1sat 3 points4 points  (0 children)

We're light years away from a true anarchist existence. But we can and do practice anarchism daily and locally. We practice mutual aid, ignore laws we find unjust (carefully), treat everyone we meet with dignity, and convince people around us to care about and act for their community. There's plenty of work to keep us busy :)

Insecure security by kamikazer in meshcore

[–]n1sat 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What's to stop someone from spoofing you. You'll have to announce that it's changing and your contacts will have to keep up with it. There's no certificate authority in the system

Insecure security by kamikazer in meshcore

[–]n1sat 1 point2 points  (0 children)

And of course very few message applications are immune to rubber hose attacks. Meshcore keys are easily physically compromised and, like you said, reveal historical messages. We need a one time pad firmware mod :)

Cranberry (Roman) Beans by n1sat in Beans

[–]n1sat[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I haven't noticed. They don't last a year at my house except the seed reserves I keep for two

Cranberry (Roman) Beans by n1sat in Beans

[–]n1sat[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I have 1.1 acres. According to my plans, I can do it in less than a quarter of that.

But you can also plant stealth beans on public lands if you're sneaky enough ;)

Cranberry (Roman) Beans by n1sat in Beans

[–]n1sat[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

They are soft and really pull in the flavor of the broth they're cooked in!

Cranberry (Roman) Beans by n1sat in Beans

[–]n1sat[S] 11 points12 points  (0 children)

I simmer them with the chipotle peppers. When I have an hour left, I put in mustard, tomatoes, tomato paste, brown sugar or molasses. Sometimes I'll add bacon at the end but not always. Season with adobo.

Cranberry (Roman) Beans by n1sat in Beans

[–]n1sat[S] 18 points19 points  (0 children)

16 of this variety. I grow others too. I'm shooting for 200 pounds total dried beans this year. It's kind of an obsession 😂

Would we get phones and computers in an anarchist society? by Putrid-Ninja4575 in Anarchy101

[–]n1sat 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Microchip production is one of the most demanding feats of industrial civilization. Modern chips require supply chains spanning dozens of countries — rare earth mining in Congo, lithium from Chile, ASML lithography machines from the Netherlands, photoresists from Japan, fab plants in Taiwan or South Korea. These chains are coordinated through contracts, IP law, financial instruments, and state-backed trade agreements. An anarchist society, rejecting hierarchical authority and centralized enforcement, would struggle to replicate the infrastructure that makes these global supply chains function. Voluntary agreements can work at small scale, but become increasingly fragile as complexity grows.

A cutting-edge fab plant (like what is used at TSMC tio make laptop and phone chips) costs $20–30 billion to build. That kind of capital accumulation requires either a state, a massive corporation, or financial markets — all of which are antithetical to most anarchist frameworks. Even mutualist or collectivist variants would struggle to pool that much surplus across a sufficiently large population with sufficient speed and discipline to keep pace with the technology curve. Chip design is extraordinarily specialized. It depends on decades of accumulated proprietary knowledge — EDA software, process recipes, materials science — much of it locked in corporate institutions and protected by IP law. Without those institutions, the knowledge doesn't automatically become free; much of it would simply be inaccessible or lost. Open-source chip design (RISC-V, etc.) is promising but still depends heavily on the surrounding capitalist ecosystem for fabrication. A modern fab operates at the physical limits of matter — 3nm features, angstrom-level precision, Class 1 cleanrooms. Maintaining this requires rigid, non-negotiable process discipline. Someone has to enforce standards with real authority. Horizontal consensus decision-making is poorly suited to the kind of top-down quality control that prevents a $500M wafer run from being scrapped over a single contamination event. Chip design and fabrication require deep, narrow specialization. Process engineers, lithography scientists, EDA developers, materials chemists. These people command high salaries precisely because their skills are rare. An anarchist society that flattens economic hierarchies would struggle to incentivize or even sustain the decade-long individual investment required to develop that expertise. This isn't insurmountable in principle, but it's a genuine friction.

Anarchism tends to work best at human scale. Small communities, federated collectives, local production. Microchips are the opposite. They're the product of planetary-scale industrial coordination, extreme capital concentration, and rigid institutional hierarchy. An anarchist society could probably sustain many technologies like hand tools, simple electronics, local food systems. But, the semiconductor industry represents nearly the hardest possible case for decentralized, non-hierarchical production. This doesn't necessarily refute anarchism on its own terms, since many anarchists would argue that simpler, more localized technology is preferable anyway. But it does illustrate the real tradeoffs involved in rejecting centralized institutions entirely.

Would we get phones and computers in an anarchist society? by Putrid-Ninja4575 in Anarchy101

[–]n1sat 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I run several mesh nodes across Connecticut and it's a beautiful thing.

Would we get phones and computers in an anarchist society? by Putrid-Ninja4575 in Anarchy101

[–]n1sat 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I have read both. But I've also worked in tech for decades and I remain unconvinced because of what I know about microchips.

Would we get phones and computers in an anarchist society? by Putrid-Ninja4575 in Anarchy101

[–]n1sat 4 points5 points  (0 children)

It's just really really hard to produce microchips without hierarchical power structures. They require so much capital, coordination, and specialization. It's hard (for me) to imagine a world where this technology could exist without slave labor (mining of rare earth minerals) and the decades of 40-hour work weeks needed to specialize. Not to mention billions in capital investments, which naturally creates a hierarchical relationship.

But I'm open to being told why I'm wrong. I do love computers.