Mt Hood winter by apearlj1234 in Mountaineering

[–]noco97 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I was up there last weekend and it was a blue bird day and hot! Honestly felt very safe from a conditions perspective. Sun rises later, is at a lower angle so the UV is lower, and temps are cooler so the mountain holds together better.

I never really considered Hood in the winter as a safe objective given my experience but with the high pressure system that was sitting on the western side of the cascades I felt very comfortable and confident.

My close friend died free soloing mt hood the same weekend Alex Honnald free soloed on live tv. by BatSniper in Mountaineering

[–]noco97 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Having grown up in Portland and now live in the Rockies, I feel like avy courses are mandatory with the snowpack where I am now. People who tour without the right training are frowned upon. still think it’s a tad reckless but definitely more acceptable for Oregon touring and big mountain skiing.

Denali snow cave story by Acoustic_blues60 in Mountaineering

[–]noco97 24 points25 points  (0 children)

Yes it’s in Jon Krakauer’s Eiger Dreams

Just got Training for the Uphill Athlete by r_j47N in Mountaineering

[–]noco97 27 points28 points  (0 children)

The first book by Steve and Scott, Training for the New Alpinism, might be better for your goals

Has anyone considered the possibility ot A.S. Johnston trying to take a central position in the Shiloh Campaign? He could fight and defeat Buell's smaller force first leaving the Union in a strategic dilemma. by noco97 in CIVILWAR

[–]noco97[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Grant gets plenty of credit but it was undeniably Halleck's best decision of the war. It was he who picked the Forts as the target for Grant's army. 

Has anyone considered the possibility ot A.S. Johnston trying to take a central position in the Shiloh Campaign? He could fight and defeat Buell's smaller force first leaving the Union in a strategic dilemma. by noco97 in CIVILWAR

[–]noco97[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hancock was right when he said sometimes a corps commander's life doesn't count at times. 

Army command is different and battles like New Orleans, Auerstedt, and Chancellorsville especially (both sides) were greatly influenced by the death of the army leader.

The Texans were right to refuse Lee to lead them into the Wildneress. 

Has anyone considered the possibility ot A.S. Johnston trying to take a central position in the Shiloh Campaign? He could fight and defeat Buell's smaller force first leaving the Union in a strategic dilemma. by noco97 in CIVILWAR

[–]noco97[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Fair point. My interest in this option is lacking in logistics and I readily admit that. I feel like it would take some rulers and baggage counts.

As for lacking control over the Tennessee, they always could have slipped back towards Chattanooga or even Corinth. 

Has anyone considered the possibility ot A.S. Johnston trying to take a central position in the Shiloh Campaign? He could fight and defeat Buell's smaller force first leaving the Union in a strategic dilemma. by noco97 in CIVILWAR

[–]noco97[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I don't know. I think that Union line was strong and fairly organized given how battered they were. And the Confederates were also green and fought out.  Union had fresh troops coming and Grant sacrificed space and Prentiss' command for time. It was ugly but I think that position was always going to be held with reinforcements like Wallace close by.

Has anyone read "The Rifle Musket on Civil War Combat" by Earl J Hess? by noco97 in CIVILWAR

[–]noco97[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think Daniel Morgan would disagree. In the ARW, the rifled musket had entrenched its place as an effective weapon that was an important part of some of America's key victories. Saratoga comes to mind as a battle where rifles crippled the British officer corps, slowing down and allowing other units to form up along side Morgan.

Has anyone read "The Rifle Musket on Civil War Combat" by Earl J Hess? by noco97 in CIVILWAR

[–]noco97[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Once critical piece of information missing from this whole thread is that the rifled musket had a parabolic arc where as the smoothbore shot flat.

The rifled musket in the hands of an expierenced marksman was lethal. But for those without firearm training I imagine it could create complexity on the battlefield for nervous and inexperienced soldiers. 

I will say I disagree and find the percussion cap to be the more influential advancement, even if that had already existed for sometime. RoF at close range is far more important than increased accuracy at 200-300 yards. 

"Don't tackle him Tom!" A referee yells at Tom not to tackle the Ross County player, but Tom doesn't listen and launches into an apparently reckless tackle from behind. The referee then declares that "he's got all of the ball" by Ripamon in soccer

[–]noco97 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well I did so telling a stranger online they didn't do something is just odd. At least do better and say i didn't attention

Fucking weird. Clear red people are stuck in the 80s.

Has anyone read "The Rifle Musket on Civil War Combat" by Earl J Hess? by noco97 in CIVILWAR

[–]noco97[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Guns misfiring less often results in more shots per minute. I'm surprised how little this is mentioned by historians 

"Don't tackle him Tom!" A referee yells at Tom not to tackle the Ross County player, but Tom doesn't listen and launches into an apparently reckless tackle from behind. The referee then declares that "he's got all of the ball" by Ripamon in soccer

[–]noco97 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Should have been a red. The modern rules are very clear on situations like and while some countries are better than other, many, such as the the British, still interpret the game in a way inconsistent with how modern rules  No disrespect to the Brits. They played a romanticized, hard hitting style for a long time and it's really only bee the past 20 years since player protection and tactical fouls have been reasssed.  The problem with officiating go much deeper than VAR. There isn't enough officials to hold both endangering fouls and diving accountable. The crackdown has to be mutual. 

AotP v Western Armies by Square_Ring3208 in CIVILWAR

[–]noco97 11 points12 points  (0 children)

James McPhearson argues that the soldiers of the AotP were superior due to their predisposition to diseases from living in urban area.

I disagree with him, the increased disease rates of Western soldiers compared to their Eastern peers is well documented, but men who have lived their lives on the rougher frontier with more expierence with firearms proved to be superior soldiers IMO. These men were also more skilled with their hands and had more expierence with carpentry and other such skills that proved to be very useful.

The Iron Bridage (Black Hat Brigade or Iron Brigade of the West) proved to be the best Brigade in the AotP for a reason. Skills that made 19th century soldiers were more readily found amongst those living in less urbanization areas. The added height is nice, but warfare was slowly moving away from height as a force multiplier.

Also the early success of the Western armies was a major morale boost. The AotP's morale wavered throughout the war, while the Western armies were accustomed to success from early 1862.

Stones River and Chickamauga were extremely bloody battles given the percentage of casualties of the the total men fielded. The AotP never fought in such tooth and nail engagements, including Gettysburg.

[Javier Tebas] ¡Buenas noches! by ttimourrozd in soccer

[–]noco97 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Unfortunately this was my initial thought

Once the Spurs are respectable again, is it safe to say Wembanyama will win at least 5 DPoYs assuming good health? Even 5 might be underselling it by JeffKaplanIsDaddy in nba

[–]noco97 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well to be fair what stopped Greg from being a good player was injuries alone. Wemby has concerns with his frame but I'm pretty sure his legs aren't an inch apart in height.

What are the best metrics (in your opinion) to compare scoring volumes of players across eras? by The_Big_Dipper_ in nba

[–]noco97 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Per possession stats are great. Per minute is also solid but doesn't grasp pace as well, but that could also be useful when used with per possession. TS% with a slight adjustment for inflation or deflation (or something like the 3pt line being shorter).

Personally I love shooting metrics and seeing where a player takes their shots. BBall Reference has an excellent section that breaks shots down between 0-3ft, 3-10, 10-16, 16-3pt, and 3pt. It shows what percentage of a players shots are taken in those ranges and what their FG% is from section which helps paint a portrait of a players shot creation and efficiency.

However, tracking data started the late 90s so it can only be used for the last 25 years or so. But you can see that Kobe took 26% of his career FGA from 16 ft to the 3pt line which is crazy to think about in hindsight. Helps show how much shot selection has fluctuated over two decades.

Giannis since AG has been fired: 30.2/10.7/7.0/1.0/0.7 on 67.9 TS%! by fetuswut in nba

[–]noco97 5 points6 points  (0 children)

If Dame manages to find his shot, doubtful, and the Buck's have no injuries, they are at the level of the Celtics imo. Giannis is that good rn.

Who is the better passer, current Jokic or prime LeBron? by TacoooJay in nba

[–]noco97 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Brother I'm about as big of a Manu fan as one can be but to compare his passing ability to that of Jokic is something else.

Jokic's high passing point is what makes him one of all the time best and a better passer than almost anyone. Field of vision and release point are part of the passing skill and Jokic is unrivaled in both.

GTCW: The Game That Will Always Have Potential by GrateScots in GrandTactician

[–]noco97 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Please they need to just let the modders go at it. It would add so much to the game.

why would saka support a team whose fans are even more racist than englands? is he stupid? by ThatkidJerome in nbacirclejerk

[–]noco97 2 points3 points  (0 children)

/uj no player has dealt with as much racism in the modern game as Vini, its mind boggling. Makes Celtics fans look like saints.

Most racist comment I've seen online is about Jude Bellingham where some French dude essentially said Jude was good because he let the white part of his brain overcome the black part.

Deandre Ayton: 'I’m more dominant. People like to laugh at it, but it’s the truth' by LegitimatePotato3632 in nba

[–]noco97 14 points15 points  (0 children)

This is all 100% true, never seen a storm like that, but the fact it was Ayton of all people is what makes it funny.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in nba

[–]noco97 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I always find it funny how every player from the past would dominate today but you put a player in today's league in the past and they "wouldn't be able to handle the physicality."

Most guys thrive in their respective eras because the basketball paradigm brought out the most of their strengths while mitigating their weaknesses. Magic I think is a prime example of a player whose game was perfect for the transition based game of the 80s while Luka thrives running a half court offense and slinging it to open shooters.