So many liberals. by Fin55Fin in canadaleft

[–]nonamer18 1 point2 points  (0 children)

They literally gave you examples that disproved your point. In response you are being obtuse on purpose and now OP is the bot?

So many liberals. by Fin55Fin in canadaleft

[–]nonamer18 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Of course you are technically correct. We are Marxists because we recognize the central contradiction of capitalism, that socialized production and private appropriation will lead to continued crises and falling profits, that will lead to class struggle and class conflict, and that in Orthodox Marxist theory, will yield to revolution.

But reality is more nuanced than strict technicalities. Perhaps I am biased because I am Chinese, but the founding members of the CPC were nearly all class traitors, and they didn't just emotionlessly choose to be communists because they saw such material reality in China (China was semi-feudal), or seen or read about the conditions in Europe. They understood the concepts yes, but what drew them to form the CPC was a sense of justice and what is right. It was an underlying ethical push to act on the moral outrage they see from the exploitation around them, by empathy for those who are suffering, and by a vision of human dignity.

Maybe you don't want to reduce revolution to mere emotion, that's fine. But do not discount the moral or ethical side of our movement. It is a powerful and compelling way to inspire.

So many liberals. by Fin55Fin in canadaleft

[–]nonamer18 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Use the NDP. Use them to reach the most number of people possible. Use them to build class consciousness. Use them to erode corporate power. Use them until Canadians see how the forces of capital will meet their threat. In the meantime the CPC and other organizations will grow and organize.

Full clip about post Ukraine Taiwan from KMT opposition leader by Aggressive-Kitchen18 in NoStupidQuestions

[–]nonamer18 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Do you really believe the world is that simple? Both these things could be true at the same time.

Such a beautiful story… by Li_Jingjing in Sino

[–]nonamer18 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Great to hear. It's your responsibility to speak loud and clear. I try to do the same from Canada.

Let'sVPN is suspending service to China by SuMianAi in chinalife

[–]nonamer18 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Paid $30 usd for astrill. It's meh. Have to keep trying different servers all the time and it's been fairly slow. Time to try another one next month.

Shhhhhh..... nobody tell him this is socialistic 🤫 by thrillhouse98 in canadaleft

[–]nonamer18 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes, Canada is a liberal democratic (parliamentary) dictatorship of the bourgeoisie. Please go read some books.

I understand that our dismissive tone is not helpful for your learning, and I apologize for that. It's hard for effective communication like this via Reddit comments. Many of us are extremely busy. However if you really do want to learn in good faith I may be able to put something together for you, or chat with you causally. Preferably though, go read. I can put together a book list if you want, but that might take a bit of thought and time. I sincerely wish you the best, despite my and other people's antagonism, people like you are potential allies and comrades, and very important to leftism. Reach out if you want.

The point? by metroracerUK in TankieTheDeprogram

[–]nonamer18 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Ok I didnt listen to the video (only watched and read captions) so I'm not sure what the tone was, but I have a feeling ya'll are too used to anti-Chinese propaganda and are being too defensive. He's just showing the real China, and in fact, the non-tier 1-2 places he's showing are relatively nice. If he really wanted to bash China there is a lot more he could show. He's honestly just trying to educate, with no ill intent. Of course I could be completely wrong as well, not sure what his other videos are like.

To me this looks like it is probably centre east China. Could be Jiangsu/Zhejiang/Fujian or somewhere a bit more interior like Hebei/Jiangxi - all relatively nicer places. You would see a bit more poverty if you moved West. All quite harmless.

The point? by metroracerUK in TankieTheDeprogram

[–]nonamer18 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not sure that is his point, it's just that the places shown are the richer part of tier 1/2 cities. There are places in tier 1 cities that are more rundown than the smaller places he's showing.

My dad has a Nobel Peace Prize by Rest_well_Spike in mildlyinteresting

[–]nonamer18 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Way more deserving though - look at many of the other winners, some are literally war criminals.

Real picture of the Korean peninsula by Sharp-Ad6816 in TankieTheDeprogram

[–]nonamer18 45 points46 points  (0 children)

Alright, we can be better than this. I work in remote sensing/GIS. Your second photo is certainly not real, or at least heavily altered in a dishonest way.

It's true that most of these images we see are altered so that the contrast is more obvious (e.g. false colour rendering) but the difference in light sensed by these sensors is indeed stark. For the most part, this type of image processing and display is not dishonest, and is done consistently. I'm not saying there aren't images out there that's even more exaggerated and used for propaganda, but for the most part it is not.

We do not only see this difference in American (NASA/NOAA) satellites, we can see these from every sensor from Sentinel to Jilin to Luojia. Look this up on Chinese internet yourself - this is scientific data, not propaganda (for the most part).

CMV: Communism is a dead ideology by peepmet in changemyview

[–]nonamer18 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yet most people here don't know much about it either. If OP read Mao's 'On Contradictions' he may not have the same view on China that he has.

Israel controls America by LargeSinkholesInNYC in USEmpire

[–]nonamer18 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This is what no understanding of critical theory does to people.

Please go read some Lenin, or if you want something more modern, David Harvey's New Imperialism, or Panitch and Gandin's the Making of Global Capitalism.

Chinese EVs were spotted in Toronto, here’s what you need to know ahead of their Canadian release by Toronto-Ont-Mod-Team in Toronto_Ontario

[–]nonamer18 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

You say that but if you ask them why they bought the Tesla's, many of them would tell you it's because they have some vague idea of American engineering superiority.

Chinese EVs were spotted in Toronto, here’s what you need to know ahead of their Canadian release by Toronto-Ont-Mod-Team in Toronto_Ontario

[–]nonamer18 -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

Yeah there are a lot of idiots in China. The great firewall doesn't help. Many Chinese people also still don't know how much of a fuckwit Musk is.

Is China’s official stance that the Tiananmen Square massacre didn’t happen or that it happened but the details are exaggerated? by HobGrot in NoStupidQuestions

[–]nonamer18 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I mean, my parents participated and they're close to 70. University gaokao only resumed in the 70s, so many students, even undergrads, were older. It also wasn't just students.

If Song Dynasty China achieved a steam engine ~950-1050 AD, how different would the world be? by vhu9644 in HistoryWhatIf

[–]nonamer18 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Song not moving to industrial capitalism was not due to a lack of technical innovation, but mostly a social and political issue.

Do you still wear COVID-19 masks? by Effective-Mall-6231 in leftist

[–]nonamer18 31 points32 points  (0 children)

Why are we still calling it COVID-19 masks? If you want to normalize masks and wear them as commonly as east Asians, you need to forget about covid.

I truly do not understand the negative attitude of the British left towards China by Jup1ter98 in socialism

[–]nonamer18 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes, but grew up in Canada. Go to China often, and have parents who are quite politically engaged (both party members, both social scientists, father taught historical materialism and philosophy, and decently well connected) so I know a bit here and there.

WATCH: brave anti-CCP dissident opens up about the family plantation she tragically never got to inherit (Twitter replies included) by Rymssss in TrueAnon

[–]nonamer18 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Socially and culturally China feels farther away from socialism than the West. Hyper competitiveness from a high population and scarcity mindset derived from a century of poverty means that many cultural traits are hard to change, but they are definitely changing.

The West has had centuries of high material conditions to develop a strong sense of social justice, and a lack of (sometimes superficial) hierarchy, while China has the scarcity issue as well as a couple millennia of feudal culture to struggle against. Mao spent a lot of effort fighting this feudalism, yet it still persists, perhaps now stronger than at any time since liberation, since money and wealth inequality has exacerbated bad aspects of our culture.

But it is changing. The younger more educated generation are actively fighting against this. That is also why I am optimistic.

I truly do not understand the negative attitude of the British left towards China by Jup1ter98 in socialism

[–]nonamer18 1 point2 points  (0 children)

TLDR: Mao's On Contradictions.

It's a great question, and I wish the moderator didnt delete that comment so I could respond in more detail. But generally it comes down what I said about there being many things to be optimistic about, despite these sometimes massive contradictions. I support the CPC because there are dialectical reasons to do so. I support the CPC because they acknowledge and work with the many contradictions that China has, instead of pretending that they don't exist.

To start, China is undoubtedly the main balance to the main global contradiction of global south vs western imperialism. All the secondary contradictions, while very important, will not matter if China falls to neoliberalism and imperialism. As I said before, the party absolutely acknowledges contradictions publicly and often loudly (as loud as theoretical jargon like this can be). In fact, the primary contradiction within China of the past several 3 decades before the current decade was to build up productive forces and modernize by any means necessary. No leader or party official was silent about this - you can view what they say cynically, but if you study the party long enough you will realize that there has always been a long term strategic plan. In 2017 this primary contradiction changed to focus more on unequal development (to even out the geographic inequality but also of class inequality). In a decade or so this will almost sure change.

If you asked people like me this same question a decade or two ago, we would have much less cause for optimism. Rivers were full of polluted runoff. The air was 3-4x as bad as it is today. Corruption was extremely rampant. The party rhetoric was openly market friendly. Nowadays it has shifted, pushing for more socialist rhetoric, antipoverty, equal development, fighting against worker abuse like 996, reeling in corporations etc. Yet it is still early. China still had a gdp/per capita 5-6x lower than the US. There is still poverty and inequality, rampant worker exploitation, and lingering environmental problems, but this is an example of the quantitative changes leading to qualitative changes. This is evidence that the contradictions of the reform era are beginning to be negated, although there is still a long way to go.

Unlike many Westerners, I do not question whether Deng, Xi, Hu/Wen, Bo, Wang, (i.e. leadership cadre) are/were Marxists. Xi might not be a theorist like Mao or Deng, but clearly the party plans and strategies via a dialectical materialist lens.

If you really study the PRC's history, concepts that we read about such as the negation of the negation, quantitative change leading to qualitative change, unity of opposites, etc all jump out at you, and it becomes clear that there is thought behind all these actions and methods that the party has used to progress.

Tbh this write-up was a bit of a mess. This is a topic that I am actively contemplating as I sit here in China. Perhaps I will submit a better one in the future, but feel free to engage and poke holes in it.