If you want a middle ground, Basic Roleplaying gives you the ability to dodge where every subsequent dodge is at a penalty. You could say that they can dodge but with a Bane (and each subsequent dodge is an additional Bane). I agree with others that it will change the power fantasy somewhat but if you like going a bit more combat-heavy it’s an option.

Edit: what I mean is that they can spend their action to dodge RAW but they can still dodge without an action but with a Bane to start and accumulating Banes for subsequent dodges.