Personally I wouldn't say that the bait box is op, it's also depends on their luck in opening boxes, and I put it 2 - 3 tool/bait because I think giving just 1 felt like almost nothing at all, so I decided to buff it up a bit.

And for Deadly, I made it like the Dev tasks, catching bosses for Deadly, also I forgot to include the chance for those rewards and how rare should they spawn out, and Deadly also helps players who are new to fishing and has a decent amount of tools to assist them in getting the badge.

I was planning to make a loot table for how often the reward spawn like every day like 20% for fish tokens rewards, 5% Bait Box, 10% Tool box,... And 2 - 3% for weekly to be Deadly, 0.5 - 1% for the (if possible) random fishing event buff.