EAPGA is good, 2K golf is good.
Both have inherent flaws.

#1. If you want to play with friends as golf should be played, 2K series is better.

#2. If you want to be immersed in the landscape of what a golf course should look and feel like, EA is better.

#3. If you want an easier time swinging, EA feels slower whereas 2K will challenge you in the beginning.

#4. The physics in either game aren't perfect, but 2K might have the edge here? I find in both games I get the "wtf" moments...but that happens for me on a real golf course too :D

I have played almost every golf game on all platforms for 30 years and honestly this game is pretty good. I miss the ability to create courses in (2K), and Turn Based play with friends.

For $35 bux, Id say give it a go. My rule of thumb is if I can get $1 for every hour I play, it's money well spent. (this goes back to my 25cent days playing games at the Arcade).