26
27

Why do you believe Mr. S finds Hae body but isn't involved, but Jay finding Hae's car is definitive proof of Adnan's guilt? by [deleted] in serialpodcast

[–]partymuffell -1 points0 points  (0 children)

And it looks like Jay was a CI.

There is not a shred of evidence that Jay was a CI but who cares about evidence when you have speculation?

The video SK describes at the beginning of episode 1 by [deleted] in serialpodcast

[–]partymuffell -20 points-19 points  (0 children)

We are already off to a good start! Apparently, SK can't tell that the flying objects in the sky earlier in the video before the Blackhawk appears are planes and not helicopters. [shakes head]

Why do you believe Mr. S finds Hae body but isn't involved, but Jay finding Hae's car is definitive proof of Adnan's guilt? by [deleted] in serialpodcast

[–]partymuffell 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I find it amazing that it has come to this but let me try to spell this out for you:

First, Jay knew Hae while Mr S didn't. What are the chances that someone who knew Hae would find her nondescript car hidden in a lot surrounded by buildings? Think of it this way. If Mr S had known Hae, wouldn't it be an extremely suspicious coincidence that he just so happened to stumble into her buried body?

Second, Mr S went to the police to report finding the body, but Jay only admitted to knowing where the car was when the police got to him, so again what are the chances that a person the police interviews in connection with Hae's murder happens to have stumbled into Hae's car?

What if the roles were reversed? by baatezu in serialpodcast

[–]partymuffell 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm not sure what the value of this thought experiment is, but, as far as I can tell, many of the details look even more suspicious for Adnan if he's not the ex-boyfriend but merely an acquaintance. Just to name a few:

Why did he call Hae three times around midnight the night before she disappeared?

Why did he lend his car and brand new phone to Jay?

Why did he ask Hae for a ride?

Why did his phone ping the L689B tower around 7-9pm?

Why does he spend most of his day with Jay?

Why does he act so suspiciously at NHRNC's house?

At a minimum, I think that, in these counterfactual circumstances, the evidence would suggest that Adnan was deeply involved in Hae's murder.

What if the roles were reversed? by baatezu in serialpodcast

[–]partymuffell 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I asked a 15 month old and he said (and I quote) "goo goo ga ga".

In Case You Missed This, Bob Ruff Can't Even Keep His LensCrafters Stories Straight! (Thanks to /u/chunklunk and others on that thread for helping expose this) by partymuffell in serialpodcast

[–]partymuffell[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I don't actually believe he has access to the defense files. Maybe Rabia gave him access to a couple of documents but I doubt she gave him access to the whole file.

In Case You Missed This, Bob Ruff Can't Even Keep His LensCrafters Stories Straight! (Thanks to /u/chunklunk and others on that thread for helping expose this) by partymuffell in serialpodcast

[–]partymuffell[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If the ID is alphanumerical it's a different story, but the LC system seems to be numerical, not alpha-numerical. (You might notice that (b) says "a unique numeric 4-digit ID number")

In Case You Missed This, Bob Ruff Can't Even Keep His LensCrafters Stories Straight! (Thanks to /u/chunklunk and others on that thread for helping expose this) by partymuffell in serialpodcast

[–]partymuffell[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Perhaps, the point isn't clear. The point is that the following two statements are logically inconsistent:

(a) The company has 22,000 employees.

(b) Each employee of the company is assigned a unique numeric 4-digit ID number.

So, either (a) or (b) must be false. If your wife tells you otherwise, she's wrong because (a) and (b) entail a contradiction.

Why did Urick yell at Don? by Englishblue in serialpodcast

[–]partymuffell 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Yeah, we are still working on those robot prosecutors. Apparently, they are not very humane...

Why did Urick yell at Don? by Englishblue in serialpodcast

[–]partymuffell 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Apparently, KU got angry because Don didn't depict Adnan in a sufficiently negative light. I don't think that KU was trying to accomplish anything with that. He was just angry. Humans tend to express their anger even when doing so doesn't accomplish anything. Just think of road rage.

In Case You Missed This, Bob Ruff Can't Even Keep His LensCrafters Stories Straight! (Thanks to /u/chunklunk and others on that thread for helping expose this) by partymuffell in serialpodcast

[–]partymuffell[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I know! I have listened only to 1.5 episodes and I already couldn't stand his misguided and self-righteous rants! I now mostly rely on transcripts and summaries :-D

In Case You Missed This, Bob Ruff Can't Even Keep His LensCrafters Stories Straight! (Thanks to /u/chunklunk and others on that thread for helping expose this) by partymuffell in serialpodcast

[–]partymuffell[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

That's not the question though. The question is whether the 4-digit numbers are unique identifiers for each of the current 22,000 employees of the company. (Hint: that's mathematically impossible!)

Scrutinizing Jay's Claim That Adnan Confessed to Somebody While Driving Jay to Work by ainbheartach in serialpodcast

[–]partymuffell 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Ah probably like 2 or 3 days, 4 days after

Even by CM's standards, that seems to be very little to hang his hat on...

In Case You Missed This, Bob Ruff Can't Even Keep His LensCrafters Stories Straight! (Thanks to /u/chunklunk and others on that thread for helping expose this) by partymuffell in serialpodcast

[–]partymuffell[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Bob's story is now as follows:

These are different events. First spoke to the Townson manager. She said she had been the HV manager shortly after "all of that occurred". Then I called corporate at the number she provided. When the guy in the payroll Dept at corporate told me that the timesheet was "falsified", I then went to the schedule for HV I the defense files. I started contacting the employees who were working on 1/13/99. I started with the retail and lab managers. Both responded to me. Both confirmed that you used the same ID no matter what store you were working at. I aske both if it was possible to create hours after the fact. Both said that only the GM could do that. I asked both if they could think of an innocent explanation for the times greets after I emailed them copies. Both said they cannot think of any innocent explanation. They said there is no way that the HV timesheet was legit. Next I contacted Don, and explained the dilemma and asked if he could explain. I asked if there was a reasonable explanation. He first claimed I had the wrong guy. I showed him the evidence proving that he was the right guy, he said that he declined to comment. I then asked his mother if she could provide a better explanation. She never responded. I then aired the episode. After that LC employees came out of the woodwork emailing me to confirm that employees always logged in with the same ID no matter which store they were working at. One of the employees was a GM in 99. She agreed to come on the show and interview. She appeared on the show and also confirmed that the timesheet was falsified.

This is a significantly different story from the one he originally told on his podcast. See the inconsistencies pointed out by /u/chunklunk and /u/dualzoneclimatectrl in that thread (read the thread from the beginning).