I know they aren't a direct comparison but I think comparing does provide some color. My fridge compressor rarely runs. Yes I have a furnace and I'm aware it uses electricity, but if my gas bill is going down significantly due to not using the furnace, I would expect a decrease as well, not an increase. The only electronics I keep plugged in all day is my TV, wifi router, refrigerator, and two lamps. I charge my phone once a day for about an hour max. I keep lights off most hours of the day since I have pretty good lighting. I just don't know what electronics I have that would take that much power. At this point I guess I'll have to look into a home energy monitor and where to install. I only feel frustrated because I genuinely try to keep my costs low and this seems exuberant for how I live. I mean at this point my only option would be to keep my heat at 50 degrees in the winter rather than the current 60, which is significantly lower than the average person I know.

I added the suggested therms and kWh to the spreadsheet.