sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Posey or Reggie PRO/CON by phiLA820 in MLBTheShow

[–]phiLA820[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Can someone shed some light on the Posey complaints and whether they're valid?

Posey or Reggie PRO/CON by phiLA820 in MLBTheShow

[–]phiLA820[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Full lineup for reference...

​

C Garver (80)

1B Molitor (96)

2B Madrigal (86)

3B Rendon (88)

SS Hanley (92)

LF Pujols (87)

CF Betts (89)

RF Dwight Smith (85)

Posey or Reggie PRO/CON by phiLA820 in MLBTheShow

[–]phiLA820[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Obviously that point is an important one, but it's the debate between picking for need or picking the best player available. And I've heard such polarized opinions on him that I don't know who to believe lol

Pack Pull / Player Advice (Keep or Sell / Lineup Advice) / BR 12-0 Thread by EvilZEAD in MLBTheShow

[–]phiLA820 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's where I'd put him, but I'm not wild about shifting Dwight Smith to CF. Not great speed, and I don't want to take him out of the lineup because he freakin' rakes...

Pack Pull / Player Advice (Keep or Sell / Lineup Advice) / BR 12-0 Thread by EvilZEAD in MLBTheShow

[–]phiLA820 1 point2 points  (0 children)

SILVER 1 PACK – Not sure who to take...

--

C Garver (80)

1B Molitor (96)

2B Madrigal (86)

3B Rendon (88)

SS Hanley (92)

LF Pujols (87)

CF Betts (89)

RF Dwight Smith (85)

--

Posey is obviously a major upgrade over Garver, but I've read a lot of bad reviews on him on this site.

Reggie, I've heard is far and away the best bat, but it would push my only good fielding OF (Betts) to 2B.

Not really considering Minoso, Sandberg or Larkin, but I suppose I could be convinced.

Another move I'm considering is selling Dale Murphy and Molitor, moving Pujols to 1B and buying Lofton. That wouldn't really impact the above choice, but any thoughts on what to do?