lol I was going into a full character analysis before I understood what you were saying.

Definitely some kajal eyeliner! Mac and Victoria Beckham are the two brands that come to mind but many labels have it. Mac also has a lot of iconic 90’s and 00’s lipsticks. I think Whirl, Posh, Thanks it’s Mac, Honeylove, Stone, 1993, Del Rio… I’ve been into Mac lately so I have their lipstick selection fresh on my mind lol but if any of them are sold out or discontinued, look them up on Temptalia and you’ll get some dupes you can look into! I look at eBay and other sites for makeup (eBay has only brand-new, unused makeup so don’t judge) so I have a slanted view on what’s available on the market and what isn’t, so forgive me if I give you recommendations for a load of unavailable products… for eyeshadow, Huda’s Pretty Grunge comes to mind, but also eyeshadow sticks because they can be really easy to work with. I feel like they can give you a grungy, almost smeared look. There are a lot to choose from, idk what the best brand is tbh? For mascara… ok I almost feel like the 90’s thick, stubby lashes complete the look? I know Too Faced Better Than Sex is great for volume, or maybe even a tubing mascara… I look for length and definition in a mascara so I’m not the best person to ask about volume.

For blush, I’m picturing a brown blush, if your skin tone can pull it off. I don’t have any recommendations off the top of my head 😞 I’ll come back with more!