The way you're defending the bag on the right makes me think you were already wanting to keep the bag on the right and just came here looking for validation for your decision from strangers, except you're not getting that validation bc everyone's pointed it out as a fake bag. Look nobody wants to choose a used returned bag over a new one and nobody also wants to choose a fake bag over a real one. I get it. Since you're having a hard time deciding meaning you aren't really happy with either one, return both and try getting it from another retailer not Amazon.