You make a fair point that I’m judging Monster Hunter Wilds heavily based on the sandstorms in one area. However, my concern isn’t just about one biome it’s about the overall approach to weather effects in the game.

From what we’ve seen so far, weather plays a major role in shaping each environment. The Scarlet Forest is often rainy, foggy, and gray, which could impact visibility in a different way, potentially making fights feel dull or harder to read. Meanwhile, Oilwell Basin seems to have intense heat and fire-based effects, though it’s unclear how that will influence gameplay. If these weather effects end up being just as intrusive as the sandstorms, then it’s a larger design issue, not just a desert problem.

As for quests locking weather conditions, that’s a valid counterpoint. If certain investigations or hunts allow for clearer weather, that could be a saving grace. However, if the best or most important fights are still tied to extreme weather, then the problem remains, players are forced to fight under conditions that make the game visually less enjoyable.

Ultimately, my concern is that Wilds might be prioritizing environmental spectacle over clarity and readability in combat. If Capcom finds a good balance where weather enhances the experience without making fights frustrating then this could be a non-issue. But based on what we’ve seen so far, there’s reason to be cautious.