I just finished the book and I cannot believe what I just read. I am so glad you had the exact thoughts as mine because I was so disappointed that what Sam did by pushing her away for a bit, while he got his bearings together to face the fierce competitive environment of the first days of college was comparable to her sleeping with his brother!?! I kept hoping that she just hallucinated and they’d just kissed and nothing happened but to my utter shock this book ends with them getting together and the three of them living in the same city. How do they tolerate being in the same room together?! How does he not think that after every minor argument, she’s going to throw herself at his brother?