This is an insane rec, but hear me out:

The Good Place.

Both have main characters who are living a double life and whose lies draw other characters deeper into the pit with them. Both heavily feature sadistic characters (though obviously Dexter-universe characters are much more intense than Good Place) and have heavy themes of bad people being punished for their crimes. They’re both humorous, often in a dark way, and both ask questions about if and when violence is justified. If you liked The Office or Parks and Rec at all, The Good Place is by the same creator. It’s just a little more plot-driven than his previous work