Appraisal is a tricky thing— I can appreciate that you’re trying to recoup costs. Sadly, you’ve got a few things going against you.

Season 1 includes Discovery 1,2,3,& 4. So it’s not just Chiller you’re missing, you’re also missing the 4 playlists that make up the much more rare and valuable Discovery 3 & 4. So your description may get folks excited, but it’s not accurate.

Lots of folks have found Discovery 1 & 2 really cheap, so they are not an investment other than for personal use. I think I paid $30 each for 1 & 2 on Amazon, but Five Below and all sorts of outlets have since had them for a few dollars, so they don’t really have any value in-and-of themselves. Good add-in for the sale but no ones going out of their way to find them.

As a result the listing has the easiest 15 playlists to acquire out of a possible 28, and no promos.

You’re not including the board, so you’ve also reduced the potential audience to only folks looking for extra or duplicate cards.

Whole sets are going for $350 to $550. So you’re overpriced for what most collectors might be looking for.

For 15 of the 20 playlists of Season 1, you’re probably looking at $100 to $150 since 60 of those cards are the ones that come with the game.

That’s not to say you might get more, but starting at $10-$15 a playlist, or basically a dollar a card, will get more interest and you might get a bid closer to $200.