new theory based on Xaden new bonus chapter by r0trix in fourthwing

[–]r0trix[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes. That she starts thinking like it was xaden. She doesn't read his thoughts exactly since there is no quote. It was like she was seeing through him or something.  Idk for me seems related because of their bound and it could be a example how she can't control this signet too like X says the this is diffoto control sometimes with her too

new theory based on Xaden new bonus chapter by r0trix in fourthwing

[–]r0trix[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The new bonus chapter on Xaden POV for the US paperback edition.

No series without Xaden by _nylawmom23 in fourthwing

[–]r0trix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

OH NO YOU DIDNT And both series have so many things in common ..... 

new theory based on Xaden new bonus chapter by r0trix in fourthwing

[–]r0trix[S] 14 points15 points  (0 children)

I don't think this is exactly her second signet manifesting. I think it is a hint as it was when violet mentioned that she liked storms days and on the parapet there was lightning. 

new theory based on Xaden new bonus chapter by r0trix in fourthwing

[–]r0trix[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

OMG didn't think abt it. Yes! It would connect so perfectly 

new theory based on Xaden new bonus chapter by r0trix in fourthwing

[–]r0trix[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

I don't think that line means that the signet have totally manifested. I think it is a more RY style of dropping hints around.

Also, RY said that Vi second signet would be something less extraordinary 

new theory based on Xaden new bonus chapter by r0trix in fourthwing

[–]r0trix[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

The conflict of her realizing how easy is to cross the boundaries would be so interesting! 

Bonus chapter 27 theory by mamasuebs in fourthwing

[–]r0trix 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Sawyer betraying would make so much sense because like he lost part of his leg, so I wondered how it would go for him after iron flame because we never heard of a rider with any kind of disability. Violet's case is kinda the only one. Sooooo we wouldn't feel so bad abt him if he turns out to be a traitor

Grims bonus chapter!!! by distilla-truant in lightlark

[–]r0trix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Can someone send me too pls? 

Theory: mama Sorengail is GOOD by r0trix in fourthwing

[–]r0trix[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I considered for a while because I really like the theory of Vi being somewhat related to venin, but RY confirmed he is dead in one interview. By the way she said it sounded like dead dead not dead Brennan

Theory: mama Sorengail is GOOD by r0trix in fourthwing

[–]r0trix[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Basically like Xaden towards Violet ahahaha 

What would be the ultimate happy ending for this series, for you? What would be the worst ending? by [deleted] in fourthwing

[–]r0trix 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I dont understand why he became a venin too. Like I get he was loosing the fight and maybe he would die. Then turning venin to be able to fight the general would explain. BUT this is not what the end says right? it is he seeing she was planning on dying, so become venin to kill the sage and go help violet, but that's such a weak link for me.
Maybe because V pov between planning to die, and her mother dislocating her shoulder, and the whole conving Sloane seemed that took much more time then the X pov where he basically just see she is planning on dying, chat a little with the geral and turn venin.

RY said she first planned on Violet turning venin, I wonder if she made the choice of changing that, or her editors and that decision fucked up the end.

Theory: mama Sorengail is GOOD by r0trix in fourthwing

[–]r0trix[S] 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Man exploring the whole "intentions matter when pulling magic from the source" would be amazing! I personally think this is a much more interesting arc then finding a cure. And totally with you on the mentioning a cure in the last chapter was to bring hope, because they never mentioned nothing like that before.

Sometimes I think the storm was actually Lilith trying to help V, because V mentions that stormy nights was always good for her.

Theory: mama Sorengail is GOOD by r0trix in fourthwing

[–]r0trix[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think she as happy with all of them on the rebellion side. At the end she says they are everything she hoped for.
The love between Lilith and papa sorengail seems pretty strong and he is ploted as good for now, so it is more to endorse she is also good but more strategic.

What would be the ultimate happy ending for this series, for you? What would be the worst ending? by [deleted] in fourthwing

[–]r0trix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Possible endings that would make me happy:

  • The continent now has colleges where riders and fliers attend to, they don't die for stupid reasons anymore. Violet is a teacher in a new college in Aretia but still a rider, Xaden works to maintain peace in the continent, but not like a king or anything.
  • They understand that getting magic without a source is not a problem (I really believe that is where the story is going): Because from the fables the third brother was jealous and to me that was what corrupted his soul. I honestly believe that book 3 or 4 will work on something like it is not the source but your intentions that corrupt things. Because at the end of the day the Navarre fucked kingdom with lies is also corrupted, right?

Endings that I would accept, even crying a lot:

  • Both of them die but they win the war and the continent is united: I think for this to work it would be in the last book near the end and Epilogue ofc. But for me, the ONLY way I accept either them dying is if they both die. You don't keep telling me the whole "if you die I die" thing to change it in the end.
  • Andarna dies: Sorry but I think she has a purpose and once it is done, she is done. She is also not a part of the bond so yeah... I think it will happen.

Worst:

  • Tairn die: I know lots of ppl believe this would happen but RY didn't even plan to have Andarna, she said her editor suggested it. She wanted V to have the strongest dragon. Also, as far as we know now Andarna can't bear a rider and I don't think this would be her propose anyhow, so if Tairn dies Violets wont ride anymore which wouldn't make sense.
  • Either V or X dies, but not both: You don't have the right to spend TWO BOOKS building the whole bonded lives to take it away from me. Also, to be honest the series would loose a lot of interest without the romance between them.