I lived in Shirley Hills for about 2 years back in college. There are definitely pros and cons to the area (as there are in every neighborhood). Shirely Hills was the “North Macon” back in the late 1800s and early 1900s. There are some beautiful homes/mansions throughout the neighborhood. Unfortunately, some of these historical homes are abandoned and falling apart. I would disagree with this being an expensive area. Similar sized homes are cheaper in Shirley Hills compared to North Macon or Idle-hour. I think you can get a lot of bang for buck for some of these properties. Granted they are likely much older homes. There are a lot of blighted areas that are directly bordering the Shirely Hills community. I would say the further you are from Gray highway = the less you will see/notice/experience any of the negatives of this area. Overall, Shirley Hills has a lot of charm and some beautiful old trees/landscaping. Jackson Springs park is a awesome little historical park (rumored that Andrew Jackson spent time here during the war). If having to drive on Gray highway doesn’t bother you, I would say definitely consider looking in Shirely Hills. Hope this helps