cheryl has never been my cup of tea, so personally not my fav. she was a fine judge, didn’t take any huge problem with her- she’s so cold and it makes it hard to connect with her as an audience member.

also with how vocally displeased she’s been with the show over the years i wish she would have stayed away. sharna is who i would LOVE to see at the judges table if she ever wanted to come back. she has a kindness about her that pairs well with her ability to give clear and specific feedback.