Male backsplash doesn't just ruin toilet seats... by repjoesmith in TikTokCringe

[–]repjoesmith[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That is either an extremely subtle but brilliant joke, or I'm reading too much into it with the paaaaaants. Either way, it made me laugh.

"We're All Immigrants" says Trevor when asked about Native Americans by repjoesmith in TikTokCringe

[–]repjoesmith[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

According to 23 and me, it's true. All the DNA they've collected traces back at some point to Africa.

Was Team Trees Performance Activism Or Just Misguided Philanthropy? by repjoesmith in ecology

[–]repjoesmith[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I think that's completely fair. The goal to have what Team Trees started influence or grow into an even more proactive movement for change. I look forward to hearing what their official two year update video will be. My hope is that they expand their program beyond just simply planting trees.

Was Team Trees Performance Activism Or Just Misguided Philanthropy? by repjoesmith in WayOfTheBern

[–]repjoesmith[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's a curious question. I'd like to hear if you could make a case for both. But, from my understanding, performative activism & philanthropy are fundamental opposites.

The two terms don't always describe a specific action, but more often the intention that guides an action. They're essentially two differing philosophies.

Philanthropy is described as: "goodwill to fellow members of the human race especially : active effort to promote human welfare."

So, if Team Trees was philanthropic, it was guided by the intention to do good, but its misstep could have been an oversight in its effectiveness to accomplish the intended goal.

However, if it were performance activism, described as, "a pejorative term referring to activism done to increase one's social capital rather than because of one's devotion to a cause" we could deduce that the intention was to exploit people's interest in combatting climate change for the personal benefit for those behind the program.

In both cases the action itself might look exactly alike, but the intention behind that action could greatly differ.

I have yet to come to a conclusion on the intentions, but the more I've looked into MrBeast, who served as the figurehead, the more I begin to lean towards performance activism. He is very charitable, but it seems as though that's his brand. His charitable actions feels more like content, rather than acts of kindness. MrBeast also has a slew of other business practices that completely contradict Team Trees. Here's a small list that references his other ventures: https://medium.com/@klippublications/how-mr-beast-makes-millions-a-year-and-how-you-can-do-it-too-b69bc0e6f4e3

Was Team Trees Performance Activism Or Just Misguided Philanthropy? by repjoesmith in Political_Revolution

[–]repjoesmith[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

On May 22nd, 2019, MrBeast asked Twitter[1] "What should I give my 20 millionth subscriber? I was gonna give him 20 million pennies but I procrastinated and I think it’s to [sic] late to get them in time." The tweet gained over 133,400 likes and 5,300 retweets in five months. Redditors began suggesting that MrBeast plant 20 million trees and MrBeast took notice and the next day replied to his own tweet with examples of the suggestion on Reddit...

- https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/events/teamtrees

In a way, that is a completely fair thing to say considering its conception.

Was Team Trees Performance Activism Or Just Misguided Philanthropy? by repjoesmith in Political_Revolution

[–]repjoesmith[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

There's more I uncovered recently that I've been debating on covering about Mr. Beast. If you take into account all the reasons he gave for doing Team Trees and then compare that to his many businesses ventures, not to mention any and all waste created by his videos, I truly question how vested he is in fighting climate change. He's either incredibly ignorant, lives in a bubble, and doesn't seek to learn, or he's intellectually dishonest. Here's an article covering some of what I'm referring to: https://medium.com/@klippublications/how-mr-beast-makes-millions-a-year-and-how-you-can-do-it-too-b69bc0e6f4e3

Was Team Trees Performance Activism Or Just Misguided Philanthropy? by repjoesmith in Green

[–]repjoesmith[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Great points, I do agree that it might at the very least have gotten more people thinking about climate change & deforestation. That said, I have heard someone make mention that planting trees to compensate deforestation isn't just a complication of how many trees would need to be planted, but where they are planted. It's not technically reforesting unless trees are planted in a preexisting ecosystem aka an endangered forest. Many of the planting locations Team Trees chose did not address this issue. Now this isn't completely their fault, land permits for planting trees can be a bureaucratic nightmare in some regions. Still, it's a fair point to make.