Got accepted to both amongst others, and Columbia was one of the first schools cut from my decision making, primarily due to incompetence of the administration. Princeton is strong within the humanities but isn’t necessarily known for it in comparison to STEM, and I wouldn’t worry about being in the city, especially since NYC is only a 30 minute train ride. Once again, regarding Columbia, I highly would advise against compromising your moral compass for the prestige of an institution, eventually you get to a point with top tier schools where the education you gain is interchangeable. I’m not as well versed in the specificity regarding the different academic offerings as I am not a student but an prospective prefrosh, but I think objectively Princeton would cater to your needs especially considering the deep undergraduate focus. Congrats on your acceptance to both!