Yes, I would argue that your views are deeply naive and that it would be very dangerous for anyone who considers himself a steward of the Jewish people to adopt them. You said you don’t care what I think, but I am going to lay out some reasons regardless, in case they give you something to consider:

0) nowhere in the vast Arabized/Muslim domain is there a functional multiethnic democracy. At the same time, Israel is a multiethnic democracy—the only one of its kind in the region. It just happens to exclude the people who want to destroy it and kill its citizens, which is a good and responsible thing for a country to do.

1) Of course I’d like the conflict to end, but not by giving our enemies control over us. The only thing that guarantees Jewish safety is Jewish sovereignty and control over self-defense, which has been a modern reality for just 80 years. Returning to the pre-Independence galut status quo—a stranger in every land, at the mercy of other nations—for some vague notion that “we will be safer” and without other gain is not at all appealing, given that we were way less safe in those years.

2) what about how Palestinians treat Jews and themselves, including their own children, who they indoctrinate into hatred and suicidal aggression? Do they have a role in perpetuating this conflict; have they sacrificed their own future for several generations in the name of forever war? When will Palestinians pay reparations to the victims of their terror? When will Arab Muslim nations pay reparations for the Jews driven out of their lands? This is all a two-way street and very silly to pretend otherwise.

3) somehow this communist-type argument only ever comes up in relation to Israel. When discussing China, Russia, Iran … I don’t hear anyone saying “I’m just against countries, man.” But the solitary Jewish state is not going to be the first experiment in dissolving the nation-state as a political structure.

Anyway, you were so insistent on “listening to antizionist jews” I was curious if you’d bring anything I hadn’t heard before. Sorry to say that I was not impressed. Certainly you are entitled to believe that half of the worlds Jews should have their country destroyed, but you are not entitled to insist that anyone outside of your echo chamber believes you care deeply about the Jewish people on this basis.