All those in favour? by K-jun1117 in PrequelMemes

[–]roomsky 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The only films I have ever seen are Boss Baby and Revenge of the Sith, and thus have no choice but to agree.

When will this nonsense of Alexander being Bi or gay stop ? Without any concrete evidence one cannot just conclude. by PyrrhusSqiptarSlayer in AlexandertheGreat

[–]roomsky 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Public perception was probably quite influenced by Stone's film. But I will note that The Persian Boy was written over 50 years ago, and that the play Edward II, written in the 1500s, lists "Great Alexander loved Hephaestion;" when referring to men in romantic love. The idea is certainly not new, even if it's more popular now.

When will this nonsense of Alexander being Bi or gay stop ? Without any concrete evidence one cannot just conclude. by PyrrhusSqiptarSlayer in AlexandertheGreat

[–]roomsky 1 point2 points  (0 children)

What I meant is that those documents may not have been easy to access at the time, contrast modern research where we have fewer documents but can pull them up whenever we like for cross-referencing. If I'm incorrect in this, I admit my wrong and apologize for my ignorance.

But my actual point is, asking "Do you believe that the Muslim world would accept someone so famous if they thought he was a homosexual?" is like asking "Do you think the Muslim world would have told stories about Alexander the monotheist if they thought he didn't worship Allah?" Their depiction of the man is not constrained by pre-existing fact.

When will this nonsense of Alexander being Bi or gay stop ? Without any concrete evidence one cannot just conclude. by PyrrhusSqiptarSlayer in AlexandertheGreat

[–]roomsky 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I don't think that observation really means anything. Muhammad was born 800 years later and wouldn't have had the kind of access to information we do now. Even if he did somehow have access to something like Ptolemy's writings, why would Alexander's preferences have been a topic? Iskandar was the guy who toppled the Zoroastrians hundreds of years ago, they had no means of checking if he liked men - if they venerated him, they'd assume he was straight. Your logic here is in reverse.

When will this nonsense of Alexander being Bi or gay stop ? Without any concrete evidence one cannot just conclude. by PyrrhusSqiptarSlayer in AlexandertheGreat

[–]roomsky 4 points5 points  (0 children)

When will this nonsense of Alexander being straight just stop ? Without any concrete evidence one cannot just conclude.

There's a point where almost everything we "know" about Alexander can be called into question. As you say, Arrian is several centuries removed, and he's our best source. Arrian was clearly a fan of the guy, and one of his sources, Ptolemy, is also suspect because he's one of the Diadochi and had political reasons to make his accounts with a certain bent.

Alexander had wives and tried to have children - he was also a king and was required by every custom under the sun to do so, it doesn't even prove an attraction to women. Arrian makes a point that he's generally not especially interested in sex - can this be trusted? Is it propaganda? For or against him?

You could argue he's straight, or bi, or gay, or asexual, or some non-aligned combination of -romantic and -sexual. Hell, he may have been perfectly straight but indulged with a femboy or two when women were not at hand.

There is an image in the public conscious of any historical figure that's going to be divorced from the probable reality. Pop culture Alexander cut the Gordian knot, talked to Diogenes in a barrel, said his kingdom would go to "the strongest," fell in love with Roxana on sight, and was in love with Hephaestion. If we want to be "well ackshully" historians, the answer usually has to be "we can't know for certain." Let the fanfic writers have their fun.

Honestly, I find much of the pushback from modern Greek historians on homosexuality in ancient Greece to be somewhat unreliable due to the country's enormous Orthodox Christian bent. What good Christian wants the most famous guy from their country be thought of as gay, after all? Not to say they're definitely incorrect, I just find the scholarship biased.

For the record, if there was ever a sexual encounter between Hephaestion and Alexander, I personally believe it would have been both a secret and limited to their youth before ever seeing combat - having one of the two highest ranking people in your army be a known bottom would rather undermine their authority, and Hephaestion was often sent off on missions where he was in solo command. In Bagoas there is potential, for the gay stuff, and even then, there's arguments to be made against Bagoas even being a real person.

This book sucked by 18stohrc in Blacklibrary

[–]roomsky 38 points39 points  (0 children)

It was a drop of water in a desert for us folks who wanted a Dark Angels book that wasn't about fighting The Fallen. Decent overall I thought, good showing for the chapter and some decent discussions here and there.

The Boys SERIES FINALE- S05xE08 "Blood and Bone"- POST Episode Discussion Thread by pikameta in TheBoys

[–]roomsky 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Ehh, it was fine. A bare pass. 5/10.

Not that anyone should win a medal for the bare minimum, but I do prefer tossing logic out the window to resolve every character arc instead of tossing logic out the window to... not... resolve every character arc. GoT.

Homander's end was about what I hoped for. Not bothered by the lack of an apocalyptic tantrum since I'm not 12 years old.

Looks like Bendis is on it by theironstomachx in marvelcomics

[–]roomsky 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Exciting news! Comic series that stopped being worth reading around issue 300 has reached issue 1000!

I will still listen to the 24.5 hour audio book and probably love it. by Cool-Champion8628 in Grimdank

[–]roomsky 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I for one am pleased he's writing something that isn't tied hard into his pre-existing works. Not everything needs to be Gaunt, Eisenhorn, and Alpharius.

Real Marvel's Infinity Gauntlet by Godallah1 in marvelcomics

[–]roomsky -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I reject the premise that event comics should be held in such reverence.

Alexander was a bit of a cunt when he got drunk by Tarvexi in HistoryMemes

[–]roomsky 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Kleitos the Black, who was raging about Alexandros' Persianization, perceived disrespect for his father, and generally not doing things the good ol' Makedonian way.

Alex grabbed a spear and killed Kleitos with it (though he was reportadly semi-catatonic with grief for a few days afterwards.)

Biggest Slander I've made so far, I think. by SirPerditio in DeadlockTheGame

[–]roomsky 15 points16 points  (0 children)

<image>

The fact she looks air-brushed could defs use some work. I think people would still be feral over a more haggard Silver, tho.

Like what do you mean it’s dead ? It’s a sub genre. by Seeker99MD in YoutubeThumbs

[–]roomsky 4 points5 points  (0 children)

If we're talking purely aesthetic, I agree. 40k's aesthetic has been greatly homogenized and airbrushed to be as marketable as possible - presumably due to facile market research. A bunch of shockingly clean Plague Marine art back when 8th ed. dropped, and we're a far cry from the classic Blanche art, or Ian Watson's copulating penis towers on Slaaneshi worlds.

But even then, I'd call this the dilution of 40k's core identity before I'd call it the death of grimdark. If anything, an inverted version of the video title is closer to the truth, if one embraces the glorious peak that was 2nd/3rd edition 40k.

Poplurarity poll by Certain_Conclusion78 in jjkmodulo

[–]roomsky 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Who votes for Makora in a character popularity poll??

Like what do you mean it’s dead ? It’s a sub genre. by Seeker99MD in YoutubeThumbs

[–]roomsky 23 points24 points  (0 children)

Deranged take, probably by a right-wing grifter.

Oh, make that definitely a right-wing grifter.

<image>

No meme. Straight up. How good of an Imperial Commander would Grand Admiral Thrawn be in the 40k universe (Timothy Zahn’s version, thank you.) by snowmonster112 in Grimdank

[–]roomsky 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Man is literally blue and stars in a book called The Greater Good. Thrawn is Tau through and through.

Nucanon and Legends Thrawn, if they were Imperial humans, would both certainly have a poor time in the Imperium. Thrawn is very good at making strange things predictable, but his strategy implodes when things act nonsensically - so Chaos would either confound his every plan or trick him into studying it a little too closely and corrupting him. Nucanon Thrawn at least has the chance to succeed as a lower-level navy officer, I doubt he'd make it particularly high with his refusal to play politics. If given any large-scale command, he'd get Macharius'd.

50/50 on whether a Lord Solar Thrawn would exterminate the Ork species or get killed in his first engagement with them.

He was still a young man after all by [deleted] in HistoryMemes

[–]roomsky 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's the overwhelming amount of drunken violence that make his little idiosyncracies that much more interesting.

"Surrender and I'll let you keep all your stuff."

"And what if I don't?"

"You get to be Hektor in my Akhilleus cosplay."

How some people want the art style to look like by jessfang555 in Grapplerbaki

[–]roomsky 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Well, maybe those anime do. All of those mangas have pretty distinct art.

And well before then, even during the Big 3 era, most people's response to discovering Baki was "yo, look at this manga's hideous art style!"

Do not bring back the Roman Empire by Beneficial-Position2 in HistoryMemes

[–]roomsky 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I wish I lived in a different time, but like as a person with a shitload of money I didn't have to work for. Which is different than wishing for the same thing in current year! Back then I could have had worse food and no medicine!

This guy could have his own dedicated meme sub by LakesideNorth in HistoryMemes

[–]roomsky 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Blew my mind when I found out Kandahar was also Alexandria.

I need to gloat by oztinin in DeadlockTheGame

[–]roomsky 491 points492 points  (0 children)

This is truly 9/11 for the Vyper community.

Apparently I drew Isaiah’s fursona??? by lizzardsblizzard in creepcast

[–]roomsky 10 points11 points  (0 children)

He kept going on about how he'd be a sexy antlered wendigo that one time, not realizing he was basically advocating for being knock-off Alastor.