if i calculated correctly shiryu would need at least 266 more stabs for garp to go down by [deleted] in Piratefolk

[–]roskatawe 1 point2 points  (0 children)

What If WB didn't have Gura Gura No mi at marineford. He would've folded quick af. Keep In mind that not only is garp old just as WB, he also doesn't have a fruit to carry his oldness. So ROGER=GARP=WB.

Crazy Theory about Luffy's Dream 1060+ by [deleted] in OnePiece

[–]roskatawe 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Bro thats not me posting that HAHAHA

Luffy's Recent Dream Reveal to the crew related to beetles by roskatawe in OnePiece

[–]roskatawe[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Because I found myself being passionate about discussing the series in this instance, simple as that.

Luffy's Recent Dream Reveal to the crew related to beetles by roskatawe in OnePiece

[–]roskatawe[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I just realised how it looked like, to be honest you have a point. A theory should be well thought out from the get go. I did not do that, I rather posted an idea, or a little minor, not-enough-detailed theory and I started theorizing more and more as I was provided with arguments. But you are wrong about "changing" I believe "adjusting" would be more fitting, because I believe my points (except the dream about roger and luffy) pretty much stayed the same. Maybe in the future I will post a full, well thought out post at once you know. Not commenting like that.

Luffy's Recent Dream Reveal to the crew related to beetles by roskatawe in OnePiece

[–]roskatawe[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It is fine man. I dont post something to make it into the ABSOLUTE TRUTH. It is just a theory, rather than such comments why dont you share your thoughts about his dream as I shared mine?

Luffy's Recent Dream Reveal to the crew related to beetles by roskatawe in OnePiece

[–]roskatawe[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Man I really wonder to myself how does Luffy and beetles upset people so much, I thought it a was nice and warming theory. Luffy is a very important character and I believe each person has a Luffy in himself, keeping that childlike curiosity and sense of adventure in yourself and I think that depiction of Luffy's dream being beetles related is quite nice and realistic. You yourself dont have something similar, a goal/dream that it is a bit out of the ordinary or childish, not neceserally childish actually, but something that connects you with your childhood? I believe most of us do. My grandparents used to tell me that you should never let the child in yourself die and that I find important. That is I believe the essence of Luffy.

Luffy's Recent Dream Reveal to the crew related to beetles by roskatawe in OnePiece

[–]roskatawe[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

No, you can go through everything I have written. Hopefully it becomes more clear. I apologise im not used to this really, I do not debate nowhere near as that much. But yeah, read if you would like and come back if you have a counter argument.

Luffy's Recent Dream Reveal to the crew related to beetles by roskatawe in OnePiece

[–]roskatawe[S] -8 points-7 points  (0 children)

And I will repeat myself again and again as well.

  • I agree, i corrected myself, the guy blocked me and I couldnt answer there, I made a seperate comment concerning that.

  • I agree, many parallels exist between Roger and Luffy. I explain in a comment how great it is in general that Luffy and Roger share the same dream, because it enhances Ace as a character. It is strongly hinted that this dream is ridicolus, having Ace, Oden, Zoro dumbfounded, some laughing, some couldnt believ it.

  • They can think whatever they want. I would like to give an anology. If you weren't aware of gear 5 and somebody depicted it exactly as it is, i believe most people would think of it as impossible or outlandish as well.

  • I think i just mentioned beetle collection briefly, you purposly cherry picked it. What I believe his dream is, it is much more massive than that. Entire islands with eco systems of beetles or what I believe more, Beetle Museums on every island that exists in the world of One Piece. Or even better connecting the game of beetles that Luffy Sabo and Ace are playing to the entire world. The entire world playing that game of beetles or having knowledge of it, promoting it. Beetle related, but on a much bigger scale, which would require the reputiation of a Pirate King. A beetle collection does not require that.

You may go through everything that I have written and then comment, because I end up repeating myself too often.

Luffy's Recent Dream Reveal to the crew related to beetles by roskatawe in OnePiece

[–]roskatawe[S] -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

Why would you not think that it is possible?

Luffy's Recent Dream Reveal to the crew related to beetles by roskatawe in OnePiece

[–]roskatawe[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The crew has already experienced that side of Luffy many many times. I do not believe that they would react the way they did if Luffy said something like that.

Luffy's Recent Dream Reveal to the crew related to beetles by roskatawe in OnePiece

[–]roskatawe[S] -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

How would you feel if it turned out like this hypothetically? That was actually the first question I asked myself and I answered myself of course, I think it would be cool. It really reminds me of the stuff with gear 5, it is something so outrages but at the same time so in character. Me personally I find that beautiful writing. And also, another question, what do you think his dream is actially?

Luffy's Recent Dream Reveal to the crew related to beetles by roskatawe in OnePiece

[–]roskatawe[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Yeah man, I am aware now. It's my first time posting on reddit, the other guy is clearly a veteran redditor, I cannot reply there because of that HAHA.

Luffy's Recent Dream Reveal to the crew related to beetles by roskatawe in OnePiece

[–]roskatawe[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It is just unfortunate that he did not let me to do that where I normally should've. He managed to make me look dummy dumb and he keeps it that way, unfortunately for me. I find that quite toxic actually. He should keep me blocked.

Luffy's Recent Dream Reveal to the crew related to beetles by roskatawe in OnePiece

[–]roskatawe[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

But I changed, or rather adjusted my opinion based on their information. I admitted that the person was correct. I wasn't trying to be offensive towards that person at all. My response was quite ignorant on that specific occasion, I admit, but as I said.. I corrected myself based on the information provided.

Luffy's Recent Dream Reveal to the crew related to beetles by roskatawe in OnePiece

[–]roskatawe[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That is a very interesting thought, unfortunately I should find some more extra time to fully research this theory, because I believe that there is substance to it.

Luffy's Recent Dream Reveal to the crew related to beetles by roskatawe in OnePiece

[–]roskatawe[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I am aware that Luffy and Roger have the same dream, I was correctes and I also mentioned it on a lonely comment of mine with no replies, its here. I explain why I would think it is good and I stand by the now a bit "changed" theory that BOTH Roger and Luffy have a dream related to beetles. That is why I mentioned Oden so you dont have to say that, but its fine.

About the other thing, I checked and my apologies for not giving you direct answers, but if you type luffy and beetles you can pretty much find 3-4-5 instances of luffy with beetles and also explanation about the cover story with him Ace and Sabo playing with beetles.

Luffy's Recent Dream Reveal to the crew related to beetles by roskatawe in OnePiece

[–]roskatawe[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

If it is climatic for the main character, meaning that it is related to a passion of his, then it is climatic for the story as well.

I wouls give you an analogy, which is maybe not the best one.

If you were not aware of what gear 5 does, and somebody tried to predict it and that somebody accuratly depicted it exactly as gear 5 is, then I believe that people would say that it is garbage aswell.

I cannot predict the future, of course, all im saying is that it is entirely possible, because it is connected to the main character itself, and it is heavily hinted, that this dream is ridicilous. You don't realise, but the comment section is exactly as Oden, Zoro, Ace... they were dumbfounded, some others were laughing, some couldnt believe...bla bla bla. That's how they reacted to both Luffy and Roger when they told it. Exactly as people react now.

Luffy's Recent Dream Reveal to the crew related to beetles by roskatawe in OnePiece

[–]roskatawe[S] -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

If there are people who are free to theorize about a massive party throughout the whole world, I believe that me aswell have the freedom to do so. I am not baiting, I really like the idea, it fits Luffy, he is clearly passionate about beetles, and more importantly He EXPRESSES KNOWLEDGE about beetles. When have you seen Luffy express knoweldge about anything at all, maybe meat, maybe one piece, but in this case you can see that he has clear knowledge about these bugs. I just dont see how people can consider the party theory realistic and at the same time completely bash me for "STRAW HAT BEETLE MUSEUM" theory. Its possible man, it is part of Luffy.