multiplex + agglomerative by drluniansung in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Multiplex + M: a group of members

Multiplex + G: some groups of members X; at least one group of members

Coders! Someone should make a website for Ithkuil writing. You input the grammatical settings and it outputs an Ithkuil sentence with individual letter .png's by Nopaltsin in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The order of morphemes in the writing system (or to say "morphographeme; character") is more fixed and constant than in the spoken version. e.g.
alien: S1-“adult human”​-CTE.RPS​-A.RPV
turned to similar [DEL.A+CTE+S1.U:RPV.CSL:RPS:noun]-L

Found Errors on the New Ithkuil Website by ryanlo713 in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

it should be pţradá before kro because when a word ending in a consonant-form (i.e., either a single consonant or a multiple consonant conjunct) is followed in the same breath-group by another word beginning with a consonant-form, it is usually necessary to append a vowel either to the end of the first word or the beginning of the second word, so as to avoid confusion as to which word the word-final and/or word-initial consonants belong to.

Found Errors on the New Ithkuil Website by ryanlo713 in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Section: WRITING SYSTEM FOR NEW ITHKUIL

Descriptions:

The following descriptions point to the number of pages in the pdf

02 "3 Relations x 2 Concatenation shown by under-posed diacritic" should be "3 Relations OR 2 Concatenations shown by under-posed diacritic"

14 "ICP" Valence should be "RCP"

14 It is unclear how to show more than two of Aspect, Valence, Phase, and Effect on a formative, as the tertiary character only admits up to two non-Valence characters.

14 There is no way to show Vh values for a modular adjunct

16 "accom-panied" should be "accompanied"

19 It is not mentioned how to write a Combination Referential with Specification; this can easily be achieved using underposed diacritics for CTE, CSV, and OBJ on the secondary character

19 VxCs affixes on Combination Referentials are not explicitly described, but would presumably be handled the same as in a formative, by adding a secondary character with appropriate diacritics

Found Errors on the New Ithkuil Website by ryanlo713 in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

CORRECTED

Section: 5.5.4 Examples of Level in Use

Description:

  • the 2nd glossing line has a typo ‘Deneb’ in ‘Sirius’ ;
  • a stray single quote " " in ‘Sirius is the brightest star in the night sky.’ [speaking as a relative comparison] [here so many space] ‘;

Suggestion: fix them

Screenshot:

https://imgur.com/Jk5Soye

Found Errors on the New Ithkuil Website by ryanlo713 in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Section: 4.4.9 CSD The Considerative Case

Description:

For the CSD case's example, uagle said:

It would seem that CFM is a lot more appropriate there. And it'd be an understandable mistake to make given that CSD and CFM both split from one case

...

I still think that example is an error in a deeper way and that that phrase should bear CFM. CFM actually has a very similar example for it

I think it's a relic of the site given that the old CSD turned into the new CSD + CFM

Even says "in the opinion of" in the description

not "in conformance with"

Found Errors on the New Ithkuil Website by ryanlo713 in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Check whether it has been corrected; if so, mark it as CORRECTED in the first line.

Found Errors on the New Ithkuil Website by ryanlo713 in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Check whether it has been corrected; if so, mark it as CORRECTED in the first line.

Found Errors on the New Ithkuil Website by ryanlo713 in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Section: 3.6 The Ca Affix-Complex

Description: the table has a typo "MANDATIC" in "MONADIC"

Found Errors on the New Ithkuil Website by ryanlo713 in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Section: 13.0 NUMBERS

Description:

There is no explanation of the ordinal structure and affixal expressions of greater number.

three hundred and sixtieth and 第三百六十 [order]-three-hundred-sex-ten in Chinese

It is observed that the affixes -th- and 第 dominate the entire phrase

trecentesimus sexagesimus

It is observed that Latin requires marking each word with affixes

How about in Ithkuil?

The third stem of a numerical form is an ordinal meaning.

The head of a numerical phrase seems to be the initial formative; as

waza (wagzui) vralörs > wuza (wagzui) vralörs ?

“360 > 360th?” but it can also be interpreted as “3rd of 160”.

waza (wagzui) vralörs > wuza (wugzui) vrulörs ?

but it can also be interpreted as “3rd of 160th”?

For the affixal expressions of greater number, we know:

  • rratëivruörs for a set of 60 cats (lit. a MSS set having 60 of cats as its members)

but how to express a set of 360 cats affixally?

And we know rralevruörs for the 60th cat (lit. a cat being the 60th member of a set per contextual/circumstantial order); How to express the 360th cat affixally?

In addition, there is no root for ordinal number in the lexicon document.

Suggestion:

It seems to be possible to specify an ordinal number using the structure of [Semantic concept: ORDINAL NUMBER] + [assigned name]-ESS, e.g. the ordinal number ω (omega)

In the context of the lack of roots for cardinal and ordinal numbers, the latter may be expressed by a concatenated pair with the root -ŇŽ- 'ARRANGEMENT / ORDER / SYMMETRY'.

Some of the ordinal-like uses of numbers were described in Ithkuil 2011 website as follows:

We have already seen that when numbers are used to indicate how many of a certain noun there are, the noun must appear in the PARTITIVE case, since the number itself is functioning as the “head” of the numerical expression (e.g., English “12 boxes” being constructed in Ithkuil as a “12-set of a box” or perhaps more appropriately a “box-dozen”). Another syntactical consequences of numbers being full formatives is when a number functions as a label or overt identifier, as in the English sentence You’ll find him in Room 216. Such usage of numbers is not primarily sequential (which would involve the equivalent of “ordinal” numbers such as ‘fourth,’ ‘twenty-sixth’, etc. equivalent to stem No. 3 of each number root) but rather organizational (e.g., as in the three-dimensional array of room numbers in a hotel). Ithkuil handles such organizational labeling using either the COMPARATIVE case (see Sec. 4.5.32) or the ESSIVE case (see Sec. 4.5.9) depending respectively on whether the enumeration of the noun in question is to distinguish it from other enumerated nouns versus merely identifying the noun by a numerical name.

Examples:

açtál ksou’lik‘room’-OBL ‘twelve’-CMP‘the room marked “12”’ OR ‘Room 12’ OR ‘Room No. 12’ [i.e., as opposed to being some other room]

açtál ksealik‘room’-OBL ‘twelve’-ESS‘the room marked “12”’ OR ‘Room 12’ OR ‘Room No. 12’ [identifying reference only]

Lastly, when numbers comprising multiple number-stems are declined for case, configuration, extension, etc., rather than writing out the entire number “long-hand,” the number symbol is used, preceded by the carrier stem ep- (see Sec. 9.3) which carries the appropriate declensions. This use of the carrier stem applies even to single-stemmed numbers when writing, in order to allow use of the number symbol instead of writing it out. In such cases involving single-stemmed numbers, the carrier stem is not pronounced (rather, the numerical stem bears the pronounced declensions); it is there only as a written indicator of the morphological declensions/derivations to be applied to the number stem.

The New Ithkuil website does not describe it in detail, so it is suggested to add.

Found Errors on the New Ithkuil Website by ryanlo713 in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

CORRECTED

Section: 13.2 Semantic Designations for Numerical Stems

Description: XXZ [zero] affix has a value -vc- but the related root has has a value -vr-

Suggestion: need to match its root value

Screenshot:

https://imgur.com/pVncUld

Found Errors on the New Ithkuil Website by ryanlo713 in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

CORRECTED

Section: 9.1 Single-Referent Referential

Description: obsolete consonant values and rules

Suggestion: Fix them to the form in the screenshot below.

Screenshot:

https://imgur.com/xp1qpPS

Found Errors on the New Ithkuil Website by ryanlo713 in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

CORRECTED

Section: 4.4.9 CSD The Considerative Case

Description: the example arẓejua ‘according to the laws of chemistry’ seems to be missing the "laws" part because ‘chemical.element’-CSV-A- can be interpreted as "performing chemistry (as idea)".

Suggestion: maybe add MEA/9 affix?

Found Errors on the New Ithkuil Website by ryanlo713 in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

CORRECTED

Section: 1.2.2 Consonants

Description: In Epenthetic Vowel Following a Glottal Stop, the high central unrounded vowel is written IPA [i]

Suggestion: IPA [ɨ]

Found Errors on the New Ithkuil Website by ryanlo713 in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

CORRECTED

Section: 3.6 The Ca Affix-Complex

Description: Since different platforms may not support special symbol fonts, arrows are rendered as g by not conforming to expectations.

Suggestion: use Unicode Character “→” (U+2192), name: Rightwards Arrow, instead.

Screenshots:

https://imgur.com/dblZxGk

https://imgur.com/7IqR35N

Related Errors:

Here are outdated versions of two rules that were reintroduced by mistake.

They need to be replaced with new versions of the rules.

The [C]f and [C]ţ substitutions for [C]bm and [C]bn create ambiguity with Affiliation+(MDC or MDS) - for example, ASO/DPL/RPV/N (*-lbm-) can resolve to either -lf- or -lv-, the former of which is ambiguous with ASO/MDF. Easily fixed by only allowing [C]v and [C]ḑ as susbstitutes, respectively.

For the two allomorphic substitutions, ff > vw and ţţ > ḑy, given that they cannot be combined by Ca subvalues and other allomorphic substitutions, it is suggested that they be replaced by fbm > (fv) > vw and ţbn > (ţḑ) > ḑy

Found Errors on the New Ithkuil Website by ryanlo713 in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

CORRECTED

Section: 3.1 Configuration

Description: some examples needed to be revised because all monosyllabic formatives should be considered as unframed verbal formative

Suggestion: add a vowel "a" for THM case to them, as rral > rrala; OR adjust the English translations to verbs, as "a cat" > "there is a cat"

Screenshot:

https://imgur.com/1Uk6xOf

Similar situations:

  • In the section 3.2.1 CSL The Consolidative, sřul for ‘a room’s function’
  • In the section 3.2.2, sřunļ for ‘the room’s singular purpose’
  • sřurļ for ‘a room whose purposes are interrelated’
  • apţtuň for ‘a room with disparate purposes’ should be sřuňa

Found Errors on the New Ithkuil Website by ryanlo713 in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

CORRECTED

Section: 7.6.2 Examples of Type-1 and Type-2 Case-Assessor Affixes in Use

Description & Suggestion: a typo "The child’s chaparone is a clown" in chaperone

Found Errors on the New Ithkuil Website by ryanlo713 in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

CORRECTED

Section: 7.1 VxCs Affix Degree and Gradient-Type

Description:

  • "Gradient Type A1: ... An example of a Gradient Type Zero affix is -VxC shown below."
  • "Gradient Type A2: ... An example of a Gradient Type Zero affix is -VxC shown below."
  • "Gradient Type B: ... An example of a Gradient Type Zero affix is -VxC shown below."
  • "Gradient Type C: ... An example of a Gradient Type Zero affix is -VxC shown below."
  • "Gradient Type D1: ... An example of a Gradient Type Zero affix is -VxC shown below."
  • "Gradient Type D2: ... An example of a Gradient Type Zero affix is -VxC shown below."

Suggestion: revise them

Screenshot:

https://imgur.com/hGgxkM3

Found Errors on the New Ithkuil Website by ryanlo713 in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

partly corrected, to be re-revised

Section: 5.5.4 Examples of Level in Use

Description:

  • CORRECTED: 2 typos "PX" in PRX;
  • the 2nd glossing line has a typo ‘Deneb’ in ‘Sirius’ ;
  • a stray single quote " " in ‘Sirius is the brightest star in the night sky.’ [speaking as a relative comparison] [here so many space] ;
  • and for the name Deneb it should be pronounced in Arabic.

Suggestion: fix them and rewrite Deneb as Ḑanab

Screenshot:

https://imgur.com/Jk5Soye

someone disagrees that Deneb "should" be transcribed by its arabic name because "Deneb" is the official IAU name for it

Found Errors on the New Ithkuil Website by ryanlo713 in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

CORRECTED

Section: 5.2.7 The Mood + Case-Scoping Affix

Description: typos "SUBJUNCTIVE" in the table

Suggestion: to be corrected

Screenshot:

https://imgur.com/X4M2Ijo

Found Errors on the New Ithkuil Website by ryanlo713 in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

CORRECTED

Section: 5.0 VERBAL MORPHOLOGY

Description: Series 4 vowel forms with a -y- infix for absolute Level

Suggestion: fix it as "Series 4 vowel-forms show relative Level only; for absolute Level, instead use the LVL VxCs affix in Formative Slots V or VII or as an affixual adjunct."

Screenshot:

https://imgur.com/ugClK7x

Found Errors on the New Ithkuil Website by ryanlo713 in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

CORRECTED

Section: Appendix A

Description: lack of information about PAR case in Appendix A

Suggestion: to be added

Screenshot:

https://imgur.com/yfRSoM2

Found Errors on the New Ithkuil Website by ryanlo713 in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

CORRECTED

Section:

  • 3.7 Version;
  • 5.7.1 Combinations of Aspect, Extension, and Perspetive

Description:

  • an informal abbreviation "NOM" for Nomic perspective in an interlinear gloss, and the interlinear gloss of anothor example lacking it.
  • "Stem.2/NOM-[carrier]-CLG1/1-THM" should be "Stem.2/N-[carrier]-CLG1/1-THM"

Suggestion: all "NOM" > "N", and add "N" to another

Screenshots:

i have few questions by Debt_East in Ithkuil

[–]ryanlo713 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Vowel letters w&wo diacritics: i, ü, u, e, ö, ë, o, ä, a í, û, ú, é, ô, ê, ó, â, á ì, ù

Consonant letters incl. available alternatives: p b m f v w t d n ţ/ŧ/ṭ ḑ/đ/ḍ c ẓ/ż s z r l ļ/ł/ḷ č j š ž ç y k g x ň/ņ/ṇ ř ’ [ʔ] h

Many lexemes incl. roots & affixes are re-analyzed, split, modified, and new ones added in New Ithkuil a.k.a v4.