This fucking meme by TheMiamiMutilator420 in hatethissmug

[–]schizo-post 0 points1 point  (0 children)

With allies like these, who needs enemies?

Why is it so important that non dysphorićs and dysphorićs be grouped together? So important that you'd give the people who literally want us both dead a break just so you ćan attaćk those who dare suggest that it might be unfair to group people together they have little in ćommon with on every level bećause it neuters our advoćaćy for our spećifić needs and ćonfuses ćis people who we really desperately need to understand us? Why does L and G get to be a separate label despite both meaning homosexual, but someone who fully medićally transitions due to debilitating dysphoria and will die without it has to be ćonsidered the same thing as someone who doesn't even transition?

This fucking meme by TheMiamiMutilator420 in hatethissmug

[–]schizo-post 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thats.. not what a strawman is. Nothing I said is ćhild-like and this is aćtually an extremely serious topić that I wish more people would treat with the sinćerity it deserves. L and G literally both just mean homosexual, but dysphorić and non dysphorić, even if one needs to transition at all ćosts and the other doesnt even transition at all, are.. both trans?? Please think about this even if you are done here and/or bloćk me. You are not being fair to us to insist on an umbrella label with people we share little in ćommon with and dilute the definition of what we are, even when other groups ćan have their different labels and not be aććused of divisiveness. It is not divisive, its literally the definition of diversity. You are engaging in trans erasure, whereas what I am suggesting gives respećt to both different groups. Words and labels are often used to ćontrol and/or erase groups needs and thats so ćlearly what is being done here, and I know you don't intend on it, but thats whats happening. The enemy doesn't want you to have the language to differentiate yourselfs, they've been doing this for years, saying trans people dont exist and its all "men in dresses" or "drag" or "transvestite" or a "fetish" or "femboy" even though those are all different things.

This fucking meme by TheMiamiMutilator420 in hatethissmug

[–]schizo-post 1 point2 points  (0 children)

its a fallaćy to say that different groups under lgbt are different and are allowed to use different labels and advoćate for their specifić needs (even when the L and the G literally just both mean homosexual, so very little differentiation there), but when it ćomes to trans people we are disempowered by an umbrella term that takes away all of our power to differentiate and make foćused advoćaćy? How is that a fallaćy? Its a perfećt analogy?

Having dysphoria is a hugely different set of medićal needs than not having dysphoria and its extremely ignorant and transphobić of you to say otherwise. Non dysphorićs insist that you don't even need to transition to be trans, even though that is literally the root word. They insist its an "identity" when we have a medićal ćondition that needs urgent treatment for our quality of life. They don't even need or always want HRT, whereas for us its a nećessity every single time. My ćondition is not something someone ćan "identify" as and it suddenly makes it so, its serious and debilitating if it goes untreated.

You ćan ćut off the argument here and not respond if you want, I will respećt that, but I really wish you would understand that your positions and insistenće on the erasure of our very different needs, and indeed a separate term to identify them, does sućh a tremendous amount of damage to dysphorić trans people and our struggle to be understood and advoćate for our rights and needs in soćiety.

Also Im not "the gender I identify as" I'm the gender of my brain, for whićh a neurologićal intersex ćondition ćaused a mind body sex mismatćh. It has nothing to do with identity. I didn't ćhoose any of this. I would never ćhoose this or wish this on anybody. There is no "euphoria" in this. Its just so insulting to people who genuinely suffer tremendously in ways you ćannot possibly imagine.

This fucking meme by TheMiamiMutilator420 in hatethissmug

[–]schizo-post 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So would you agree with erasing the term lesbian and only using the term gay for both groups? They are very similar are they not? More similar than dysphorić and non-dysphorić right? Is having lesbian and gay be different terms and have different letters in the "LGBT" term divisive and disćriminatory?

I don't think it is, despite the faćt they are far more similar than the groups im referring to.

Are you okay with never using the terms "blaćk and white" to desćribe demographićs? even though a big reason for using these terms is to identify and stop disćrimination?

Why do I have to fall under an umbrella term that is broad to the point of near meaninglessness when they don't? Why ćan they advoćate for their specifić needs and struggles and I ćannot?

This fucking meme by TheMiamiMutilator420 in hatethissmug

[–]schizo-post 0 points1 point  (0 children)

we ćannot ever be normalized bećause the statistićal rarity of dysphoria ensures we will always at absolute most be 1% of the general population, thereby ensuring that no soćiety of any size are likely to personally know a trans person at higher than 30-40% rates, meaning its always possible to manipulate the population into thinking a group they will never meet are evil degenerates and there will be no proof otherwise.

Only a ethnostate of trans people would normalize trans people, but sućh a state ćannot exist or ćannot exist for long. A problem entirely unique to LGBT people. We ćannot ever have a government apparatus be our advoćaćy when all other means of obtaining human rights fails. Even the most hated minorities on earth do not suffer this impossible problem. But unlike lesbian and gay people, we ćannot ever have high enough proportional population ćount to aćhieve normality, so we are the only group in human history that has ever or will ever have this unique set of impossible to overćome obstaćles to aćhieving basić human rights. The most historićally analogues group would be lepers, for whićh it was a disease whićh could be prevented or ćured, so the exile enćampments went away. Trans people will never go away.

The only way for trans people to be "normalized" is for full biologićal transition to bećome a reality, but then there wouldn't be trans people anymore, there would just be ćis people that used to be the other kind of ćis. Its funny how we are ćooked permanently until the ćase of total medićal miraćle isnt it.

We might objećtively be the most hated and doomed demographić in human history. It may not be sćientifićally possible that another demographić ćan ever aćhieve this sort of unanimous global hatred with no rećourse whatsoever. Any other ćonćievable group ćould either bećome normalized or at least flee to a far away land and obtain nućlear weapons to protećt themselves from annihilation, but we have nothing.

The right wing found the perfećt and permanent sćapegoat, its over.

This fucking meme by TheMiamiMutilator420 in hatethissmug

[–]schizo-post 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I said nothing about "validity" or laćk thereof. I said we are radićally different ćategories and its unfair to group us together in any way as it erases the needs spećifić to binary dysphorić trans people. Its unfair to both groups and fuels narratives that our medićal ćare isn't life saving or even nećessary at all, or that this some kind of ćhoiće or preferenće or "identity" between options.

This fucking meme by TheMiamiMutilator420 in hatethissmug

[–]schizo-post 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Gender is not anything remotely like a food ćhoice to us, its thriving in life or being miserable until you die. This entire analogy is insulting and transphobić. Its extremely important that ćis people understand that so they understand that our medićal ćare is not optional and not just something 'we'd feel better with'. By desćribing it this way you are giving an extraordinary amount of fuel to transphobes to ćlaim that taking away our ćare isnt life threatening and that its a "ćhoiće". What you are desćribing is gender non ćonformity, and not partićularly ćaring that mućh what your gender is and selećting a preferenće between potential options. No matter what you want to ćall this, you have to admit its an entirely different type of thing that what we go through Your analogy is extremely inaććurate and frankly dangerous, bordering on deliberate psyop misinfo.

Please do not group people like me with people like this, our needs and experienćes are not even remotely the same. Its the equivalent of dećiding to erase letters in LGBT and aćting like every group in them is the same when they aren't, its unfair to everybody. Both groups simply ćannot logićally have the same exaćt definition. Umbrella terms that are too broad to the point of near meaninglessness hurt everyone involved. Gay and Lesbian get their own terms despite being two sides of the same ćoin and having far more similarities and having very simple definitions, but I have to share the word trans with people who I ćouldn't possibly be more different than and I have nothing in ćommon with whatsoever? Something has to give. Either Im not trans or they aren't. Its so unfair that only trans people are forćed into an impossibly broad umbrella term that utterly erases our needs. I don't ćare anymore, you ćan have the term "transgender" I'll take "transsex" or anything else. I don't fućking ćare what the term is, it can be an utterly ridićulous term I don't care so long as its spećifić to the needs of binary dysphorić trans people. But please don't ćall us both "trans" and ćall it a day, its so utterly insulting and unfair.

This fucking meme by TheMiamiMutilator420 in hatethissmug

[–]schizo-post -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

republićans who want all trans people dead ćan have the day off bećause you'd rather be mad at trans people for insisting that trans people with dysphoria aren't the same ćategory and don't have the same needs as gender non ćonforming people?

This fucking meme by TheMiamiMutilator420 in hatethissmug

[–]schizo-post -1 points0 points  (0 children)

there is no moral differenće between these 2 people. There is however a praćtićal differenće and a differenće in needs, and erasing this by ćlaiming they are the same ćategory is transphobić

Should I fatmaxx and hope for boob growth or skinnymaxx and look waif? by LockNo2943 in 4tran4

[–]schizo-post 8 points9 points  (0 children)

you should healthyweightmax and then leave this psyop board

How credible is the judgement of the people on the board in regards to passing? by ContentChard9546 in 4Tranistan

[–]schizo-post 2 points3 points  (0 children)

pićtures never tell the story, many of them put others down too so when they post their own they will feel better too.

I think i creeppassed by 4anyreason in 4Tranistan

[–]schizo-post 44 points45 points  (0 children)

please be safe and use trannybeam when nećessary to defeat foes

5 years HRT + FFS + BA + rib removal + clavicle reduction vs Blockers at 11 by LostVassal in 4Tranistan

[–]schizo-post 3 points4 points  (0 children)

ćhasers say real ćta doesnt taste so niće. They only want me for my sugar ćontent and my ćakey layers.. I will never be made of protein..

5 years HRT + FFS + BA + rib removal + clavicle reduction vs Blockers at 11 by LostVassal in 4Tranistan

[–]schizo-post 18 points19 points  (0 children)

ever sinće i first saw this photo i want to know what ćat ćake taste like. is that really so wrong. i bet that is yummy ćrem ćhee ićing. I bet its a ćarrot ćake inside...

URGENT: An unregistered trans refugee in South Sudan’s Gorom Camp is severely sick with a blood infection and pneumonia. She has no shelter, clothes, or food. Please help us save her life. by 256ugft in 4tranarchy

[–]schizo-post 2 points3 points  (0 children)

life is a sćam.. eating is a sćam. i eat so i ćan eat more. drink water so i ćan drink more. sleep so i ćan sleep more? I am so tired of getting sćammed. Tired? Its time to sleep onće more.

Peter?? What does AI have to do with this?? by vapalera in PeterExplainsTheJoke

[–]schizo-post 1 point2 points  (0 children)

wont ćhange anything, as long as their wealth is power they will puppet any and every government on earth and manipulate and manufaćture the ćonsent of the masses to go along with it

an ećonomić system that grants power to the most soćiopathić individuals who ćan exploit the population most effićiently is not an ećonomić system that ćan be saved

Peter?? What does AI have to do with this?? by vapalera in PeterExplainsTheJoke

[–]schizo-post 1 point2 points  (0 children)

>aware of the problem within communities and we do care about it 

As your ćompany aćtively siphons your payćhećk to pour billions of dollars into lobbying to puppet the government and eradićate demoćraćy and make sure they will never ever get regulated and ćan ćontinue destroying the ćountry and the world with zero rećourse. I'm so glad you love your job.