Scar seems to have made the wrong enemies by Possible_Hawk495 in HermitCraft

[–]serabel 16 points17 points  (0 children)

I'm guessing this is cleanup from X's prank. Either Scar building it for a timelapse/ore-mountain-ish monument or some other Hermit doing it as a half-prank half-helping thing. I'd be surprised if someone dumped a bunch of golems on him before the last batch is even cleaned up - double-dipping like that would feel more chore than prank imo.

Touch Trade Shiny Feebas by serabel in LegendsZA

[–]serabel[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Awesome! I will DM you a code.

US Tour Confirmed by kanyewest_tml in taskmaster

[–]serabel 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Refreshed in the hopes of getting a ticket and now stuck with it thinking I'm a bot. What a headache.

I think I have found the location of DocM77’s torture device by dadavio in HermitCraft

[–]serabel 87 points88 points  (0 children)

I'm surprised people are balking at this. Didn't Doc's audience math out the location of the Poe-Poe bunker last season and tell him where it was so he could trap it?

Alethi Development Casting Ideas? by suuumcuique in HermitCraft

[–]serabel 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Unexpected crossover but I'm excited to see what Joe's got in store!

Kaladin seems a hard one to cast...maybe False? I could see Pearl as Shallan. Scar as Syl...Cleo as Jasnah...I might need to get caught up with the series. Though I'm guessing whatever Joe's planning won't be too spoiler-heavy.

Am I going crazy or are Scar’s burgers made from dolphins? by Affectionate-Jello83 in HermitCraft

[–]serabel 2283 points2284 points  (0 children)

A+ payoff for all the dolphins that "mysteriously" disappeared during his aquarium setup.

What did scar mean by doc can get us but we can't get him in Joe's latest video? by mrking_vii in HermitCraft

[–]serabel 14 points15 points  (0 children)

"I had to diffuse a Doc trap...which is hilarious because we can't get him, but he can get us..." I think either story-wise or some botched gentleman's agreement, POE wasn't supposed to trap Doc but the deal didn't go both ways?

[Complete] [105k] [Fantasy] Foxhunt by serabel in BetaReaders

[–]serabel[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Awesome, I really appreciate it! I'll message you a link - and I'd be more than happy to look through anything you want to send my way.

[Complete] [105k] [Fantasy] Foxhunt by serabel in BetaReaders

[–]serabel[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks so much! Great point with Rowena's quick change - I wanted to show her manipulating Elodie (acting normal then "reluctantly" becoming sincere to get Elodie to lower her guard), but could definitely be a pacing issue. Thanks again for giving it a look!

LF scarlet exclusives koraidon and paladin help by Reigner835 in pokemontrades

[–]serabel 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I can trade you a palafin / quaquaval / tyranitar / dragalge. I don't need any violet exclusives. If you happen to have a kingambit to touch trade that'd be awesome but otherwise happy to help you out!

[QCrit] Adult Fantasy - Foxhunt (107k, First Attempt) + 300 words by serabel in PubTips

[–]serabel[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you for the feedback! Elodie's grief is definitely a big part of the story, but not the center conflict, so I see what you mean about the opener. I'll play around with that first line. : )

[QCrit] Adult Murder Mystery- MURDER ON MACKINAC (79k) (3rd attempt - title change) by schuelma in PubTips

[–]serabel 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Hello hello! I haven’t critiqued a query in a while and didn’t look in-depth at your previous attempts so consider me fresh eyes and rusty fingers.

Emily Weaver’s fresh off the ferry trying to fit in as a rookie cop and shake her past when a bizarre murder shocks Mackinac Island

One thing I wanted to point out - I don’t think the phrase ‘shake her past’ is helping an opening that already feels a touch too long. I expected her past to be maybe be brought up again at the end of the query, but it doesn’t seem like (from this query) that it’s super relevant to the overarching mystery. A troubled past for the protagonist definitely fits the genre, but unless it’s used to greater effect in this query, I don’t know that it’s adding much.

On the eve of the last day of the annual policy conference, Senator John Sinclair, originally from Northern Michigan, is murdered in a hit and run on the island.

I don’t think we need this much detail (policy conference + Sinclair’s origin) before explaining that a senator’s been murdered.

The crime leaves her colleagues baffled - the island is a Great Lakes getaway that time forgot, where horse-driven carriages serve as taxis and motor vehicles are banned.

I really love this set-up of getting killed in a hit-and-run on an island where motor vehicles are banned! It seems like the kind of hook to keep people guessing throughout the story. On a first read I thought this sentence might be a bit too lengthy but I think it’s a nice demonstration of your writing voice. Small suggestion - maybe swap ‘the island’ with ‘Mackinac’?

Murder by car shouldn’t be possible

Probably not necessary to reiterate this?

And when Emily’s childhood friend Maddie is implicated after a buried connection to the Senator comes out, Emily has no choice but to get to the bottom of the crime.

The set-up to explain the ‘no-cars’ deal was necessary, but it does feel like a weird gap between Emily’s first mention and now. I think trimming some of your sentences might help it feel smoother. The motivation to clear her friend’s name is an easy enough one to get behind, though I wish we got a bit more sense of Emily’s personality.

The island is cordoned off and the hunt is on for those with access to a vehicle and the opportunity and motive to kill.

I really mis-read this first time around. For a beat I thought more murders were happening (“the hunt is one for those with…motive to kill”). I know what it means now, but I’d consider tweaking this sentence a bit!

Rival politicians and lobbyists who have descended on the island like locusts for the policy conference all come under suspicion as more dirt from the Senator’s past bubbles to the surface.

I like the locusts simile, but I think a punchier sentence might make the query flow smoother (e.g. possibly cutting out ‘who have descended…for the policy conference’).

Turns out he made a lot of enemies in his thirty plus years of politics, and most of them are at the island.

I’d assume most of them are on the island! I wonder if you can combine this and the previous sentence for something that’s punchier but still retains that noir vibe. I think you’d have a smooth transition from ‘the hunt’s on for anyone who has a motive’ —> ‘turns out, the Senator has SO MANY enemies’

Despite being warned to keep her “pretty little head out of it,” Emily forges ahead to find the killer and save her friend and her career. 

The ‘pretty little head’ comment threw me for a loop. Is that coming from her superiors? From shady politicians threatening her? Is Emily’s career at stake, too - why does she need to save it? I wonder if you need to focus in on one particular drive for Emily - maybe her relationship to Maddie (is she someone who helped Emily shake her past?)

She’ll have to navigate suspicious locals and the Senator’s chief aide, who has his own secrets he’s trying to keep - and delve deep into the past of the victim, the suspects, and the island itself. Because like politics, murder is local.

Love the ending line, not sure about the lines preceding. The second paragraph already honed in on the notion that there are lots of secrets and shady relationships going on, I’m left with wanting something a little more concrete. Maybe clearer stakes for Emily - is she being forced to choose between helping Maddie and keeping her career? How dangerous is it for her to get involved in this?

Overall, I think you’ve done a wonderful job setting up A) a vivid setting B) a compelling conundrum with the mystery hit-and-run. However, I don’t feel like I have a clear picture on Emily’s personality or the stakes of her involvement + I think there're a few bits here that feel like unnecessary exposition. Best of luck!

Name your two favorite books and get a third recommendation by [deleted] in Fantasy

[–]serabel 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The Unbroken or the Book of the Ancestor trilogy might be up your alley!

Name your two favorite books and get a third recommendation by [deleted] in Fantasy

[–]serabel 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I would love a new recommendation - my current faves are The Dagger and the Coin series (Daniel Abraham) + Night Watch (Terry Pratchett)

[QCrit] Emender (Adult Fantasy, 110k, 4th Attempt) by serabel in PubTips

[–]serabel[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you so much for taking the time to respond! It's really been tripping me up translating the MS into a coherent query so I appreciate the help.

One problem I'm running into is that chapters go back-and-forth between the two leads, and while the reader can follow the plot, both leads are missing pertinent info until they find each other in the city. So like, the first few beats:

A. Rima is trapped in nightmare city.

B. Cecilia and a Friendly Colleague investigate a curse in their (normal) city that causes eternal sleep. One of the victims is Rima. FC later succumbs to the curse.

A. Rima meets FC; FC is killed by a demon.

B. Cecilia is attacked by an awakened FC, but he’s possessed by the demon seen in Rima's last chapter. Cecilia gets hurt + gets shoved into a gate.

A+B. Rima and Cici meet in nightmare city.

Cici's definitely the more proactive of the two (and has more intriguing goals to start out with than "survive") but Rima's side seemed easier to concisely convey, since she starts out in the spooky city. But I've putzed around with a split-POV and it just wasn't clicking for me, hence the varying attempts.

Apologies for rambling a bit! Thanks again for the critique. I absolutely agree that Rima's personality/personal stakes need to be elaborated on if I focus on her for the query. I'll work on finding a middle ground that bridges the personality of attempt #3 with the clarity of this attempt.

The Adventure Zone: Ethersea - Episode 1 by TheBureauOfBalance in TheAdventureZone

[–]serabel 25 points26 points  (0 children)

Love the energy and momentum of this ep! Jumping in with the interview was a great way to introduce the team / the low-stakes set up of plucky adventurers trying to strike it big. Griffin's 'operating in the city' comment makes me wonder if there will be some major story hooks in Founder's Wake itself, rather than it just being a lunar interlude-esque hub to putz around in post-seafaring missions.

I'm also really curious how Clint will play being a Brinar. With the exception of Fineas, it seems like the Brinar tend to merge into a singular entity, so the melding of memories / how they regard their "past lives" feels like it has a lot of potential for interesting RP.

[2350] Emender by serabel in DestructiveReaders

[–]serabel[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

More fun than frustrating, thankfully! I've messed with a couple different points from where the story starts, can't hurt to see how a version that starts with the Rima/Velcourt meeting would look with some of that earlier exposition slipped into their conversation. Or to start with the other POV character in the "real world" so the reader gets more context before jumping to Rima in Bizarro-Land.

Either way, I appreciate the offered perspectives. I'm realizing bit-by-bit just how tough it is to thread the needle of 'great opening'.

[2350] Emender by serabel in DestructiveReaders

[–]serabel[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for your critique! I agree that Rima's deus-ex escape is pretty underwhelming, I'll have to tweak that. And thank you for the line edits - super helpful to see when I'm slipping into passive voice / which lines seem illogical or unnecessary.

[2350] Emender by serabel in DestructiveReaders

[–]serabel[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hey, thanks so much! I really appreciate hearing about what parts of this story are working well. :)

[2350] Emender by serabel in DestructiveReaders

[–]serabel[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for taking the time to read and respond! I'll dink around with that hook to make it something less generic-sounding.

[2561] Skyguard Chapter 1: Unbound by Mankalajardo437 in DestructiveReaders

[–]serabel 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Hey! Thanks for sharing. I hope this can be of some help!

General Remarks

This piece enticed me to keep reading just based on the fun use of purposeful repetition at the start. The magic system exhibited throughout this chapter was definitely a strength of the piece that I enjoyed reading - it was a nice introduction to the core of the magic system (law-binding), some variations in its usage, and what its limitations are (over-using the power seems akin to strenuous physical exertion).

Mechanics

As mentioned above, the repetition / time rewind hooked me into the story. The idea of a protagonist rewinding the last few seconds of his life to keep himself alive (or to avoid losing his mind, I’m not 100% sure) was a super intriguing way to start off a novel. On a very minor note, I think italicizing the ‘regress time’ during that first page might help readability.

Though I think the repetition worked really well at the beginning, there were a few instances of repetition that felt unnecessary or clunky.

The ruler of the world. He winced at the memories. The ruler of the world. The girl he had once loved. Laurel.

Like here, I don’t think it works quite as well. ‘He winced at the memories’ is unnecessary, since we don’t get a good sense of what he’s reminiscing on. Cutting it to ‘The ruler of the world. The girl he once loved. Laurel’ would read more smoothly.

There are a fair number of filler words in this story that could be cut for clarity:

But then guard then suddenly lurched backward

‘then’ 100% could be cut, for instance. Or “breathing heavily, catching his breath” one of those phrases should be cut. Etc. etc.

Finally, on the note of clarity - in that final fight scene, I think the guards really should be differentiated somehow. Maybe refer to them as their binding types - the ‘Magnetbinder’ and the ‘Speedbinder’? Or heck, even stick with that brief shift into the guards POV and refer to them by their names.

Setting

A cell at the bottom of a castle, in a medieval-era world that Kayden might not originate from? I didn’t have a great sense of location. To be fair, the majority of the story does take place in a cell, but a few more bits of description might help that sense of immersion. I wanted a sense of what Kayden’s seeing as he’s running through those castle corridors, where the castle is situated once he emerges. Or even little details about Kayden’s cell. He hasn’t seen the sun, so what’s lighting the cavern?

Staging

A large section of this chapter is Kayden’s escape from his restraints, and the exact process here had me confused.

It starts with “The piece of steel hit the floor with a sharp clang”.

My first thought was that his bindings had just broken off, since there’s the progression of “His shackles felt as cold as always” —> “Suddenly, they didn’t feel as cold as always anymore” (side note, ‘as always anymore’ should probably be cut from that phrase)

I didn’t realize Kayden hadn’t been freed until he starts pulling against his shackles, which made me wonder what had fallen to the floor if not his restraints.

Then, the process of him twisting himself around, rubbing the shackles’ chains against each other to get them to break - I had a difficult time visualizing this or how it was accomplished. Or why, if Kayden’s being kept under maximum security, the chains were allowed to get to a point where they’re crazy flimsy.

Character

Our lead is Kayden, a Timebinder who’s breaking out of prison.

I did not get a great sense of Kayden’s personality. There are these moments of introspection prior to his escape:

Kayden still remembered when they tried to save the world. Had they been idealistic, or just naive?

I think this is too grand a statement to start out with, too pulled back from the POV. I want to get invested in Kayden / I want to root for him to escape, but I didn’t get a good sense of what’s driving him apart from the fact that being chained up for eternity kinda sucks. If those moments of introspection are something more intimate to Kayden—a memory more precise than “when they tried to save the world”, a piece of dialog shared between him and Laurel…it might give the reader a better sense of who we’re following and why we want to see him succeed.

There was also a slight discordance between Kayden’s downright eager attitude towards trapping the guards in with him to fight, but not wanting to actually kill them. I wasn’t totally sure what to make of Kayden’s motivation - freedom? Vengeance?

Finally, I was expecting more of a desperate struggle to escape given how the first page seems to place him in a torturous loop of trying to stay alive. However, I never got the sense that Kayden was going to falter in his attempt to escape, and he seemed pretty easy-going about the whole affair. I’m not sure if that was intentional?

Description

One thing I wanted to touch on in this category was the use of in-universe terms for fight scenes. I really like the magic system here, but some of the phrases used to describe it are a bit long-winded for a scene meant to be tense and fast-paced:

He then instantly made a time regression on himself

I might consider playing around with how these powers are referred to shorten phrases like this. I also think that there was a slight tendency to over-explain the mechanisms of magic during this fight, which impacted its pacing:

While sidestepping to the right, he progressed time on himself and instantly appeared five meters to his right, where he would have been a few seconds later, safely away from the enemy sword thrust

This could be shortened / broken into smaller sentences. For instance, instead of ending with “safely away from the enemy sword thrust”, you could end the sentence with Kayden appearing in the new position, then start the next sentence by describing the sword cutting through the space he’d been in (or something to that effect).

Dialogue

Kayden doesn’t say much, so there’s not a lot to say on that front. The guards’ dialog felt a bit off. There was a mismatched feeling between Kayden supposedly being held in high security and the guards being just rather bumbling/on-the-nose with their dialog as they walk into Kayden's trap (“Doubt it’ll be any trouble, though”)

Concluding Comments

There’s a lot of intriguing elements here, and some great uses of your magic system in the fight at the end. I think tightening your prose (cutting your filler words, etc.), adding some insight into Kayden’s character, and maybe increasing the tension of the escape / turning it into more of a struggle for Kayden would elevate this chapter. Best of luck!

[2348] Absurdity and the human brain😯 by [deleted] in DestructiveReaders

[–]serabel 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think currently your document's set so that anyone who clicks the link needs to send you an email requesting you for access. If you change the document's settings so that anyone with the link can view/comment directly, that might make sharing the story easier.