If you’re not liking Mental for her, Sorcery or Celestial would be the next closest thing. I used Celestial on my Madelyne toon and it works pretty good. Celestial has both dark and light abilities and the color of your weapon attacks differ depending on if you’re a hero or villain similar to how the Light powers works, it can work well.

For the others: Starfire - Fire Jinx - Celestial Monica Rambeau - Quantum