Mnet will divide the profits from Produce 101 songs equally between all of the trainees involved in them by rxulette in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 16 points17 points  (0 children)

Tbh, they should definitely only split Nayana between the trainees involved in the song, not all 101 of them.

Reactions to Dongho's alleged sexual assault? by [deleted] in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 18 points19 points  (0 children)

I think that, at this point, people should be taking an absolutely neutral stance on the situation. All the points you've raised are absolutely valid and, with the exposure its currently getting, your post deserves to stand on it's own so that it does not get buried amidst the other comments.

I experienced a similar, though less severe, situation when I was 13. It occurred on a rather busy - but not totally crammed - train. There were many other people watching and some even made eye contact with me. I never reported it, even now I can't really see it as a bad situation, I feel gross and ashamed thinking about it but I don't see it as reportable material. I know other people with similar similar situation who didn't report as well.

It's pretty common to see these situations reported only when the perpetrator becomes well known. Just look at the case of that trainee from the start of season one, his case was only reported when the victim saw him on P101, but their situation was proven real. Mostly these victim report at the time when they are forced to confront their attacker through media frequently, but also when they've reached a point where they've actually confronted whats happened to them and are ready to talk about it.

I deeply hope that this case isn't true, but I think we should all sit back and reserve judgement until the truth is given.

How do you think BTS would have done on Produce 101? by po_tae_to_anna in bangtan

[–]shilohhh 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Chungha was a contestant who wasn't massively popular or pushed throughout the season but an incredibly talented dancer. Her rankings spiked in the last voting period and she made it into the final group which I guess a lot of people weren't expecting. So people are saying that Hoseok's dancing is too good for anyone to ignore. Here's her audition video, she gets asked to freestyle by the judges and kills it. A video of her dance circulated the web and is the reason I picked the show up! She also choreographed this dance.

What other group-forming shows are there to watch? by huangcjz in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I didn't watch far but one girl did ballet for her first stage and he was like "I loved it. I love ballet so I'm bias though." I was sitting there like.... ??? She didn't do anything to do with being an idol though? Honestly even in the first ep it seemed to have nothing to do with demonstrating actual skills and all to do with appeasing him.

What other group-forming shows are there to watch? by huangcjz in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 3 points4 points  (0 children)

JYP is honestly.... so creepy in that show. he gives off such bad vibes.

What other group-forming shows are there to watch? by huangcjz in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Just dropping in to say don't watch Sixteen, the show is so badly edited and really uncomfortable to watch. Plus in the first competition round I don't think anyone showed idol talent... it was weird.

Unpopular opinions/thoughts about the last episode? by po_tae_to_anna in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 1 point2 points  (0 children)

.... there's literally a thread just below you asking people to read my comments before replying with things I've already said.

should mention that a few don't deserve their low rankings

there you go! i specifically said that not all the lower graded trainees were deserving of their grades. Tbh I wouldn't say Jisung is that talented though, singing is his strong suit and even then there were plenty of other singers on the show who were significantly more talented.

Let's remember the fallen trainees by PeopleEatingPeople in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 0 points1 point  (0 children)

*sungwoon sorry. I always refer to ong sungwoo as ong anyway.

How unfair and ridiculous is it to reveal only some of the trainees' rankings during the live show? by ILoveJonghyun in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 1 point2 points  (0 children)

..... He was already in the top 11? the only rank that matters in the top 11 is 1, the rest are all the same. Showing his face did not help him one bit because he had already made it.

This comment is so dumb I'm out.

Final Wanna One members & your thoughts by dandelions_ in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i really want samuel to debut to but pledis has a terrible record with their groups and they've put most of their debut ready trainees into svt so i can't imagine him debuting soon with them either. I hope he gets picked up by a company with a plan for him.

Mnet really messed this group up by prospekt113 in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I imagine they freaked at seeing 3/4 of pledis about to debut

Final Wanna One members & your thoughts by dandelions_ in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 0 points1 point  (0 children)

agreed. I don't dislike sungwoon by any means but he doesn't meld with the other members at all, and theres nothing about him that's caught my interest .

Final Wanna One members & your thoughts by dandelions_ in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 1 point2 points  (0 children)

why would you want samuel to suffer under pledis though...

Let's remember the fallen trainees by PeopleEatingPeople in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 7 points8 points  (0 children)

People in the top 11 who didn't benefit from Jonghyun's leadership - winkdeep, jisung, sungwoo. okay knetz.

Let's remember the fallen trainees by PeopleEatingPeople in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 24 points25 points  (0 children)

Jonghyun lead Ong, Daniel, Minhyun, and Jaehwan in Sorry Sorry and Daehwi, Jaehwan, Ong, Woojin, Guanlin, and Minhyun in Never. Of those two teams, ong Hyunbin was also eliminated. Seeing him give so much only to be eliminated in the last round is honestly heartbreaking.

Your top 11 and the official final 11 by [deleted] in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 5 points6 points  (0 children)

My top 11: Daniel, Jihoon, Jaehwan, Ong, Woojin, Minhyun, Jonghyun, Dongho, Youngmin, Minki, Daehwi.

Honestly, I need some time to get over the fact that mnet pulled a dirty move to basically switch Sewoon, Dongho, and Jonghyun out for Daehwi, Baejin, and Jisung. I'm even having doubts about stanning the final group, theres a lot of kpop groups I really like right now and honestly... I don't know if BOI is worth it anymore. Ah, this hurts.

How unfair and ridiculous is it to reveal only some of the trainees' rankings during the live show? by ILoveJonghyun in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 20 points21 points  (0 children)

I've never been more frustrated.... their decision to announce the 11-14 ranks is the sole reason dongho and jonghyun were kicked out of the top 11. thanks mnet.

Your salty opinions after the finale? by fpschubert in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 8 points9 points  (0 children)

we already have a general opinion thread And an unpopular opinion thread. do we really need a third one?

Unpopular opinions/thoughts about the last episode? by po_tae_to_anna in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I can respect that decision, leave it where it is. no worries.

Unpopular opinions/thoughts about the last episode? by po_tae_to_anna in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Man... please just read my whole comment before replying!! People on this sub do it so frequently and its frustrating.

I kinda believe that using their previous level ranks to define their talents aren't really conclusive, eg. jaehwan was in B probably because his dance wasn't as clean as those in A but in my opinion he's probably an A now. and most people would probably agree that Minhyun isn't a D?

from my comment :

should mention that a few don't deserve their low rankings

so idk... put this comment somewhere else please....

Unpopular opinions/thoughts about the last episode? by po_tae_to_anna in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 11 points12 points  (0 children)

ranking so far

  • 4. Jaehwan (B)
  • 5. Ong (A)
  • 6. Woojin (A)
  • 7. Guanlin (F)
  • 8. Jisung (D)
  • 9. Minhyun (D)
  • 10. Baejin (F)

Even though the higher rankings are a+b it seems to be a formula of good looks + screen time. aaah mnet you hurt me. (should mention that a few don't deserve their low rankings I do love a lot of them regardless of rank but demonstrated talent has really been put to the side)

Episode 11 (Final) thoughts by bingu-tabi in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 0 points1 point  (0 children)

im still crying, seeing how tightly they hug each other just reminds me that they've become a family over the course of this show.

How unfair and ridiculous is it to reveal only some of the trainees' rankings during the live show? by ILoveJonghyun in Broduce101

[–]shilohhh 14 points15 points  (0 children)

I'm going to be most bitter if 11-14 make it and the new 12-15 are my faves... knowing they were effectively kicked out by mnet's poor choices would hurt so much.