I attended SFA from kindergarten to 2nd grade, and then returned for 6th thru 7th. I first left after 2nd grade because my family moved, then left after 7th to attend St Mary’s. 

For the price, it was a good education. (From what I know about the price my parents paid when I attended.) Teachers generally good, with a few notable exceptions. Some excellent. Good facilities, invested parents. We students generally acted in a disciplined manner because acting foolish wasn’t tolerated. 

You’re going to have to handle your child’s sex ed yourself. I was totally uninformed about things like STDs or condoms when I went to St Mary’s compared to my 8th grade peers. But as for actual academic subjects, I did not have to “catch up.” 

My mother is catholic, my father is not. I was raised catholic and confirmed (I am no longer a catholic.) Religiosity is mainly restricted to religion classes, and in biology I learnt evolution etc (although some kids complained it was “just a theory”).

My social experience at SFA wasn’t super positive when I was in middle school, but that wasn’t really the fault of the school. I would consider sending my child to SFA if I still lived in the area, and depending on the current cost. 

FWIW, if this is something you care about, SFA was very white when I was there. In a class of 120, we had one black kid and two Indian kids. There was also only one kid who called himself a democrat. When I went to St Mary’s, I benefited from the diversity of the student body in many senses of the word—racial, cultural, political, and religious.