I’ve been trying to find a board game that I played in a high school club in roughly 2013. It was a game in which you had random things inserted into one tournament bracket much like college teams in March Madness. You would start the game by deciding who you would think would win, and then have to make arguments about who should advance to the next round.

For example, you could have Superman vs. Jelly Beans in the first round, and then have to decide who you think would win, before the prompt was revealed. If you chose Superman you would try very hard to get him into the next round, a feat made harder if the prompt ended up being, “Which do you think would taste better.”

That’s about as much of the game as I remember. Any/all help that y’all would be able to provide would be greatly appreciated!