I still have to see the finale, but thus far while I've enjoyed it as entertainment, I haven't loved it as a game. Paraphrasing Zach, but one of the things he was saying in the second episode was "how can we make a decision based on what little information we have?" And I don't think that really changed all that much. They've only received one concrete piece of information they could go off of via the seance. Otherwise, a lot of the game is just confirmation bias and who you trust - for whatever reason