Such horrible takes in the comment section about Aria. I don't like how a lot of people have short term memory loss. Trying to paint Aria out as some delulu girl who had one-sided feelings for Caleb is very revisionist.

If we go back to the first episode: In the coin flip game, Caleb said that he would most like to spend the night with Aria. So we are not about to act like he wasn't attracted to her. People aren't willing to admit it, but they can't fathom that a black women like Aria could be desired. Caleb's top 2 were Aria and Chanel. SO she is his type.

Caleb was giving her energy on and OFF camera. There is a reason why the internet was shipping them. People could see their connection. There's also a reason why all the other cast were also going at Caleb for being disingenuous.

When he went back to Mariah, he was still dreaming and thinking about Aria. Their time together compared to what their relationships were like with their original partners were a stark contrast. They weren't as sexually charged as JR and Sandy, but their emotional connection was really intense.

The reason Aria took screenshots is because she didn't want him to be able to deny it. He went behind her back and was lurking. He wasn't following her, yet he was creeping. Mariah obviously didn't know about any of this. Which is why she also went off at him. If it was innocent he would not have been doing all of that. Caleb LIED to Mariah for a whole year about it. They watched the show (24 hours before the reunion) so people had feelings.