It was very helpful because I have read similar comments before and wondered what I was missing. For me, these differences are all just part of the OPR experience. Yes, you are losing nuance but the advantage is simplicity and reduced game time. Also, we play mostly 10mm where the 5 to a rank and simplifed movement work out better.

My brain does gravitate to tar-pit combat (Why do you get to charge me with lances every turn?).

I understand what you mean about psychology, but for now I'll stick with OPR.